They described the terms of the agreement in detail.
The water rights were shared.
No single company or individual could claim permanent control over the spring.
The arrangement had been intended to protect the entire community.
Elara turned another page.
There was a list of witnesses.
Calder recognized one name.
Edmund Vale.
He looked at her.
"The banker."
Elara nodded slowly.
But the most important detail appeared beneath the signatures.
A second document had been attached to the book.
It was a formal declaration stating that the agreement would remain valid only while the water was distributed equally among the participating families.
If the arrangement was altered without consent, the claim to exclusive use would become void.
Calder read it twice.
"That's what Rusk has been hiding."
Nantan examined the signatures.
"Then the old agreement cannot be used to take the water."
"No," Calder answered. "Not legally."
Elara closed the book.
For the first time that morning, she smiled.
"We have it."
Calder nodded.
"We have something important."
He placed the book inside his leather case.
But as they stepped outside, he noticed something unusual.
Fresh horse tracks crossed the path.
Someone had visited the spring recently.
And beside the tracks was a small piece of blue cloth.
Calder recognized it.
It matched the lining of Victor Hale's coat.
He looked toward the northern ridge.
They were not the only ones searching for the old records.
Someone had followed them.
And that person now knew exactly what they had found.
They returned to the village before noon.
Calder immediately sent Nantan to inform Thomas Bell about the discovery.
Elara remained with him to examine the original agreement.
They spread the documents across the meeting-house table.
The signatures were clear.
The terms were unmistakable.
The agreement had never granted permanent ownership of the water channel to the cattle company.
It had established shared rights among the families.
More importantly, the declaration attached to the final page prohibited the transfer of exclusive control without the consent of every participating household.
Elara read the passage aloud.
"Any alteration to the agreed distribution shall require the approval of all parties concerned."
She looked up.
"Then Rusk cannot simply redirect the water."
Calder nodded.
"Not without permission."
"And he doesn't have it."
"No."
She placed the document down.
For a moment, the two of them simply looked at one another.
They had spent months watching people use complicated language to disguise simple theft.
Now they had discovered an agreement written in plain terms.
The water belonged to the community.
Not to the richest man.
Not to the largest company.
Not to whoever could produce the most convincing document.
It belonged to the families who depended on it.
Calder began copying the relevant passages.
Elara examined the remaining pages.
There was another detail.
A list of annual maintenance contributions.
Every family had agreed to provide labor or materials to keep the channel functioning.
The arrangement had been based on cooperation.
Not ownership.
Elara looked thoughtful.
"My grandfather used to say that the river was never anyone's property."
Calder glanced at her.
"He understood the agreement."
"Yes."
She touched the old paper.
"He believed that if people shared the water, they would have fewer reasons to fight."
Calder considered that.
"It sounds sensible."
"It was."
Outside, a wagon approached the meeting house.
Nantan entered carrying a letter.
"Thomas sent this."
Calder opened it.
The territorial investigator had agreed to examine the evidence.
An official representative would arrive in Copper Bend within two days.
That was good news.
But the second paragraph was more troubling.
Rusk had already submitted an application to begin construction.
The application claimed that the water channel was privately controlled and that the proposed work was necessary for public improvement.
If approved, the construction could begin immediately.
Calder looked at Elara.
"We have two days."
"To do what?"
"Make certain the investigator sees the original agreement before Rusk's application is approved."
Nantan nodded.
"I can take the documents to Thomas."
Calder shook his head.
"Not alone."
"Why?"
"Because someone has already followed us to the spring."
Nantan's expression changed.
"You think Hale knows?"
"I think he suspects."
Elara stood.
"Then we should tell the families."
Calder nodded.
"Yes."
They organized a meeting for the following afternoon.
Word spread quickly.
By sunset, nearly every household had sent someone.
Calder stood beside the table while Nantan explained the original agreement.
Several older residents recognized the names of their grandparents.
One man began crying when he saw his father's signature.
Another shook his head in disbelief.
"My family has been paying Rusk's company for access to water," he said.
"How long?" Calder asked.
"Almost six years."