Vain's smile never quite left his face, but it changed as he looked at her, cooling at the edges, becoming something more like an assessment. He asked Thad, lightly, as if it were a joke between men, where he had found his companion, and Thad said nothing at all, which was answer enough, and Vain laughed, a short, polished laugh, and said that the world was a small place, and that old acquaintances had a way of turning up where a man least expected them. Then he tipped his hat, or nodded, or did whatever polished men do when they leave a store, and he was gone, and the bell over the door rang thinly behind him, and the store smelled of coffee and leather again, as if nothing had happened at all.
They left the store not long after, though Nia could not have said how long, because time had gone strange on her, stretching and compressing the way it does when a memory and a present moment collide. The walk home was a mile of silence. Not the companionable silence of the ranch, not the silence Thad gave her when she wanted it, but a different silence, heavy and full of things unsaid, pressing on her chest with every step. Thad walked ahead, his shoulders set, his hat low, and Nia walked behind him, turning the face over in her mind: the silver collar, the polished boots, the half-heartbeat of recognition, the smile. She had seen that face in smoke. She was certain of it. But certainty was not the same as understanding, and understanding was what she did not yet have.
You two know each other? Nia asked at last, when the town was behind them and the road stretched west and the silence had gone on long enough to become unbearable.
Thad waited almost a mile before answering. He did not stop walking. He did not turn around. He simply walked, and the road went on, and the hills went on, and Nia thought he might never answer at all. Then, quietly, as if the words cost him something to say aloud after years of not saying them:
I served under him.
Nia stopped walking. The road dust settled around her boots. The wind moved through the grass. "In the army?"
Yes.
That was all, for the moment. One word, flat and final, and yet it opened a door in Nia's mind that she had kept shut for thirteen years, a door behind which smoke and shouting and running feet had been waiting all along. A soldier. Thad had been a soldier. Under Vain. Under the man whose face she knew from the canyon. The man who had bought her freedom at auction had once served the man who had ordered the destruction of her world. The pieces did not fit together yet — they were scattered, sharp-edged, refusing to form a picture — but they were moving, and the movement itself was terrifying, because once pieces start moving toward each other, they do not stop until they meet.
The pieces moved as she walked, and each one brought its own flash of the canyon. Smoke first, because smoke had been the first thing: thick, yellow-gray, rolling between the rocks until the sky was gone and the air itself seemed to burn. Then the shouting, men's voices giving orders she had not understood at sixteen, and her mother's hand, and the running, and the terrible noise of gunfire echoing off stone until it seemed to come from everywhere at once. She remembered a soldier's hands, rough and urgent, pulling her behind a rock, and her own fighting, because she had thought he was trying to hurt her, and his voice, young and desperate, telling her to stay down, to be still, to live. She had never known that soldier's name. She had never seen his face clearly, because the smoke was in her eyes and terror was in her heart, and afterward he was gone, the way everyone was gone after the canyon, scattered like ash. Now a man who had served under Vain had bought her at auction and cut her ropes and given her a bedroom and asked her what she wanted, and the soldier behind the rock had been eighteen, and Thad had been eighteen once, in an army uniform, under Vain's command, and the numbers lined up with a terrible neatness: thirteen years, sixteen years old, eighteen years old, one canyon, one order, one girl behind a rock. She did not yet know if the soldier had been Thad. She knew only that the possibility had entered her mind and would not leave it, and that the man walking ahead of her on the road, silent and gray-eyed, might be the one person alive who had been there in the smoke with her — not as her enemy, but as the hands that had pulled her down and kept her alive. And with that thought came another, quieter and harder: if Thad had been there, then he had also been there afterward, when the canyon emptied and the survivors scattered, and he had gone on to live a life, marry, lose a wife, buy a ranch, while she had spent thirteen years surviving one place after another. The unfairness of that sat beside the gratitude, and the two feelings did