On the ride home, Raina told Elias that she had been ready to accuse Ben of caring more about cattle than people. "I was angry before he finished his first sentence," she admitted.
"You had reason."
"Reason isn't the same as permission to stop listening."
He glanced at her. "You should put that in the council rules."
"They'd vote it down immediately."
"Then put it at the top. They'll have to read it before they argue."
She smiled, and he thought again how strange it was that he could recognize her footsteps before she reached the porch, or know from the set of her shoulders whether she had spent the day angry, frightened, or simply exhausted. He had not decided when concern had become affection. The change had happened in small, unremarkable moments: her hand steadying a page in the wind, the way she listened to a child without looking over the child's head, the fact that she always remembered to leave water for his mule even when she forgot to drink herself.
That evening a storm crossed the basin. Rain struck the roof in brief hard bursts and ran from the eaves into barrels Elias had placed beneath them. He found Raina on the porch watching the dark clouds move east.
"I used to hate storms," she said.
"Because of the roads?"
"Because my mother would count the lightning and wonder which wash had flooded. My father traveled between settlements with medicines and letters. Sometimes he was gone for weeks. Every storm meant another reason he might not come home."
"Did he?"
"Usually. Until one year he didn't."
Elias waited. She rarely spoke of her father, and he had learned not to pull at a memory merely because it had appeared within reach.
"He wasn't killed by the company," she said. "It was fever. An ordinary sickness in an ordinary winter. I think that made me angrier. There was no man to confront, no paper to recover, nothing I could fix. My grandfather told me that grief was not a problem waiting for a clever answer. I hated him for saying it."
Elias leaned against the porch post. "My sister died after a bad winter. I kept repairing things around the house because she used to complain about every loose board. When the boards were fixed, she was still gone."
Raina looked at him. "What was her name?"
"Margaret. She was older. She taught me to cook and then spent years complaining that I never improved."
"Did you?"
"Not much."
She smiled. "I suspected."
Rain filled the silence between them. Elias wanted to say that he was sorry for her father, that he understood the shape of an absence that could not be repaired. The words seemed small beside the weather. Instead he moved the second chair closer to hers. She sat, and after a while he sat too. They watched the rain turn the yard dark, neither asking the other to be cheerful.
The next morning brought the first good news in weeks. Ada arrived with a letter from a lawyer in Santa Fe who had agreed to review the workers' claims. He wanted sworn statements, the account books, and copies of the freight receipts. He also wanted to know whether the families could afford his fee. Ada had written in the margin, in her brisk handwriting, that he should consider the answer obvious and tell them whether he intended to help.
"You frightened him," Elias said.
"I reminded him that a reputation for justice is not much use if it never leaves the office," Ada replied.
Raina laughed. Mateo asked whether the lawyer could also review the council's proposed water trust. Ada promised to ask. They spent the afternoon sorting papers into piles and arguing about how to keep the originals safe. Elias suggested the stone cistern. Raina shook her head.
"We have already learned what happens when truth is hidden for twenty years," she said. "We need copies in more than one place and people who know where they are."
They made three sets. One remained with Ada. One went to the council. The third traveled with a merchant who had agreed to deliver it to the lawyer. Elias signed the inventory, and Raina checked every page against the original. It was slow work, but each copy felt like a door opened rather than a secret buried.