She shook her head.
"No."
He nodded.
"That's all right."
For several moments, she stared at the bird.
Then asked, "Do you think my father is alive?"
Eli felt pain.
He could not answer honestly with certainty.
He did not know.
He looked toward her.
"I hope so."
Nalin swallowed.
"Me too."
She leaned against the barn wall.
For a while, neither spoke.
Then Eli asked, "Would you like to tell Ketan what you remember?"
Nalin hesitated.
"Maybe."
"Only when you're ready."
She looked up.
For a moment, her eyes filled.
Then she whispered, "Thank you."
Eli nodded.
He rose.
Before leaving, he looked toward the wooden quail.
"Your father taught you well."
Nalin smiled through tears.
"He did."
Later, Eli told Ketan that Nalin wanted to speak about the attack.
He did not repeat every detail without asking Nalin first.
Ketan respected that.
She visited the girl.
They spoke privately.
Afterward, Ketan approached Eli.
Her expression was serious.
"She remembers Miller."
He nodded.
"Yes."
"And the man with the ring."
Eli considered.
"I saw a similar ring today."
Ketan looked sharply toward him.
"Who?"
"Rourke."
For a moment, she froze.
Then closed her eyes.
Eli continued.
"That doesn't prove he was there."
Ketan nodded slowly.
"I know."
"But it gives Margaret something to ask about."
She looked toward the dark road.
For several seconds, neither spoke.
Then Ketan said, "My brother may still be alive."
Eli turned.
"Your brother?"
She nodded.
"His name is Toma."
The rancher waited.
"He helped people escape through the northern pass. I haven't seen him since."
She looked toward Black Tooth Ridge.
"I don't know whether he was captured."
Eli considered.
Then spoke quietly.
"We should tell Margaret and Dr. Ross. Perhaps someone has heard from the people who scattered."
Ketan nodded.
For a moment, hope flickered across her face.
Then vanished beneath caution.
She had already lost too much to trust rumors easily.
Eli understood.
He looked toward the mountains.
If Toma lived, finding him would require more than courage.
It would require information.
And people willing to investigate despite the pressure Rourke exerted on the district.
The rancher took a breath.
For years, he avoided the world because he believed it had nothing left to offer him.
Now he found himself preparing to enter its troubles.
Not for glory.
Not for revenge.
But because a girl wanted to know whether her father was alive.
And a woman wanted to find her brother.
Those seemed reasons enough.
Eli discovered Sarah's old letters during a storm.
A line of dark clouds crossed Black Tooth Ridge shortly after sunset, bringing wind and a brief downpour that drove everyone beneath shelter.
The rain was welcome.
But the cabin roof began leaking near the back wall.
Eli climbed into the loft to check the rafters.
While moving an old wooden chest, he found a small cloth bundle beneath a loose board.
He recognized the fabric.
Sarah used it to wrap letters and photographs.
For several seconds, he stared.
Then carried the bundle downstairs.
He sat at the kitchen table.
The sound of rain filled the room.
He untied the cloth.
Inside lay six letters.
Three were addressed to her sister in Texas.
Two to an old friend.
The final one bore Eli's name.
He stared.
For a moment, he considered putting them away.
He had avoided reading Sarah's personal papers after she died.
The grief was too sharp.
But now, with people sleeping safely in the barn and rain washing the dust from the yard, he felt ready to hear her voice again.
He opened the letter.
My dear Eli,
I know you believe a man proves his love by keeping danger away from everyone under his roof.
Eli smiled sadly.
That sounded like Sarah.
She had often challenged his belief that protecting people meant controlling every risk.
He continued reading.
But sometimes love asks us to open the door rather than close it.
His throat tightened.
The letter had been written years before her death.
She described helping a family traveling through Texas when their wagon broke down.
Eli remembered the incident.
He had been away moving cattle.
Sarah offered food and shelter until their repairs were complete.
When he returned, she told him about it.
He worried they had taken advantage of her.
She laughed.
Then reminded him that ordinary decency was not the same as foolishness.
The letter continued.
You are a good man, Eli. But you carry fear like a rifle you never set down. I hope one day you discover that being careful and being kind can live in the same heart.
He stopped reading.
For several seconds, he stared toward the rain.
Then returned to the page.
If anything ever happens to me, I don't want your life to become a shrine to what you lost.
His eyes filled.
Remember me. Remember our boy. But keep living.
He closed his eyes.
The words hurt almost physically.
Sarah had understood him better than he understood himself.
Even before her death, she knew that grief might make him retreat.
She had tried to leave something to guide him back.
He looked toward the barn.
Light glowed beneath the doors.
Someone laughed.
A child called for her mother.
Then quiet singing drifted through the rain.
Eli felt a sudden wave of sorrow.
He wished Sarah could hear it.
Wished Thomas could run outside to play with Nalin.
Wished the years they lost could be restored.
They could not.
But the letter offered something he had not expected.
Permission.
Not to forget.
To continue.
He wiped his eyes.
Then folded the page carefully.
A knock sounded.
"Eli?"
Ketan.
He looked toward the door.
"Come in."
She entered carrying a bucket.
"Water is coming through the barn roof."
He stood immediately.
"How bad?"
"Only one corner. We moved the bedding."
He nodded.
"Good."
She noticed the papers on the table.
Then his expression.
"Are you all right?"
Eli hesitated.
For years, his answer had always been yes.
Whether he meant it or not.
Now he considered telling the truth.
He looked toward Sarah's letter.
Then back.
"Found something from my wife."
Ketan's expression softened.
"Good memory?"
He took a breath.
"Painful one."