Ruth was furious. “They call it drainage. I call it a way to frighten us into selling.”
Daniel examined the cut. “We'll photograph it and ask Pike to send someone.”
“By the time he comes, the next storm will be here.”
Isabel studied the slope. “We can build a temporary bank tonight. If we place the stones here and leave an overflow gap farther down, the water will reach the creek without crossing your well.”
The Bennetts agreed. Neighbors arrived with shovels, wagons, and timber. They worked until sunset, building a small diversion that protected the house without flooding the next field. It was not elegant, but it held when a brief shower passed after dark. Ruth watched the water flow into the creek and wiped her eyes with the back of her hand.
“Thank you,” she said. “I was beginning to think nobody could help.”
Daniel shook his head. “You helped build it.”
The following morning Isabel discovered that one of the water association's maps had disappeared from the schoolhouse. A window latch had been forced, and the drawer containing the copies stood open. The original measurements were safe at the ranch, but the theft showed that someone wanted to know which families had contributed evidence. Sheriff Pike arranged for the records to be kept in three separate locations. He also warned the association not to travel alone after dark.
That evening a rider brought a message from Garrick Vane. He claimed he was willing to testify against Hale in exchange for safe passage out of the county. He requested a meeting at an old chapel beside the river, just after midnight. Daniel read the message twice and set it down.
“It's a trap,” he said.
“Maybe,” Isabel answered. “But Vane knows who ordered Samuel taken.”
“We don't have to go alone.”
They showed the message to Pike. The sheriff proposed that he and two deputies approach the chapel from the east while Daniel and Isabel waited at the main road. If Vane truly wished to surrender, he could do so in the presence of officers. If he planned an ambush, the group would have enough witnesses to prevent a false account of what happened.
The chapel stood among cottonwoods beside a narrow bend in the river. Its roof had partly collapsed, and the bell was gone. At midnight a single lantern burned inside. Pike signaled for Daniel and Isabel to remain behind a stone wall while he entered with a deputy.
A voice called from the dark. “Only the woman. She has the notebook.”
Pike answered that no one would approach without his permission. A shot cracked from the far bank. The lantern shattered. Daniel pushed Isabel down behind the wall as another bullet struck the stones. The deputies returned fire toward the muzzle flashes, and the attackers retreated through the trees.
When the shooting stopped, Pike found Vane inside the chapel, wounded in the shoulder. He had not fired the first shot. A second man lay unconscious near the door, struck by falling timber when the lantern broke. Vane was pale and frightened, but alive.
“They meant to kill me,” he gasped. “Hale said he'd protect me if I brought her here.”
“Who fired?” Pike demanded.
“Men from the pumping crew. They were supposed to frighten her, not shoot me.”
Isabel stepped forward despite Daniel's warning. “Why did you take Samuel?”
Vane closed his eyes. “Hale ordered it. He said the surveyor had stolen confidential plans. I believed him at first. Then I saw the contract. They wanted the valley's water, and Ortega knew how to prove it.”
“Will you say that under oath?” Pike asked.
Vane looked toward the broken doorway. “If you keep me alive.”
The sheriff arranged to take him to the county jail under guard. The wounded man was not forgiven for what he had done, but his testimony could help expose those who had paid him. Isabel felt no satisfaction in seeing him hurt. She felt only exhaustion and the knowledge that the conflict had reached a point where even the company's enforcers feared one another.
On the ride home, Daniel noticed that Isabel had gone quiet. He asked whether she was frightened. She nodded.
“I used to think finding Samuel would end this,” she said. “Then I thought showing the pumping agreement would end it. Every answer opens another danger.”
“That may be true for a while,” Daniel said. “But the answers also bring people to our side.”
“What if someone dies before the law catches up?”
He did not offer a false promise. “Then we'll have to live with what we could and couldn't prevent. But I won't stop trying to keep you safe.”
She looked at him beneath the stars. “I don't want you to carry that alone either.”
They reached the ranch shortly before dawn. Lucy had left a lamp burning in the kitchen, and Peter had fallen asleep in a chair beside the stove. The sight of the familiar room moved Isabel more than she expected. Daniel put the horses away while she covered Peter with a blanket.
When Daniel returned, she was standing at the window. The eastern sky was turning pale. She told him that she wanted to remain at Juniper Hollow after the hearings, if there was work for her and if the household would welcome her. He answered that there would always be maps to draw and fences to repair, but that he hoped she would stay for reasons beyond either.
She stepped closer. “I think I already have those reasons.”
He kissed her gently, giving her time to move away. She did not. The kiss was not a rescue and not a bargain. It was a choice made by two people who had learned that care could be offered without demanding surrender.
At breakfast Sheriff Pike sent a final note: Vane had signed a preliminary statement naming Hale and identifying the men who had altered the drainage channels. The county attorney had requested an emergency hearing on the pumping permit. Silver Crown would have to answer questions in public.