"I'm not saying that to be excused," Brenna said. "I've heard people summarize my position the last few weeks, and they keep landing on one of two stories. In the first one I'm a bad person who did a cruel thing and the system is fine. In the second one I'm a good person crushed by a bad system and my hands are clean. Both of those are easier than what happened. I was a competent agent who chose, on a particular morning, the resolution my station had taught me, and the choice was still mine. The button was a minute away. My hand was the last piece of equipment the airline issued me, and it did what I told it to."
Desmond leaned forward. "Ms. Kidd," he said, "I'm going to ask you the question this review asks everyone, and I'd like the answer you'd give a new agent, not the one you'd give me. What would you need — not want, need — to do this job the way the job deserves to be done?"
She answered without the hesitation that had marked the rest of it, as if the question had been waiting weeks to be asked in the right room.
"Supervision that watches the counter instead of the clock," she said. "Somebody senior standing close enough to see a queue becoming a person going wrong, whose job is to step in before the agent does something she can't take back — not to log her afterward. A recheck button that nobody gets written up for using. I mean that literally: press it as often as the passenger in front of you needs it pressed, and have it count for you, not against you. And—" Her voice thinned, once, and she let it, and went on. "And my name, said by somebody who'd seen me do the job right. In fourteen months at that station, the only times I heard my name from management were attached to a number or a warning. If the only reflection an agent ever gets is a ranking, she will become a ranking. Somebody watching has to be able to say: I saw you stay with that lady. Do it that way again."
"Thank you," Desmond said. He did not dress it up.
She stood. Walking back to her seat she passed the front row, and Mrs. Chen, without making anything of it, moved her purse a few inches so the younger woman would have room to get by. Brenna noticed. Whatever her face did then, she got it back under management by the time she sat down, and that was the end of the morning's hardest hour.
During the recess, people stood in the corridor with paper cups and agreed that the numbers had been worse than expected, the memo worse, the letter worst of all. Greg Santos, forty-four, duty supervisor, seventeen years with the airline, stood apart from his colleagues with his cup untouched. His signed statement had been entered that morning — eleven pages that did not spare him: years of receiving complaint forms across his desk and carrying them, with full knowledge of what he was doing, to the drawer instead of the system; years of hearing the doctrine at shift changes and repeating it himself, twice that he could specifically remember and therefore, he had written, certainly more. He had signed it anyway, unpromised anything, and when Desmond called him after the break, he testified to only one thing beyond it.
"You wrote," Desmond said, "that you are asking this review for an assignment rather than a penalty."
"Yes, sir."
"Explain that for the record."
Greg looked at his hands. "For seventeen years I was the person passengers were handed to when the counter went wrong. I was introduced as the man who would make it right. And then I filed their complaints in a drawer, which meant I was making it wrong a second time, in private. I don't think I get to just be sorry about the paperwork part. If the station is going to run a complaint desk where complaints are actually taken, I'd like to work its first month. Myself. Taking them. In front of the people they belong to." He paused. "I know how that sounds. It isn't a photograph. It's the only part of the job I ever did that I'm ashamed of, and I'd like to do it correctly while somebody's watching, until it's a habit instead of a decision."
"Noted," Desmond said, gently, "and the record will credit the statement as given." Greg nodded once and stepped down. Jesse Park testified for eleven minutes, among the saddest of the day, because he was twenty-two and had almost nothing to confess, and that was the confession. He had been a trainee for five months. He had worked the morning of the torn itinerary two counters down. Yes, he had heard the passenger ask for the recheck. Yes, he had known the kiosk was out of service. No, he had not said anything, then or after, nor written it in the trainee log his program required — though he had thought about that blank line for several evenings.