An HOA Karen Demanded a Stranger's Mustang for Her Son — Then She Froze

Chapter 2

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Logan laughed despite himself.

"Seriously?"

"Seriously."

The teenager wandered into the garage as though it were a museum.

He circled the Mustang slowly, hands stuffed inside the pockets of his designer hoodie.

"This thing is insane."

"It cleans up nicely."

"I looked it up."

Elijah raised an eyebrow.

"You did?"

"Boss Four-Twenty-Nine."

"Boss Four-Two-Nine."

"Yeah... whatever."

Logan grinned sheepishly.

"Only like thirteen hundred were built."

"Twelve hundred and something."

"Dang."

The teenager crouched near the front wheel.

"Original rims?"

"Restored."

"Engine?"

"Original block."

"Transmission?"

"Four-speed."

Logan whistled.

"You know this thing's worth more than my dad's Corvette?"

"I know."

"You could probably sell it for..." He shrugged. "A couple hundred grand."

"I could."

"But you won't."

"No."

"Why?"

Elijah rested both hands on the roof.

"Some things aren't for sale."

Logan frowned.

"It's just a car."

"No."

His answer came instantly.

"It's my father."

The garage fell quiet.

For the first time since they'd met, Logan didn't have a sarcastic reply.

"He helped build it?"

"Every bolt."

"He still drive it?"

Elijah's eyes remained on the polished paint.

"He passed away."

"Oh."

The confidence drained from Logan's face.

"I... didn't know."

"It happened six months ago."

"I'm sorry."

"I appreciate that."

For several moments neither of them spoke.

Then Logan broke the silence.

"So..."

Elijah laughed.

"There it is."

"What?"

"The real reason you're here."

Logan scratched the back of his neck.

"I mean..."

"No."

"I didn't even ask yet."

"You don't have to."

"What if I promised—"

"No."

"I'd only drive around the block."

"No."

"I'd pay you."

"No."

"A thousand bucks."

"No."

"Five thousand."

"No."

"You didn't even think about it."

"I did."

"What'd you decide?"

"No."

Logan sighed dramatically.

"You're impossible."

"So my officers tell me."

"What officers?"

Elijah realized his mistake.

He quickly smiled.

"Old coworkers."

"Oh."

Logan accepted the explanation.

"So there's absolutely nothing I could do?"

"There is one thing."

"What?"

"Graduate high school."

Logan rolled his eyes.

"I meant about the car."

"So did I."

That afternoon, Logan met his two closest friends at the basketball court near the neighborhood clubhouse.

Tyler Briggs, captain of the varsity football team, listened with disbelief.

"Wait."

"You seriously got rejected?"

Logan tossed a basketball harder than necessary.

"Twice."

"Maybe he doesn't know who your family is."

"He knows."

"No offense," Tyler said, "but your mom usually gets whatever she wants."

"Exactly."

Their third friend, Mason Ortiz, leaned against the fence.

"So steal the keys."

Logan stopped dribbling.

"What?"

"I'm kidding."

"...Mostly."

Tyler laughed.

"He probably keeps them locked up."

"I checked."

Both boys looked at him.

"You checked?"

"I mean..."

Logan hesitated.

"I kinda looked through his garage yesterday."

Mason stared.

"Dude."

"What?"

"That's creepy."

"I wasn't doing anything."

"You were snooping."

Logan shrugged.

"He shouldn't have something that cool if nobody gets to enjoy it."

Tyler nodded slowly.

"I kinda get that."

"No, you don't," Mason replied.

"It belongs to him."

Logan kicked the basketball across the court.

"My mom says people like him always think they're better than everyone else."

"What people?"

"You know..."

"The rich?"

"No."

"The old?"

"No."

"The guys who move in and don't even try fitting into the neighborhood."

Mason folded his arms.

"Or maybe..."

"He just doesn't want a seventeen-year-old driving a four-hundred-horsepower muscle car."

Logan glared.

"You taking his side?"

"I'm taking common sense's side."

Before Logan could answer, his phone buzzed.

Mom

He answered immediately.

"Yeah?"

"Come home."

"Why?"

"I have an idea."

Vivien Hartman sat at the dining room table with her HOA binder spread open like a general studying battle plans.

Gregory Hartman looked up from his laptop.

"Honey."

"Please tell me this isn't about the new neighbor again."

"It absolutely is."

Gregory sighed.

"Vivien..."

"He embarrassed Logan."

"He told him no."

"In front of people."

"There were two people."

"That's not the point."

Gregory closed his laptop.

"Have you considered..."

He chose his words carefully.

"...that it's his car?"

Vivien looked horrified.

"So now you're taking his side?"

"I'm taking reality's side."

"He moved into my neighborhood."

"Our neighborhood."

"My neighborhood."

Gregory rubbed his temples.

"There it is."

"What?"

"You said the quiet part out loud."

She ignored him.

Instead, she flipped through several pages before stopping triumphantly.

"There."

She tapped one paragraph.

"Section Twelve."

Gregory adjusted his glasses.

"'Excessively loud vehicles that disturb the peaceful enjoyment of residents may be subject to review.'"

"So?"

"So that car is loud."

"You've heard it once."

"Once was enough."

Gregory stood.

"Vivien."

"Don't."

"He hasn't done anything wrong."

"He refused a reasonable request."

"No."

"He refused an unreasonable one."

Vivien snapped the binder shut.

"We'll see."

Three days later, Elijah returned home after spending the morning downtown finalizing paperwork connected to his promotion.

As he stepped onto the porch, another white envelope waited for him.

Then another.

And another.

Three violations.

One afternoon.

He opened the first.

Excessive Vehicle Noise

The Mustang had not left the garage in two days.

The second.

Improper Exterior Color

The bright blue paint allegedly distracted passing drivers.

The third.

Potential Commercial Racing Vehicle

Because the Mustang "appeared capable of competitive racing."

Elijah laughed so hard he nearly dropped the papers.

Someone cleared their throat behind him.

Sandra stood at the edge of the driveway holding a pie.

"I see she found you."

He held up the notices.

"Does this happen often?"

Sandra smiled sympathetically.

"Only if she decides she doesn't like you."

"And if she does like you?"

"Then someone else gets the letters."

Elijah shook his head.

"I've dealt with organized crime that made more sense."

Sandra handed him the pie.

"For surviving your first week."

"What's the occasion?"

"It's Maple Ridge tradition."

"There really is one?"

"No."

She smiled.

"I just felt sorry for you."

For the first time since moving in, Elijah laughed from the heart.

Across the street, hidden behind lace curtains, Vivien watched the interaction.

Her lips tightened.

She hated seeing neighbors side with someone else.

Especially someone who refused to acknowledge her authority.

She turned toward the staircase.

"Logan!"

"What?"

"Come downstairs."

He appeared a moment later.

"What now?"

Vivien looked through the window toward Elijah's garage.

"If Mr. Grant wants to make enemies of this neighborhood..."

Her smile slowly returned.

"...then we'll simply make sure he understands exactly how this neighborhood works."

Logan smiled too.

Neither of them noticed Gregory standing silently in the hallway.

Or the worried expression spreading across his face.

He had seen this look in his wife's eyes before.

It never ended well.

By the beginning of Elijah Grant's second week in Maple Ridge Estates, he had earned an unusual reputation.

To some neighbors, he was the quiet man with the beautiful blue Mustang.

To others, he was the mysterious newcomer who somehow managed to smile every time the HOA sent him another violation notice.

To one person, however...

He had become a personal challenge.

Vivien Hartman hated losing.

The Maple Ridge Estates Clubhouse looked less like a neighborhood gathering place and more like an exclusive country club.

Polished hardwood floors reflected crystal chandeliers.

Fresh flowers decorated every table.

The coffee station served imported beans instead of instant coffee because, according to Vivien, "standards matter."

Every second Thursday evening, the HOA Board held its monthly meeting there.

Officially, it existed to discuss landscaping, maintenance, and community improvements.

Unofficially...

It had become Vivien's courtroom.

She stood at the front of the room, remote control in hand, beside a projector screen displaying the evening's agenda.

Her navy blazer matched the HOA logo embroidered behind the podium.

Everything about the presentation had been rehearsed.

Everything except what happened next.

"As Item Four," Vivien announced, "we need to discuss a growing concern regarding neighborhood safety."

Several residents exchanged puzzled glances.

Safety?

Nothing had happened in Maple Ridge for years.

Vivien clicked the remote.

A photograph of Elijah's Mustang appeared on the screen.

Murmurs spread through the audience.

"Our newest resident," she continued, "owns a high-performance racing vehicle."

"It's a classic car," someone quietly corrected.

Vivien ignored the interruption.

"According to automotive publications, this model produces over four hundred horsepower."

"So?"

The question came from the back of the room.

Sandra Mills raised one eyebrow.

Vivien smiled politely.

"So..."

She clicked again.

A slide titled THE DANGERS OF STREET RACING appeared.

Stock photos of smoking tires and reckless drivers filled the screen.

"Our community includes children."

Sandra folded her arms.

"And has Mr. Grant been racing?"

"No."

"Has he driven recklessly?"

"No."

"Has he broken any neighborhood rules?"

Vivien hesitated.

"Not yet."

Soft laughter echoed around the room.

The smile on Vivien's face became noticeably tighter.

"Sometimes," she said carefully, "leadership requires preventing problems before they begin."

Another hand rose.

It belonged to retired firefighter Harold Benson.

"I've seen the gentleman three times."

"And?"

"He waved."

A few people laughed louder.

"He also helped carry groceries for my wife."

Vivien clicked her remote harder than necessary.

"That's not the point."

"Then what is?" Harold asked.

"He refuses to cooperate."

Sandra leaned forward.

"You mean he won't let Logan borrow a car worth more than most of our houses?"

The room became very quiet.

Vivien's eyes narrowed.

"That has nothing to do with this discussion."

"Oh?"

Sandra tilted her head.

"Funny."

"It seems to have everything to do with it."

Across town, Elijah had no idea he was becoming the evening's entertainment.

He stood inside the city police headquarters wearing plain clothes instead of a uniform.

The promotion ceremony had been intentionally small.

No reporters.

No television cameras.

No speeches from politicians.

Just a handful of officers who had spent years working beside him.

Captain Marcus Rivera handed over a small black presentation box.

"You earned this."

Inside rested the polished gold badge of the city's new Chief of Police.

Elijah studied it quietly.

"I still don't know if it feels real."

Marcus grinned.

"It will tomorrow."

"Why tomorrow?"

"Because tomorrow everyone starts bringing you their problems."

The room laughed.

Lieutenant Sarah Collins stepped forward carrying a coffee mug wrapped in blue ribbon.

"We got you something."

Elijah unwrapped it.

Across the front were printed the words:

WORLD'S OKAYEST CHIEF

He laughed so hard coffee nearly came through his nose.

"You people are impossible."

"We learned from the best."

Another officer raised his phone.

"Smile, Chief."

Flash.

The photograph captured Elijah holding the ridiculous mug while laughing harder than anyone had seen in years.

No medals.

No stiff poses.

Just genuine happiness.

Exactly how he preferred it.

That same evening, Logan Hartman sat in his bedroom scrolling through social media.

His bedroom resembled a luxury hotel suite.

Gaming setup.

Seventy-inch television.

Designer sneakers lined perfectly beneath custom shelving.

Yet none of it interested him.

His screen displayed photo after photo of vintage Mustangs.

Especially blue ones.

He imagined himself driving one.

Windows down.

Music loud.

Everyone staring.

Thousands of followers watching his livestream.

His phone buzzed.

Tyler: Any luck with the old guy?

Logan typed back.

No. He's impossible.

Three dots appeared.

Then another message.

Bet he's hiding something.

Logan stared at those words longer than he intended.

Hiding something.

Maybe.

Nobody that calm stayed that calm for no reason.

News in the same category

An HOA Karen Demanded a Stranger's Mustang for Her Son — Then She Froze

7 Part