Elias froze. "What are you talking about?"
Whitmore stepped toward the door, pausing on the threshold. "That water didn't disappear naturally twenty years ago, Carter. Drought didn't kill your pasture."
At those words, Naelli's expression changed. For the very first time since Elias had met her, the calm certainty vanished from her eyes. She looked afraid.
Whitmore caught the shift in her demeanor and smiled wickedly. "Ah. So she hasn't told you."
Elias turned frantically toward his wife. "Told me what, Naelli?"
Naelli's hand slowly closed around the turquoise pendant, her knuckles turning white. She couldn't meet his gaze.
Whitmore adjusted his hat. "Ask your wife who owned this valley before your father did, Carter. Ask her why the earth went dry."
Chapter Five: The Buried Truth
Silence descended on the parlor, heavier than the summer heat. Whitmore's footsteps echoed on the porch, followed by the creak of his carriage springs and the crack of the driver’s whip.
Elias felt his stomach tighten into a hard knot. He looked at Naelli, who was staring fixedly at the floorboards.
"What is he talking about, Naelli?" Elias asked, his voice trembling.
Naelli slowly lifted her head. She looked out the window toward the restored creek, watching the water flow over the willow branches. Then, she turned to him and whispered, "Your father didn't buy all of this land, Elias."
Elias felt the blood drain from his face. "What? Of course he did. He showed me the deeds. He traded with the territory bank."
"There is something beneath the northern pasture," Naelli continued, her voice devoid of its usual warmth, sounding hollow and distant.
"What is it?" Elias demanded, stepping closer.
Naelli looked directly into his eyes, and the sheer weight of her sorrow pinned him to the floor. "Something your father buried. More than twenty years ago."
Outside, Whitmore’s carriage was rolling away, but before it passed the gates, the wealthy investor leaned out the window and called back, his voice carrying over the wind: "Dig beneath the old cottonwood, Carter! But you may wish you'd taken my money once you discover what your family did to hers."
The carriage disappeared in a cloud of dust.
Elias stood motionless. His mind reeled, trying to reconcile the memory of his hardworking, honorable father with the venom in Whitmore's words and the fear in his wife's eyes. For weeks, he had believed Naelli had come to Wyoming simply because of an arranged marriage, a desperate pact between distant families.
Now, he wasn't certain anymore. The foundation of everything he knew was cracking beneath his feet.
He turned toward her, his voice barely a breath. "Did you know my father, Naelli?"
Her dark eyes filled with a glistening sheen of tears—a grief Elias had never seen her display. "No," she said softly. She paused, the silence stretching between them. "But my father did."
That evening, the sun sank below the horizon, painting the sky in bruised hues of purple and deep red. Elias did not eat. He went to the tool shed, grabbed a heavy iron shovel and a lantern, and walked out into the gathering dark. He headed straight for the oldest cottonwood tree on the property—a massive, twisted giant that stood at the edge of the northern pasture, its roots plunging deep into the earth.
Naelli walked silently beside him, carrying a second lantern. Neither of them spoke. The only sound was the crunch of their boots on the dry grass and the distant murmur of the new spring.
When they reached the base of the massive tree, Elias hung his lantern on a low branch. He stripped off his coat, rolled up his sleeves, and drove the shovel into the dirt between two massive, gnarled roots.
He dug for nearly an hour. The earth was compacted and filled with rocks, but he swung the heavy iron blade with a desperate, frantic energy. He had to know. He had to understand what poison lay beneath his family's legacy.
Suddenly, the metal blade of the shovel struck something hard. It did not make the dull thud of hitting a rock. It made a sharp, hollow clank.
Metal.
Elias dropped to his knees, his hands tearing at the loose dirt. Naelli knelt beside him, her slender fingers helping to clear away the soil.
Buried deep beneath the protective embrace of the cottonwood roots was a heavy, rusted iron box. Elias grabbed the heavy iron handles and, with a massive grunt of effort, heaved it out of the hole, dropping it onto the grass.
He brushed the dirt from the top of the lid. Even in the dim, flickering light of the lantern, he could see the engravings cut into the rusted iron. There were two names etched side-by-side.
One belonged to Thomas Carter. Elias's father.
The other name was carved in a different script, an Apache name.