It was an old State Bureau of Criminal Investigation Special Investigator badgeâworn smooth along the outer points by thirty-four years of friction against leather and wool, its serial number stamped in small, sharp block digits at the base: BCI-042.
Keller held the wallet up between two fingers, letting the afternoon sun catch the dull brass, and gave Elias a crooked, mocking grin.
âWhoâd you steal this badge from, old man?â
Several feet away near the guardrail, Pike let out a soft, breathy smirk, shifting his heavy weight from one foot to the other.
Elias made no move to take the wallet back. He didn't reach out, he didn't step forward, and he didn't raise his voice by a single fraction of a decibel.
âIt belongs to me,â Elias said quietly.
Keller stared at him for another long moment, his eyes scanning the quiet, lined face before him, searching for a twitch, a swallow, or the telltale blink of an old pretender caught in a lie. Finding none, he simply let out a sharp, dismissive laugh that sounded like dry leaves scraping across concrete.
He turned his attention back to the interior pockets of the wallet.
That was when he noticed the money.
Elias had taken out cash before leaving his small home in Zanesville that morning. His daughter was having major repairs done to her roof and porch after a summer storm, and heâd promised to help cover the contractorâs initial material deposit so she wouldn't have to break into her savings. The bills were crisp, stacked neatly in two distinct, paper-banded bundles.
Keller removed the top stack. He counted the bills quickly with his thumb, his movements expert, practiced, and unhurried.
Ten hundred-dollar bills.
One thousand dollars.
Elias watched in silence as Keller folded the ten hundred-dollar bills once, tucked them smoothly into the left chest pocket of his own uniform shirt, and buttoned the flap down tight.
Still, Elias said nothing.
Pike remained silent too, his eyes darting once toward the oncoming traffic before returning to his partner.
For several endless seconds, the only sounds along that lonely stretch of Interstate 70 were the high-pitched whine of semi-trucks speeding past in the far lane and the low, mechanical idle of the cruiserâs V8 engine behind them.
Keller leaned his face closer to Elias, his breath carrying the faint, stale scent of cold coffee and chewing tobacco.
âConsider this a highway usage assessment, grandpa,â Keller whispered, his voice dropping into a low, nasty purr that barely carried over the wind. âYouâre driving an unsafe vehicle across county lines. We could impound this heap right now. We could write you three different citations thatâd take you six months of court dates to fix. Or we can just consider ourselves square.â
Elias looked directly into Kellerâs eyes. He didn't look at his pocket, he didn't look at his stolen money, and he didn't look at the cruiser behind them.
âYouâre making a very serious mistake, Officer,â Elias said. His tone wasn't threatening; it was flat, informative, and as cold as river water in January.
Kellerâs grin vanished instantly, replaced by a dark, ugly flare of irritation.
âIs that right?â Keller sneered. He closed the brown leather wallet with a sharp snap, tossed it dismissively over his shoulder, and watched as it landed face-down in the dirty gravel beside Eliasâs front tire.
The worn leather hit the rocks with a soft thud.
âPick it up,â Keller ordered, pointing a gloved finger down at the dust. âPick up your trash and get back in your truck before I decide youâre resisting.â
Elias did not look down at the wallet. His eyes remained fixed on Kellerâs face, recording every line, every scar, every pore, and the subtle twitch at the corner of the manâs upper lip.
âI asked you a question, old man,â Keller barked, stepping directly into Eliasâs personal space, his chest almost touching Eliasâs denim jacket. âPick it up.â
Elias slowly bent his knees, his sixty-eight-year-old joints popping softly against the wind, and retrieved his wallet from the gravel. He brushed the white dust off the leather against his thigh, folded it, and placed it back into his jacket pocket.
He didn't check to see how much money was left. He already knew.
âNow get in the truck and drive,â Keller said, stepping back and gesturing lazily toward the open door of the F-150. âAnd if I see this blue rust-bucket on I-70 again today, you won't be paying a fine. Youâll be sitting in a holding cell waiting for a magistrate.â
Elias didn't answer. He turned, climbed back into the cab of his Ford, and closed the door. The latch caught with a solid, heavy mechanical clunk that resonated through the quiet interior.
In his side mirror, he watched Keller and Pike walk back to their cruiser. Keller was smirking, adjusting the front pocket of his uniform shirt where the ten hundred-dollar bills sat folded flat against his chest. Pike said something to him as they reached the driverâs side door, and Keller threw his head back, laughing out loud as he opened his door and slid inside.
The cruiser pulled out first, its tires spraying a small shower of gravel against the guardrail as it swung back onto the asphalt, its flashing lights cutting off instantly as it accelerated down the highway, disappearing into the midday glare.