"Did the department interview them?"
"Not that I know of."
"Did you provide their names?"
"Yes."
Evelyn examined the complaint file.
The witness section contained only one entry: an officer who had arrived after the arrest.
There was no record of an interview with Anthony's cousin.
"What happened to your phone after the arrest?"
"They kept it for several hours. When they returned it, the video was gone."
"Did you ask them why?"
"Yes. They said the file must have been corrupted."
"Was the phone examined by a technician?"
"Not according to the paperwork."
Anthony leaned forward.
"I know what I saw. I recorded the traffic stop, and then I recorded Collins coming toward me. I remember the time because I had checked a message just before he arrived. When they gave me the phone back, the video was gone."
"Do you have any cloud backup or automatic photo storage?"
"I checked. Nothing was saved."
"Did anyone tell you that your phone had been searched?"
"They said they needed to verify that I hadn't recorded anything confidential."
Evelyn made a note.
"Did they obtain your consent or present a warrant?"
Anthony shook his head.
"They didn't ask me to sign anything."
The details were concerning, but Evelyn did not interrupt him with conclusions.
Instead, she asked for the phone's make and model, the approximate time of the incident, the names of the officers, and the date the device had been returned.
She also requested permission for the investigative team to examine the available records and, if technically possible, determine whether the deleted file could be recovered.
Anthony agreed.
Before leaving, he looked at Evelyn.
"Can I ask you something?"
"Of course."
"Do you think the sheriff knew what Collins was doing?"
Evelyn paused.
"I don't know yet."
"But you think someone knew."
"I think the records raise questions that deserve answers. I won't tell you that a particular person is responsible until we have evidence to support that conclusion."
Anthony nodded slowly.
"I appreciate that."
He stood and shook her hand.
"My father always told me that if you tell the truth, you have nothing to worry about."
He gave a bitter laugh.
"I used to believe that."
Evelyn looked at him.
"You should never have to choose between telling the truth and feeling safe. The fact that you were made to feel that way is one of the reasons we're investigating."
After Anthony left, Evelyn reviewed his file alongside the records Walter had provided.
There was a striking similarity between the cases.
A person asked a question.
An officer interpreted the question as defiance.
The encounter escalated.
A report described the civilian as aggressive.
The complaint was reviewed by someone inside the same department.
And the available evidence failed to establish what had actually happened.
The pattern did not prove that every officer involved had acted improperly. But it suggested that the department's procedures might systematically favor the accounts of its own employees.
At eleven thirty, Laura received a call from the technical team.
She listened for several minutes, asking occasional questions before ending the conversation.
Then she turned toward Evelyn.
"They've found something."
"What?"
"Several archive entries were moved to restricted storage shortly after the complaints were filed. The system logs indicate that the actions were performed through an administrator account."
"Whose account?"
"That's what they're trying to establish. The account was shared among a small group of authorized personnel."
"Can they identify the device used?"
"Possibly. The technical team is comparing the access times with workstation records."
Evelyn considered the implications.
A shared administrator account made individual attribution difficult. It could have been used by several employees, and the logs might not reliably identify who had performed each action.
But the existence of the restricted entries was important.
"Have they confirmed that the files were deleted?"
"No. Some appear to remain on the server. They're inaccessible through the ordinary system, but the forensic team is examining them."
"Then we need to avoid describing them as destroyed until the examination is complete."
Laura smiled.
"That is why I wanted you on this case."
Evelyn shook her head.
"It's also why we need to be careful. If those files contain exculpatory information, the department deserves the opportunity to explain their existence. If they contain evidence that was improperly concealed, we need to establish who was responsible."
"Agreed."
Laura closed the folder.
"There's another development. Sheriff Harlan has requested a private meeting with me."
"When?"
"This afternoon."
"Did he explain why?"
"He says he wants to cooperate with the review."
Evelyn thought about Thomas Bell's telephone call.
"Do you believe him?"
"I believe he wants to protect himself. That doesn't necessarily mean he won't provide useful information."
"Are you going alone?"
"No. I'll have another investigator present, and the meeting will be documented."
"Good."
Laura stood.
"If Harlan has information about the archive, we need to hear it. But I don't want him to believe that a cooperative attitude will end the investigation."
"It won't."
"Exactly."
That afternoon, Sheriff Harlan arrived at the state administrative building wearing his formal uniform.
He had chosen it deliberately.
The polished badge, crisp shirt, and silver nameplate were symbols of the authority he had spent nearly two decades cultivating. He believed that appearing professional would remind the investigators that he was an experienced public official rather than a suspect.
Laura Mitchell met him in a conference room with two investigators present.
No refreshments were offered.
No cameras were placed on the table for dramatic effect.
The room contained only chairs, a recorder, a stack of documents, and a clock.