That mattered.
If Sullivan's conduct was appropriate, Elijah's occupation was irrelevant.
If it wasn't appropriate, Elijah's occupation was still irrelevant.
Sullivan pointed toward the curb.
"Sit."
Elijah looked at the concrete.
"I would prefer to stand."
"I didn't ask what you prefer."
"My knee makes sitting that low difficult."
Sullivan stepped closer.
"Sit down."
Grant intervened again.
"Dan, he's seventy-two."
"I heard him."
Elijah remained standing.
Sullivan grabbed his jacket again.
This time Elijah's voice changed.
"Remove your hand."
Sullivan froze.
The elderly man's voice was still quiet.
But suddenly it carried the unmistakable authority of someone accustomed to being heard in rooms where words had consequences.
Sullivan released him.
"What exactly do you do, Mr. Carter?"
Elijah reached slowly toward the inside pocket of his jacket.
Sullivan's posture stiffened.
"Hands!"
Elijah stopped.
"My identification is inside my jacket."
"What identification?"
Elijah looked directly at him.
"The kind you should probably see."
CHAPTER 5 — THE CREDENTIAL
Officer Grant stepped closer.
"I'll retrieve it."
Elijah nodded.
"Inside pocket. Left side."
Grant carefully removed a black leather credential holder.
She opened it.
Then stopped breathing for what seemed like several seconds.
Her eyes moved from the identification to Elijah.
Then back again.
"Sir..."
Sullivan frowned.
"What?"
Grant didn't answer.
She handed him the credential.
Sullivan looked down.
At first, confusion.
Then recognition.
Then disbelief.
The identification bore Elijah's photograph, full name, and official title.
ASSOCIATE JUSTICE
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.
For the purposes of this fictional story, Elijah Carter occupied one of the Court's nine seats—the real Court is composed of a Chief Justice and eight Associate Justices.
Sullivan looked up.
Then down again.
The crowd had become completely silent.
"You're..."
Elijah waited.
"A Supreme Court Justice?"
"Yes."
Sullivan took one step backward.
His face had lost its color.
"Why didn't you tell me?"
Elijah studied him.
It was the same question he had expected.
And it revealed the problem more clearly than anything else Sullivan had said.
"Why should that have mattered?"
Sullivan stared.
"I mean... obviously..."
"Obviously what?"
"You're a federal judge."
"Yes."
"I would've—"
Sullivan stopped.
Elijah finished the sentence for him.
"You would have treated me differently."
"No. That's not what I meant."
"Then what did you mean?"
Sullivan couldn't answer.
Elijah took his credential from him.
He closed the leather case.
Then he looked toward Grant.
"Officer, am I free to leave?"
Grant looked at Sullivan.
Elijah noticed.
"Don't look at him. I'm asking you whether there is a lawful reason I'm still being detained."
Grant swallowed.
"No, sir."
"Thank you."
Sullivan suddenly spoke.
"Justice Carter, I think there's been a misunderstanding."
Elijah opened his car door.
"No."
Sullivan stopped.
Elijah looked back at him.
"A misunderstanding is when two people interpret the same words differently."
His eyes moved toward Rachel and the other witnesses.
"This was recorded."
Sullivan followed his gaze.
For the first time, he noticed all the phones.
Elijah continued.
"So I suspect there will be very little misunderstanding."
Then he entered his car.
But before closing the door, he looked at Sullivan once more.
"Officer?"
"Yes, sir?"
"Five minutes ago, you weren't calling me sir."
Sullivan said nothing.
Elijah closed the door.
And drove away.
CHAPTER 6 — THE VIDEO
By the time Elijah reached Washington, the video had already begun spreading online.
Rachel uploaded only four minutes.
That was enough.
It showed Sullivan confronting Elijah.
It showed the officer grabbing his jacket.
Most importantly, it captured the sentence:
"People like you don't get to disobey orders."
Then it captured the aftermath.
Grant opening the credential.
Sullivan's expression changing.
The question:
"Why didn't you tell me?"
And Elijah's answer:
"Why should that have mattered?"
News organizations began calling Milfield Police Department that evening.
The department released a short statement saying it was reviewing a traffic stop involving one of its officers.
Elijah's chambers received dozens of media requests.
He declined all of them.
His law clerk, Naomi Brooks, entered his office carrying a tablet.
"Justice Carter, you should probably see how big this has become."
"I've seen enough."
"It's everywhere."
"That doesn't make it more useful."
Naomi placed the tablet down.
"People want a statement."
Elijah removed his glasses.
"What statement?"
"Anything."
"Anything is usually the worst thing to say."
Naomi smiled despite herself.
She had worked for Elijah long enough to recognize when he was using humor to conceal anger.
"Are you okay?"
Elijah looked toward the window.
Physically?
Yes.
But something about the afternoon had unsettled him.