THE WOMAN THEY SHOULD NEVER HAVE TAKEN
The Kidnapping
There were plenty of foolish crimes in the history of the American West.
Men had robbed banks with unloaded revolvers. Horse thieves had stolen animals they were too drunk to ride. Outlaws had buried their loot in the middle of nowhere, only to sober up and discover they had forgotten where they had put it.
But in the summer of 1887, near Medicine Bow, Wyoming Territory, a gang of seven men made a mistake that would cost them almost everything.
They kidnapped a young woman in broad daylight.
Her name was Clara Whitmore.
She was twenty-four years old, though the hardships of frontier life had given her a seriousness that made strangers guess she was older. She lived with her widowed father on a small ranch twelve miles east of Medicine Bow, where the grass was thin, the wind was merciless, and every fence post seemed to lean in the same direction.
Clara had grown up around horses.
She could saddle a nervous gelding faster than most cowboys, shoot a rifle accurately enough to discourage thieves, and identify approaching weather by the smell carried on the wind.
Her father, Samuel Whitmore, often joked that Clara had been born with dust in her lungs and a horse's heart.
That morning, she had ridden into Medicine Bow alone.
The sun was already high when she finished buying flour, coffee, lamp oil, and a small bundle of sewing supplies. She stopped at the telegraph office before leaving.
There was a message waiting for her.
She unfolded the paper and read it twice.
ARRIVING CHEYENNE NEXT WEEK. WILL VISIT RANCH. — THOMAS
A smile touched her lips.
Thomas Bell had been away working on the railroad for nearly six months. He was not yet her husband, but everyone in Medicine Bow knew that engagement was coming.
Clara folded the telegram carefully and placed it inside her coat.
She had just stepped outside when she noticed the seven riders.
They were standing across the street near the livery stable.
Seven men.
None looked particularly remarkable at first.
That was what made them dangerous.
The leader was a broad-shouldered man with a gray hat pulled low over his eyes. His name was Cole Mercer. Beside him stood his younger brother, Jesse, a thin man with restless hands and a crooked smile.
The other five were strangers.
Clara had seen enough men in her life to recognize trouble before it spoke.
She mounted her horse.
The moment she turned toward home, Mercer moved.
"Miss Whitmore."
Clara stopped.
She looked at him without answering.
"You dropped something."
He held up a white handkerchief.
Clara glanced at her saddle.
"I didn't."
Mercer smiled.
"No. I suppose you didn't."
Something cold moved through her stomach.
She touched the rifle hanging beside her saddle.
Mercer noticed.
"So you know what you're doing," he said.
"I know enough."
The smile disappeared from his face.
"Then you know you'd better come with us."
Clara's hand tightened around the reins.
"Why?"
Mercer stepped closer.
"Because your father has something we want."
"My father doesn't have anything worth stealing."
"Oh, that's where you're wrong."
Before Clara could react, Jesse grabbed her horse's bridle.
She struck him across the face.
The crack of her palm against his cheek echoed through the street.
For one second, everyone froze.
Then Jesse laughed.
"She's got spirit."
Mercer grabbed Clara's arm.
She fought.
She kicked one man in the knee and reached for her rifle, but another outlaw pulled it away.
Someone covered her mouth.
The struggle lasted less than a minute.
That was all it took.
People were watching from the boardwalk.
A shopkeeper stood frozen in his doorway.
Two children stared from beside a wagon.
But the outlaws had chosen their moment well.
The street was busy enough to hide the crime in confusion, yet no one was close enough to stop it.
Clara was lifted from her saddle and forced onto another horse.
She screamed through the hand over her mouth.
Mercer leaned close.
"Don't make this harder than it has to be."
Clara glared at him.
He released her.
She immediately shouted.
"HELP!"
A gunshot exploded into the air.
The crowd scattered.
Mercer drew his revolver.
"Anyone who follows us gets shot."
The seven riders turned west.
Within seconds, Clara was being carried away from Medicine Bow.
She looked back.
The town grew smaller.
No one followed.
Not yet.
But Clara knew one thing with absolute certainty.
They had made a mistake.
They had assumed that because she was a woman, she would be frightened into obedience.
They did not understand Clara Whitmore.
And they certainly did not understand her father.
Samuel Whitmore was seventy-one years old.
He had fought in the Civil War, crossed half the country on horseback, survived Indian attacks, blizzards, droughts, and three separate cattle wars.
He had lost his wife.
He had buried two sons.
Clara was all he had left.
When a terrified rider finally reached the Whitmore ranch two hours later and told Samuel what had happened, the old man said nothing.
He simply walked into the house.
He opened a wooden chest beneath his bed.