THE SEVEN MEN WHO CHOSE THE WRONG WOMAN
The Kidnapping
There were plenty of foolish crimes in the history of the American West.
Men had robbed banks with unloaded revolvers. Horse thieves had stolen animals they were too drunk to ride. Outlaws had buried their loot in the middle of nowhere, only to sober up and discover they had forgotten where they had put it.
But in the summer of 1887, near Medicine Bow, Wyoming Territory, a gang of seven men made a mistake that would cost them almost everything.
They kidnapped a young woman in broad daylight.
They did it on an open trail, beneath a cloudless sky, with no trees or buildings nearby to hide the crime.
And worst of all, they chose the wrong woman.
Her name was Clara Whitmore.
At twenty-six, Clara was not the kind of woman most men noticed twice. She was tall without being imposing, slender from years of riding and hard work, with brown hair usually tied beneath a faded hat. Her clothing was practical rather than fashionable: a dust-covered riding skirt, a pale cotton blouse, worn boots, and a brown leather coat hanging from the saddle of her horse.
She was riding alone that afternoon.
That was the first thing the seven men noticed.
The second was the rifle strapped beside her saddle.
The third was the fact that she seemed completely unconcerned about being alone.
The trail stretched westward through a wide basin where the grass had already begun turning yellow beneath the summer sun. Medicine Bow's mountains were visible in the distance, blue and hazy beneath the enormous Wyoming sky.
Clara had left town shortly after noon.
She was carrying medicine for an old rancher named Samuel Bell, whose wife had sent word that his fever had worsened. The Bell ranch was nearly thirty miles from Medicine Bow, and Clara had promised to deliver the supplies before sundown.
She had been riding for nearly two hours when she noticed the riders ahead.
Seven horses.
Seven men.
They were stopped across the trail.
Clara slowed her mare.
Her horse, a gray mustang named June, lifted her head and snorted.
Clara rested one hand lightly on the reins.
The men were waiting.
That much was obvious.
She counted them automatically.
One man sat in front, wearing a black hat and a red neckerchief. He was broad through the shoulders and carried a revolver openly at his hip.
Another leaned against his saddle horn, chewing tobacco.
A third had a scar running from his left ear to the corner of his mouth.
The remaining four were younger.
Too young, Clara thought.
Young enough to believe that seven men automatically meant victory.
The leader raised a hand.
"Afternoon, miss."
Clara stopped thirty yards away.
"Afternoon."
"Where you headed?"
"West."
The man smiled.
"That's a direction, not an answer."
Clara looked at him.
"Then I suppose you'll have to live with not knowing."
One of the younger men laughed.
The leader didn't.
His name was Silas Crowe.
Clara did not know that yet.
She only knew that his eyes had changed.
The friendliness had disappeared.
"Get down from the horse."
Clara's fingers tightened slightly around the reins.
"No."
The young man nearest Silas grinned.
"You didn't hear him."
"I heard him."
"Then get down."
Clara looked from one face to another.
Seven men.
Seven guns.
An open trail.
No cover.
No help.
And yet there was something strange about the situation.
The men were nervous.
She could see it.
The one chewing tobacco kept shifting his weight.
The scarred man repeatedly looked over his shoulder.
The youngest kept touching the handle of his revolver as if reminding himself that it was there.
Only Silas Crowe looked calm.
Clara wondered what they wanted.
Then she noticed the wagon tracks crossing the trail behind them.
Fresh tracks.
Heavy wagon.
Probably carrying supplies.
The realization came quickly.
They weren't interested in her.
They were waiting for someone else.
She was simply an unexpected opportunity.
Silas pointed toward her rifle.
"Leave the gun."
Clara glanced at it.
Then back at him.
"Why?"
"Because you're going to have a long conversation with us, and I don't like armed women."
One of the others laughed.
Clara's expression remained unchanged.
"I don't much care what you like."
Silas's jaw tightened.
"Last warning."
Clara looked toward the horizon.
Then at the seven men.
Then at June.
She calculated distances.
Thirty yards.
Too far to reach the nearest man before they could draw.
The rifle was inaccessible while seated.
Her revolver was beneath her coat.
She could possibly shoot one.
Maybe two.
But seven men meant seven opportunities for failure.
So she did something unexpected.
She smiled.
It was small.
Almost polite.
"All right."
Silas blinked.
Clara slowly dismounted.
She handed the reins to no one.
Instead, she tied them loosely around a nearby scrub bush.
The youngest outlaw approached.
"Smart girl."
Clara looked at him.
"That's what people keep telling me."
He reached for her arm.
She let him.
For the moment.
Silas pointed toward a shallow depression beside the trail.