"Yes."
Robert turned to Stephanie.
"Please make sure the final report addresses it directly."
"I will."
Then he returned his attention to Nathan.
"I also understand that Whitmore Systems is reviewing our commercial relationship."
"That's correct."
"Is the contract at risk?"
Nathan did not answer immediately.
"Our existing agreement remains in effect. We will continue to meet our obligations."
"That wasn't quite my question."
"I know."
Robert folded his hands.
"Whitmore has been a valuable partner to Blue Ridge. Your systems support critical operations. A change in that relationship could be disruptive for both companies."
"That is one of the factors we're considering."
"Can I ask what the other factors are?"
"Of course."
Nathan described the preliminary contract review.
He explained that Whitmore had identified a substantial volume of additional work that had been handled outside formal billing and approval processes.
Some requests were reasonable extensions of ordinary support. Others were larger analytical projects. Some had been urgent. Others had become urgent because a manager needed information for a meeting.
The problem was not that Whitmore had helped.
The problem was that the company had not consistently measured what it provided or established a clear process for determining when additional work required authorization.
Robert listened without interrupting.
When Nathan finished, he asked, "Are you saying Blue Ridge has been taking advantage of your company?"
"No."
The answer came quickly.
"I'm saying the relationship developed habits that neither company examined carefully enough. We need to establish what was included, what was separately authorized, and what was provided informally."
"Some of those requests may have been important to our operations."
"I don't doubt that."
"And if we had been required to wait for a purchase order, certain decisions could have been delayed."
"That may be true."
Robert leaned forward.
"Then isn't there a risk that your new process will make the relationship less effective?"
"There is a risk that any change will create friction. There is also a risk in continuing a process that relies on informal favors without measuring their cost."
Nathan paused.
"We can design an expedited approval process. We can define emergency categories. We can establish preapproved rates for certain types of additional work. We can make it easier for your team to obtain the services it needs."
"Then what is the problem?"
"The problem is the assumption that because a request is important to Blue Ridge, it must automatically be included in the price we already agreed upon."
Robert was quiet.
Nathan continued.
"If you need more service, we can provide it. We have engineers, analysts, and support specialists who know your systems. But their time is not unlimited. When we allocate it to one client, it affects what we can provide to others."
"Understood."
"And when we provide additional work without documenting it, we make it harder to know whether the relationship is profitable, whether our staffing is adequate, and whether our pricing reflects the actual demands of the account."
Robert glanced at Peter Lawson.
The general counsel had been taking notes.
"Would you be willing to negotiate a revised support arrangement?" Robert asked.
"Yes."
"With the same level of responsiveness?"
"With clearly defined levels of responsiveness, including expedited options when needed."
"That sounds more restrictive."
"It is more explicit."
Robert gave a brief, rueful smile.
"Executives don't always enjoy being told that something they have received for years is no longer included."
"I understand."
"Do you?"
Nathan met his eyes.
"Yes. But I also understand the position of the employee who has been told that a request is urgent, that the relationship is important, and that refusing to provide extra work might create a problem for everyone. Eventually, that employee has to decide whether the written agreement means anything."
Robert's smile disappeared.
For several seconds, nobody spoke.
Then Robert closed his folder.
"I think we've established the issues."
Nathan nodded.
"Agreed."
Robert stood, signaling the end of the formal discussion.
Before leaving the room, he turned back.
"Nathan, I want you to know that I am taking the incident seriously. I cannot undo what happened on the aircraft. I can investigate it, determine why it happened, and make changes where they're necessary."
"That is what I'm asking."
"And I hope we can preserve the relationship between our companies."
"So do I," Nathan said. "But preserving a relationship and preserving every habit within it are not the same thing."
Robert considered that sentence.
Then he extended his hand.
"Thank you for being direct."
Nathan shook it.
"Thank you for listening."
The meeting ended at 11:14 a.m.
That afternoon, Robert convened a special leadership meeting.