The organizers were either negligent or victims of a controversy that had grown with time.
There was very little room for the uncomfortable truth that more than one person could have failed, and that acknowledging one person's responsibility did not erase another's.
Marcus entered the office and found Derek staring at the screen.
“Put it away.”
“I was reading the article.”
“You've read it three times.”
“People are saying things about Samuel.”
“People say things about everyone.”
“They're blaming him for not walking out.”
Marcus leaned against the desk.
“Did he walk out?”
“No.”
“Does he regret it?”
“Yes.”
“Then he knows that part of the story. You don't have to defend him against every stranger who discovers it.”
Derek put the phone down, though his fingers remained close to it.
“What if people get the wrong idea?”
Marcus gave him a tired look.
“You mean, what if they judge him unfairly?”
“Yes.”
“Then he can answer for himself. What you need to decide is whether you're going to make this about protecting a man you admire or about understanding what he actually did.”
Derek frowned.
“Those aren't the same thing?”
“Not always.”
Marcus sat opposite him.
“When you were competing, you treated every criticism like an attack. If someone said you were reckless, you looked for a way to prove you were brave. If someone said you were arrogant, you found another victory to hold over them. You were always looking for the counterattack.”
“I know.”
“Do you? Because I've watched you spend the last week trying to correct people's opinions about you. You want them to see your apology. You want them to notice the work you're doing. You want the association to restore your status.”
Derek looked away.
“Some of that is understandable,” Marcus continued. “But you keep confusing being accountable with being understood.”
The words stung because they were true.
Derek had told himself he no longer cared about the comments beneath the video. Yet every time someone called him a bully, he felt the urge to explain his history, his training, his achievements, and the things he had done for people who had never seen the clip.
He wanted context.
He wanted fairness.
He wanted the world to acknowledge that he was more than his worst moment.
But Natalie had never been given the luxury of deciding how millions of strangers would interpret what happened to her. She had simply been the woman trapped in his arms while he ignored her attempt to get away.
The internet had turned her fear into a spectacle.
Derek had helped create that spectacle.
He could not demand that everyone now watch him become a better man.
“I don't know how to stop caring what people think,” he admitted.
Marcus nodded.
“Good. That's an honest answer. Start there.”
Later that afternoon, Derek went to the community center. He wasn't scheduled to help, but Elena had asked whether he could repair a loose section of padding along the wall.
He found Samuel in the equipment room, examining a box of worn gloves.
“Have you seen the article?” Derek asked.
“Yes.”
“People are arguing about you.”
“I noticed.”
“Doesn't it bother you?”
Samuel held up a glove with a split seam.
“Of course it bothers me.”
Derek had expected him to deny it.
Samuel continued, “I spent a long time believing that if I remained silent, I would avoid making the situation worse. Then I spent another long time believing that silence was the only punishment I deserved. Neither belief helped Michael.”
“What will you do now?”
“Tell the truth. Correct what I know is wrong. Admit what I got wrong myself.”
“And if people still blame you?”
“Some will.”
Derek searched his face for a hint of bitterness.
“That's it?”
“What else would you have me do?”
“Defend yourself.”
“I will defend myself when the facts require it. I won't invent a version of myself that never made mistakes.”
Samuel placed the glove back in the box.
“You're asking me how to survive being misunderstood. I think you should ask yourself why you need everyone to understand you before you can change.”
Derek fell silent.
A moment later, Samuel handed him a roll of athletic tape.
“The padding along the wall needs fixing.”
Derek looked at the tape.
“You're giving me a lecture and then assigning me chores?”
“I'm giving you a job. The lecture was free.”
Despite himself, Derek laughed.
They worked for nearly an hour. Samuel held the padding in place while Derek replaced the damaged fasteners. They spoke only when necessary.
For Derek, the silence became its own kind of lesson. There was no audience to impress and no one to congratulate him when the repair was finished. The wall was simply safer than it had been before.
As they packed away the tools, Samuel's phone rang.
The caller was Adrian.
Samuel listened without speaking for a long time.
Then he said, “When?”
Another pause.
“All right. I'll come.”
He ended the call.
“What happened?” Derek asked.
“Michael has heard about the review. Someone contacted him and suggested that he should publicly blame Adrian if he wants the association to admit what happened.”
Derek felt anger rise in his chest.
“Who would do that?”
“Someone who believes the story needs a villain more than it needs the truth.”
“Is Michael going to make a statement?”
“He hasn't decided.”
Samuel placed the phone in his pocket.
“He asked Adrian to visit him tomorrow. He wants the three of us there.”
“Do you think Adrian will go?”
Samuel looked at him.
“He'll go.”
“How do you know?”
“Because he's spent twenty-eight years avoiding the conversation he needs most.”
Derek thought about the restaurant. About Natalie, who had been forced into a conversation she never wanted to have. About the way he had treated her refusal as an obstacle instead of an answer.
He had spent the weeks afterward hoping that one apology could open a door.
But a door could not be opened from the other side simply because the person waiting outside believed he deserved a chance.
“What if Michael doesn't forgive him?” Derek asked.
Samuel turned off the equipment-room light.
“Then Adrian will have to learn how to live without forgiveness being the price of doing the right thing.”
The words followed Derek all the way home.
That night, he drafted a message to Natalie.
He wrote that he hoped she was doing well. He wrote that he had been thinking about the harm he had caused. He wrote that he understood if she never wanted to speak to him.
Then he deleted it.
Not because the words were insincere, but because he finally recognized that sending them might be another way of asking Natalie to participate in his transformation.
He did not need her to tell him he was improving.
He needed to improve whether she ever knew it or not.
He closed the message window and turned off his phone.
For the first time since the video went viral, he went to bed without checking what strangers were saying about him.