He paused, looking each of the three sisters directly in the eye.
"But I cannot choose one of your daughters."
A sharp intake of breath came from Lena. Naya’s chin lifted a fraction higher, a flicker of cold contempt passing across her features, as if she had expected nothing less than a coward's refusal.
Tomas’s eyes narrowed into dark slits. "You refuse my lodge, Cole? You think our blood is not good enough for Cedar Ridge?"
"That isn't what I said," Ethan replied, his tone remaining calm, unhurried, and resolute. "I say I cannot choose one because they are not horses in a corral to be pointed at and roped. A man who chooses one woman out of three as if he were picking a rifle from a gunsmith’s rack doesn't respect the one he takes, and he insults the two he leaves behind."
He stood up, towering over the low bench, his broad frame casting a long shadow across the firelight.
"Naya has the eyes of a war chief. If she takes a husband, it will be because she chooses to trust him, not because her father traded her to buy an alliance. Lena works with the patience of the river, and she deserves a man who values the life she wants to build, not one who takes her as a prize. And Sani has more fire in her little finger than half the deputies in Yavapai County; she would make any man who tried to own her regret the day he was born."
Ethan looked back at Tomas, his gaze unwavering. "If one of your daughters ever looks at me and decides, of her own free will, that I am worthy to walk beside her, I would count it the greatest honor of my life. But I will not pick one over the others to make my own life easier, and I will not force any of them to give up her freedom to pay for my help. If I help you fight Nathaniel Voss tomorrow, I do it because it is right—not because I was promised a bride as wages."
For three long heartbeats, nobody breathed.
Then, Tomas’s jaw tightened. "And if all three wished to stand beside you?" the chief asked, his voice dropping into a register that was almost dangerous. "What then, cowboy?"
Ethan looked from Naya’s flint-hard stare to Lena’s quiet, measuring gaze, and finally to Sani’s bright, defiant smile.
"Then I would be honored to stand beside all three," Ethan said plainly. "In this lodge, on the trail, or in front of Rourke’s rifles tomorrow. Not as their master, Chief. But as their partner."
Tomas stared at Ethan for another agonizing second. Then, slowly, the hard lines around the chief’s mouth began to twitch. The silver at his temples caught the firelight as his head tilted back, and suddenly, a deep, booming laugh burst from his chest, shaking the very rafters of the shelter.
"You fool," Tomas roared, slapping his knee with a calloused palm. "You absolute white fool! You have no idea what you have just invited upon your head!"
"Father!" Naya snapped, her cheeks flushing with sudden heat. "This is not a matter for laughter!"
"It is the only thing worth laughing about in three months," Tomas gasped, wiping a tear of mirth from his weathered eye. He stood up, towering over the fire, and looked at his three daughters with immense pride. "He thinks he can handle all three of you! He thinks one man from Cedar Ridge has the hide to survive three daughters of the Apache!"
Tomas walked toward the entryway, pausing at the threshold to look back at the young rancher.
"Return to your ranch, Ethan Cole. Find your father’s survey. If you are not back before the stars show themselves tonight, we will know you are like every other white man who talks of honor until the sun gets hot."
The chief ducked through the door flap and was gone, his laughter still echoing faintly among the cottonwoods outside.
The ride back to Cedar Ridge was conducted in a race against the falling sun. The air retained its scorching heat until the horizon swallowed the sun, replacing the fiery glare with a deep violet twilight that swept across the mesa like spilled wine. Ethan rode Boone hard, keeping the gelding to the sandy washes where the footing was soft, his mind turning over every word exchanged in Tomas's lodge.
He had lived a quiet life. Since his mother had succumbed to the lung fever when he was sixteen, and since Samuel had grown too stiff to work the branding pens, Ethan had known only the cadence of cattle, seasonal rains, and the solitary creak of the front porch swing. The woman he had almost married years ago in Prescott—a banker’s niece named Clara—had looked at his sun-chapped face, his calloused hands, and his remote mountain valley, and she had seen only hardship and isolation. She had wanted townhouses, buggies with polished brass lamps, and church socials. When she realized Ethan’s heart was irrevocably rooted in the scrub and cedar of the rim, she had broken the engagement without shedding a single tear.