Silas slowly raised his Colt.
"Crowe."
The judge looked at the others.
"Put down your weapons."
Nobody moved.
Crowe's smile vanished.
"I said put them down."
Six rifles shifted toward Abigail and Samuel.
Silas saw the angles.
The distances.
The impossibility of winning without someone innocent dying.
Slowly, he lowered his gun.
Mara followed.
Tommy did the same.
Crowe descended the stairs.
"Remarkable," he murmured. "The South Pass Ghost, finally captured."
Silas stared at him.
"You killed my family."
Crowe's expression remained calm.
"Your wife became involved in matters she did not understand."
"She understood enough."
"Apparently."
Silas's hand tightened.
Crowe stepped closer.
"You should have stayed dead, Mercer."
Silas looked into his eyes.
Then he smiled faintly.
"Funny."
Crowe frowned.
"What?"
"That's what the last five men said."
For the first time, the judge's confidence faltered.
Only slightly.
But Silas saw it.
And in that moment, he knew the truth.
Nathaniel Crowe was afraid.
Not of the gun.
Not of death.
Of losing control.
Silas looked toward the cellar ceiling.
Above them, the house stood silent.
Outside, the wind moved through the pines.
The night was far from over.
Nathaniel Crowe ordered the prisoners separated.
Silas was taken to the old wine cellar beneath the western wing. Mara and Tommy were locked in a storage room near the kitchens. Abigail remained with her father, though two guards stood outside the door.
Crowe believed separation would weaken them.
He was mistaken.
Silas had spent years learning that a prisoner's greatest advantage was often the arrogance of his captors.
The wine cellar was cold.
Rows of empty racks lined the walls.
A single lantern burned near the stairs.
Silas sat on a wooden chair with his wrists bound.
He examined the knots.
Tight.
Competent.
But not impossible.
The guard standing near the door was broad-shouldered and heavily armed.
He wore a deputy's badge.
Silas studied him.
"What's your name?"
The man ignored him.
"How long have you worked for Crowe?"
Silence.
Silas leaned back.
"Does he pay well?"
The guard shifted.
"Shut up."
Silas nodded.
"Not well enough, then."
The man stepped closer.
"You think you're funny?"
"No."
"Good."
Silas looked at the badge.
"Did you earn that?"
The guard's face darkened.
"What?"
"The badge."
"Of course."
"Then why are you guarding a kidnapped man?"
The guard hesitated.
Silas saw the uncertainty.
A small crack.
He continued.
"There's still time to choose what kind of man you want to be."
The guard looked away.
"Too late for that."
Silas studied him.
"Maybe."
Upstairs, Crowe stood before Abigail with a document in one hand and a revolver in the other.
Samuel sat beside her.
His breathing was shallow.
The judge placed the paper on the table.
"This ends tonight."
Abigail looked at him.
"You've said that before."
Crowe's expression hardened.
"Your father will sign."
Samuel shook his head.
"No."
Crowe raised the revolver.
Abigail stepped between them.
"Stop!"
The judge looked almost weary.
"You continue to mistake defiance for strength."
Abigail held his gaze.
"And you continue to mistake cruelty for power."
Crowe smiled coldly.
"Perhaps."
He turned toward the door.
"Bring Mercer."
Abigail felt her stomach tighten.
"What are you going to do?"
Crowe did not answer.
Silas was brought into the drawing room shortly after two in the morning.
His wrists remained bound.
Two guards stood behind him.
Crowe waited beside the fireplace.
Abigail and Samuel sat near the desk.
Silas looked at them first.
Both alive.
That was enough.
Crowe gestured toward the document.
"Mr. Hartwell will sign."
Silas said nothing.
"And you will provide a statement confirming that the South Pass killings were committed by independent criminals."
Silas looked at him.
"That's what you've been telling people for fourteen years."
"Precisely."
"Then why need my signature?"
Crowe's expression tightened.
"Because your return has complicated matters."
Silas smiled faintly.
"Seems I have a talent for that."
Crowe raised his revolver toward Abigail.
Silas's smile vanished.
"Careful."
The judge watched him.
"Sign, and she lives."
Silas stared at the gun.
He had faced this choice before.
At South Pass.
On the wagon trail.
At the line shack.
Always the same cruelty.
Always an innocent person placed between a murderer and the consequences of his actions.
Silas looked at Abigail.
She shook her head.
"No."
Crowe pressed the revolver closer.
Silas spoke quietly.
"Put the gun down."
"Sign."
Silas looked at the document.
Then at Samuel.
His old friend was watching him with an expression of terrible sorrow.
Silas understood.
Samuel would rather die than surrender the truth.
But Abigail was twenty-three.
She had a life ahead of her.
He could not sacrifice that life to preserve a document.
Silas stepped toward the desk.
"Give me a pen."
Crowe smiled.
At last.
The ghost had surrendered.
But as Silas bent over the paper, he noticed something beneath the desk.
A small brass bell.
A servant's signal.
Its cord disappeared through a narrow opening in the floor.
Silas glanced toward the doorway.
One guard stood beside the fireplace.