“Choose One of My Three Daughters,” the Apache Chief Told the Cowboy — He Chose All Three, Then Rode Into War Beside Them

Chapter 4

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

And Ethan Cole, who had ridden out at dawn to fetch three stray horses, understood with a clarity that settled in his chest like a stone that he had walked into something far larger than a broken fence, and that walking away from it would cost him more than staying ever could.

Ethan did not stay for the evening meal, though Aiyana offered it plainly and Tala's disappointment was written across her face like weather. He told Tomas he would return, and he meant it, but he needed to ride home first, to think, and to look at something he had not looked at in three years: the contents of a locked drawer in his father's house.

The three horses followed Juno willingly enough, strung on a lead rope, their bellies full of spring water. Kaya watched them go from the ridge path, her rifle across her shoulders, and did not wave. Ethan did not expect her to. Trust, in his experience, was not given at a first meeting. It was earned in the days after, when a man did what he said he would do.

The ride back was longer than the ride out. The sun stood high and white, and the heat came up off the stones in shimmering waves. The horses' hooves kicked up dust that hung in the air and settled on Ethan's skin. He rode with his father's words turning over in his mind, the warning and the promise tangled together: a clean conscience, money offered to forget, a document with a territorial seal that might one day become important.

He had thought the document was a curiosity. A piece of family history, filed away with his grandfather's survey maps. He had never asked himself why his father kept it locked.

Cedar Ridge appeared at last, low-roofed and weathered, the stable and the corral and the house his father had built with his own hands. Smoke rose from the cookhouse chimney. Miguel Reyes, his foreman, stood in the corral with a rope in his hands, working a young colt that had decided the world was its enemy. Miguel was forty-eight, a vaquero who had ridden for Samuel Cole before Ethan was old enough to hold a rein, and he read Ethan's face the way he read weather.

You found them, Miguel said, watching the three horses file into the corral.

I found them, Ethan said. "And more besides."

He told Miguel everything as they unsaddled and watered the horses: the hidden valley, the spring, the settlement, Tomas, the three daughters, the brand burned into the post, the paper nailed to the wood, the thirty days. Miguel listened without interrupting, his hands steady on the colt's lead, his face growing graver with each detail.

The Frontier Water and Cattle Company, Miguel said at last. "Silas Brandt's outfit. They have been buying up wells all spring, and the ones they cannot buy, they claim."

You know Brandt?

I know his kind. He came through Juniper Flats in April with a lawyer and a smile. He buys what he can and takes what he cannot buy, and he calls both of them business. Miguel spat neatly into the dust. "Your father would not sell him water, you know. Brandt came to this ranch two years before your father died. Offered good money for the east well. Samuel told him the well belonged to the land, not to a company, and showed him the gate."

Ethan felt something shift in his chest, a piece of the puzzle sliding into place. "My father knew Tomas. He visited the valley twice a year. He never told me."

Samuel kept his own counsel, Miguel said. "He had friends in places the town did not look. He said a man who talks about his friends puts them in danger."

Pete Aldana, the young ranch hand, came out of the stable with a bucket, and Walt Simms, sixty-four and bowed by years of saddle work, followed with a saddle over one shoulder. Ethan gave them their orders for the afternoon: mend the south fence properly this time, with new rails from the woodpile; water the cattle at the east well and count heads; keep the rifles close but out of sight. They nodded and went to it, and Ethan walked to the house alone.

The house smelled of dust and old wood and coffee. His father's desk stood in the corner of the front room, scarred by decades of use, and in its right-hand drawer, behind a lock Ethan had not opened since the funeral, lay the things Samuel had kept closest: the survey maps, rolled and tied with twine; a leather-bound journal, its cover worn soft; and a folded document, heavy paper, bearing a territorial seal pressed in faded red wax.

Ethan spread the document on the desk and read it by the window light.

It was dated 1868, nineteen years earlier. It was called, in careful copperplate, the Dry River Accord. It recorded an agreement between the Territory of Arizona and the Apache people of the Dry River valley, granting them the valley and its spring in perpetuity, in recognition of their long occupation and in exchange for peace on the trails and safe passage for travelers. It was signed by a territorial commissioner, by a mark made for Chief Tomas's father, and by two witnesses.

One of the witnesses was Samuel Cole.

Ethan sat down slowly. The chair creaked under him. He read the document a second time, and then a third, and each time the words were the same, plain and binding and impossible to misunderstand. The valley belonged to Tomas's people. It had belonged to them for nineteen years, by territorial agreement, witnessed by his own father.

News in the same category

“Choose One of My Three Daughters,” the Apache Chief Told the Cowboy — He Chose All Three, Then Rode Into War Beside Them

45 Part