He thought about the storage cabinet near the workbench, the one where the six taped packages had been found. He had built that cabinet himself, years earlier, to hold finishes and hardware and spare parts. He opened it every day. He knew what was inside it: cans of stain, boxes of screws, sandpaper, glue, the small things a cabinet maker reaches for without thinking. He had opened it the day before, and it had held only his own supplies. Now it held six sealed packages wrapped in brown paper, and he did not know how they had gotten there, or when, or who had carried them through his garage door in the middle of the night. Someone had been in his house, in the room where he worked, and he had not heard them. He had slept through it. The lock had not stopped them.
Ethan stayed on his knees on the wet grass and tried to think. He thought about the night before, and how ordinary it had been. He had finished a cabinet in the workshop, washed his hands, locked the garage door from the inside wall control, and gone to bed. Leah had been in her room. The house had been quiet. He had slept deeply and without waking, and now he was on his knees in his own front yard with plastic around his wrists while officers searched his workshop for things he had never seen. He tried to hold on to the ordinary facts of the night before, because they were the only facts he had. He had locked the door. He had gone to bed. He had been asleep.
He could hear them inside the workshop now, their boots on the concrete floor, their voices low and businesslike. He heard a cabinet door opening, and then something heavy being set down on his workbench. Every sound was a sound he knew, but the hands making them were not his hands. He had built that workbench with his own tools. He knew the smell of the sawdust and the oil. And now strangers were moving through it with flashlights, opening his storage cabinet and lifting out packages that did not belong to him, and there was nothing he could do but kneel in the wet grass and listen.
Leah had been moved to the driveway, and the female officer stood beside her, saying something Ethan could not hear. Leah nodded, and then she looked toward Ethan, and her face was pale in the flashing light. Ethan wanted to go to her. He wanted to tell her that it would be all right, that this was a mistake and that someone would see it was a mistake. But his hands were bound, and an officer stood beside him, and he could not go to her. He could only meet her eyes across the driveway and nod, a small nod, the only reassurance he had to give.
The neighbors were still on their porches. Ethan could see them in the gaps between the police vehicles, standing in their robes with their phones held up. He knew most of them by name. He had built cabinets for some of them. He had waved to them from his driveway for years. Now they were filming him on his knees, and he understood that by the end of the day, the video would be everywhere, and the people who watched it would not know his name or his work or his daughter. They would know only the picture: a man on his knees in front of his own house, in the red and blue light, with his hands tied. The picture would travel faster than any explanation ever could.