Naya seemed to understand that she had stepped onto dangerous ground.
"I do not say she was murdered," she replied carefully. "I say there are questions that were never answered."
Elias turned away.
Beyond the corral, the morning sun had climbed above the eastern hills. The valley looked almost peaceful now. The hundreds of Apache riders had vanished into the ridges, leaving only scattered hoofprints and the lingering smell of dust.
He wished they had never come.
He wished Naya had never appeared beside his fence.
Most of all, he wished he could return to the previous afternoon, when a stranger needed water and nothing more.
Taza approached slowly.
"Mercer, my daughter has traveled far and lost much to bring this information."
"Then she should tell me what she knows."
"She will."
Elias faced him.
"All of it."
Taza considered him for a moment.
Then he nodded.
"All that she knows."
They moved into the cabin.
It was a small building, constructed from pine logs and reinforced with stone around the chimney. A narrow kitchen occupied one side, while the other held a table, two chairs, a bed behind a curtain, and a bookshelf containing more volumes than most ranchers considered necessary.
Naya noticed the books immediately.
Her eyes traveled across their spines before settling on a framed photograph above the mantel.
A young woman stood beside Elias beneath a flowering apple tree.
Clara.
She wore a pale dress and smiled with the unguarded happiness of someone who had not yet learned how abruptly life could change.
Naya studied the photograph without touching it.
"She was beautiful," she said.
Elias placed the map on the table.
"She was."
He did not trust himself to say more.
Taza remained near the door while the two younger warriors took positions outside. Naya sat carefully, suppressing a grimace as her wounded side touched the chair.
Elias noticed.
"That bandage needs changing."
"It can wait."
"No, it can't."
She opened her mouth to argue, but he was already retrieving the medical supplies from the cupboard.
"Whatever this is about, you won't explain it any better after bleeding all over my floor."
For the first time since the sheriff's departure, she almost smiled.
"Do you always speak this way to guests?"
"Only the ones who arrive with an army."
He set clean cloth and boiled water beside her.
Naya tended the wound herself while Elias turned toward the window.
When she finished, he returned to the table.
"Now," he said, "tell me about Whitcomb."
Naya unfolded the map.
"Thomas Whitcomb was a surveyor employed to examine the old mining claims north of San Rosario. He had been working for a federal land office, though some of his assignments were paid for by private companies."
"Varrick's company?"
"At first."
She pointed to the abandoned silver road.
"Whitcomb discovered that the old mining maps were wrong. The miners believed they had found three separate underground springs. He found evidence that the water came from one large channel beneath the valley."
Elias leaned closer.
The map showed a rough outline of the mountains, the dry creek, and several old mining shafts. Three crosses had been drawn in dark ink.
"That doesn't explain Clara."
"No. But Whitcomb also found records from four years ago."
Elias felt a chill.
"What records?"
"Reports of sickness among families living near the southern creek. Dead livestock. Strange deposits in the water. A doctor was called to examine several people."
"Doctor Harlan," Elias said.
Naya nodded.
"Yes."
The name brought back a memory Elias had not considered in years.
Doctor Samuel Harlan had arrived at the ranch two days before Clara died. He had examined her, prescribed medicine, and warned Elias that the fever was dangerous.
He had also taken a sample of water from the kitchen barrel.
Elias remembered watching him fill a small glass bottle.
At the time, it had seemed unimportant.
"Why would he take water?" Elias murmured.
Naya heard him.
"Because he suspected the illness was not ordinary fever."
Elias sat down heavily.
The chair creaked beneath him.
"Where is Harlan now?"
"Dead."
The word struck like a hammer.
"When?"
"Three months after your wife."
Elias remembered hearing about the doctor's death. A carriage accident on the road to Santa Fe. Terrible weather, a broken wheel, and a body found at the bottom of a ravine.
Nobody had questioned it.
Nobody had questioned anything.
Naya reached into her pouch and removed a narrow strip of paper.
"Whitcomb found this in an old county archive."
She slid it across the table.
The handwriting was cramped but legible.
Patient C.M. β severe abdominal pain, fever, weakness. Symptoms inconsistent with common seasonal infection. Possible contamination from household water source. Further examination required.
Below the entry appeared a date.
Four days before Clara died.
Elias read the words three times.
Then he looked at Naya.
"Where is the rest?"
"Missing."
"Who removed it?"
"We do not know."