She also intended to discover who had tried to stop her from looking.
Because Officer Mercer had made one assumption that could not be allowed to stand.
He had believed that if he raised his voice loudly enough, everyone else would become quiet.
He had believed that if he invoked his badge, questions would disappear.
And he had believed that a woman sitting at a courtroom table could be forced to surrender her judgment simply because a uniformed man demanded it.
He was about to discover how wrong he had been.
By six o'clock that evening, the courthouse had become the center of a controversy that nobody in the police department seemed prepared to handle.
News vans occupied the curb outside the main entrance. Reporters stood beneath umbrellas, delivering live updates while camera operators adjusted their equipment against the wind. A short clip showing Officer Richard Mercer grabbing Judge Regina Callaway's jacket had spread across social media, and every new broadcast seemed to raise another question.
Why had a police officer confronted a judge inside a courtroom?
What investigation had he been trying to interrupt?
And why had the judge ordered the preservation of records connected to a disputed drug arrest?
The police department's public information office released a statement at 5:35 p.m.
It described the incident as an unfortunate misunderstanding involving an officer who had entered the courthouse to address an urgent investigative concern. The statement promised a thorough internal review and emphasized the department's commitment to professionalism.
It did not mention the unauthorized request for sealed court records.
It did not mention the missing evidence.
And it did not explain why Mercer had placed his hands on Regina.
When Regina read the statement, she closed the webpage without finishing the final paragraph.
"They're trying to make this about his temper," she said.
Her longtime colleague, Judge Eleanor Whitaker, sat across from her in the small conference room adjoining the chief judge's office.
"That may be all they know how to do," Eleanor replied. "If they admit the confrontation might be connected to the Price case, they have to explain why an officer believed he had a right to interfere with a judicial proceeding."
"Exactly."
Eleanor removed her glasses and rubbed the bridge of her nose.
"I've known Mercer for years. He testified in several cases before me. He was always aggressive, but I never saw him behave like that."
"Did you ever receive complaints about his courtroom conduct?"
"One. A defense attorney said Mercer had attempted to speak with a witness in the corridor after the judge ordered the parties not to discuss the testimony."
"What happened?"
"The attorney withdrew the complaint after the department assured him the matter had been addressed."
Regina looked up.
"When was that?"
"About fourteen months ago."
"Was it documented?"
"There should be a record."
Regina made a note.
"Please don't retrieve it yourself. Ask the court administrator to preserve the relevant files and forward the request through the proper channel."
Eleanor gave her a questioning look.
"You think someone might interfere with the records?"
"I think we should not create a situation where anyone can later argue that the evidence was handled improperly. We need independent preservation, not personal favors."
Eleanor nodded.
"You're right."
For a moment, they sat in silence.
Then Eleanor asked, "Are you going to recuse yourself from the Price case?"
It was a reasonable question, and Regina had expected it.
The officer had confronted her personally. The incident had been recorded and reported. The police department's actions were now under scrutiny, and Regina's name had become part of a story that was attracting national attention.
Any decision she made in Daniel Price's case would be examined for signs of bias.
"I will not make that decision casually," Regina said. "The question is whether I can continue to act impartially and whether the circumstances require another judge to take over."
"And can you?"
"Yes. But that is not the only consideration."
Eleanor leaned forward.
"Explain."
"The court has a duty to ensure that the case proceeds lawfully. I also have a duty to avoid even the appearance that my personal experience is influencing a ruling. I will review the applicable rules, disclose the incident to the parties, and hear their positions before deciding."
"That sounds fair."
"It has to be."
Regina gathered her papers.
"If I step aside, it cannot be because Mercer intimidated me. If I remain, it cannot be because I want to prove that he failed."
Eleanor studied her for a moment.
"Your mother would have been proud of that answer."
Regina smiled faintly.
"My mother would have asked whether I had written it down correctly."
Eleanor laughed, but the laughter faded quickly.
The incident was serious.
And both women understood that the consequences could extend far beyond one courtroom.
At 7:10 p.m., Officer Richard Mercer sat alone in an interview room at the police department.
His badge had been temporarily collected, and he had been instructed not to contact witnesses or discuss the incident with other officers while the initial review was underway.
He had spent the first hour insisting that he was the victim of a misunderstanding.
He said he had entered the courthouse to provide information concerning an active criminal investigation. He claimed that Regina Callaway had repeatedly challenged his authority and refused to acknowledge the urgency of the situation.
When investigators asked why he had grabbed her jacket, he said he had been trying to prevent her from walking away before he could finish speaking.
The explanation did not match the video.
The recording showed Regina sitting still while Mercer shouted at her. It showed her asking him to release her jacket. It showed the judge ordering him to step back.
And it showed Mercer tightening his grip.
When investigators played the footage for him, his expression changed.
"I didn't realize how it looked," he muttered.
Detective Laura Chen, who had been assigned to the department's initial review, folded her hands on the table.
"How it looked?"
"I was frustrated."
"That doesn't answer the question."
Mercer leaned back.
"I felt like she was trying to make me look incompetent."
"Did she threaten you?"
"No."
"Did she strike you?"
"No."
"Did she attempt to flee?"
"No."
"Did she prevent you from presenting evidence to the court?"
Mercer hesitated.
"I was trying to explain something."
"Then why didn't you submit it through the prosecutor?"
"Because the situation was urgent."
"What was urgent about it?"
He looked toward the wall.
"I can't discuss the details of an ongoing investigation."
Chen waited.
Mercer seemed to realize that he had said something useful.
"There," he added. "That's why I needed to speak to her directly. There were things I couldn't discuss in open court."
"Did you have authorization to request a private meeting with Judge Callaway?"
"No."
"Did you have a court order authorizing access to the sealed records?"
"No."
"Did you have permission from the prosecutor to bypass the ordinary procedure?"
Mercer rubbed his forehead.