Karen stood where she had been standing, in the middle of his pasture, and she watched him come with an expression Marcus had seen on her face once before, on the day he had flagged down her SUV at the property line. It was the look of a person who had decided in advance that nothing she did could be wrong, and that anyone who objected was the problem.
"Your dog chased my cattle," Marcus said. His voice was low now, and it shook a little, not with fear but with the effort of keeping it steady. "Your dog is not on a leash. This is my land. Those animals are mine."
Karen lifted one hand and waved it in the air, the way a person waves away a fly. "He was only playing," she said. "He is a friendly dog. He would not hurt anything. You are making a fuss over nothing."
Marcus looked past her, toward the fence line. The cattle had stopped running, but they had not calmed down. They stood pressed together against the fence, their sides heaving, their heads up, their eyes still wide and white-rimmed. They panted heavily in the warm afternoon air, and their breath came in short, ragged pulls. One of the older cows kept shifting her weight from foot to foot, as if the ground itself could not be trusted anymore. Another stood with her neck stretched out, staring at the place where the dog had disappeared, waiting for it to come back.
And in the corner of the pasture, apart from the rest, stood Daisy.
Daisy was the gentlest animal Marcus owned, a heifer with a broad, patient face and a slow, careful way of moving, and she was pregnant, her belly round and low, and she had always been the calmest of the herd. Now she stood in the corner with her legs braced and her head lowered, and she was trembling violently, the tremor running through her whole body in waves he could see from twenty feet away. Her ears were flat. Her eyes were fixed on nothing. She did not move when Marcus called her name softly. She did not move when he took a step toward her. She only stood there and shook, as if the fear had gotten inside her and could not find its way out.
Marcus felt something cold settle in his chest. He knew what stress could do to an animal, and he knew what it could do to a pregnant one. He knew that a heifer chased in circles by a barking dog was not a small thing, and he knew that a heifer trembling in a corner after the dog was gone was not a small thing either.
He turned back to Karen. She had already started walking away, back toward the edge of the field, her bright shoes picking their way through the grass with small, careful steps. Her dog trotted ahead of her, tongue out, tail still wagging, as if the afternoon had been a fine success.
"You need to keep that dog on your own land," Marcus said. He kept his voice level, and he kept it loud enough for her to hear. "You need to keep yourself on your own land too. This is not your shortcut and it is not your park. It is my farm."
Karen did not turn around. She raised one hand over her shoulder in a small, lazy wave, the way a person waves at a neighbor they have already forgotten, and she kept walking. The dog bounded ahead of her and disappeared over the rise toward the subdivision, and Karen followed, and a moment later both of them were gone, and the pasture was quiet except for the sound of the cattle breathing hard against the fence.
Before he went to her, Marcus walked the pasture the way he walked it every morning, slow and thorough, looking at the ground as much as at the animals. The grass was torn where the cattle had run in their circle, and the dust still hung low over the trampled patch, and he could see the dog's paw prints pressed into the soft earth near the gate, a line of them running in and out of the herd's path, quick and light, nothing like the heavy, splayed prints of the cattle. He followed the prints with his eyes to the gap near the gate where the dog had slipped out, and he stood there for a moment looking at the gap, at the wire that had been bent just enough to let a dog through, and at the field beyond it, where the subdivision's lawns began and the houses stood in their neat rows.