The meeting between Cole and the Sterlings did not happen in a lawyer's office or a police station. It happened because Vivian, after days of thinking about it, called Cole herself, using the number from the homeowners association directory, and asked if he would come for coffee. Marcus had not wanted her to make that call. He had argued, gently at first and then with more heat than he intended, that Cole was part of what had happened and that they owed him nothing, least of all hospitality. Vivian had listened, and then she had said that she was not inviting Cole for his sake, but for theirs, because she did not want to live two doors down from a man she had turned into a villain in her mind, and she did not want their children to inherit a feud with a neighbor they had never met. Marcus had not agreed, exactly, but he had not stopped her either, and on a Saturday afternoon Cole arrived at their front door carrying a small plant in a terracotta pot, as if a plant could carry the weight of what he needed to say, and stood on the porch looking like a man preparing to be turned away.
Vivian opened the door before Marcus could, and she ushered Cole into the living room where the light was soft and the chairs were arranged so that no one had to sit with his back to the door. Cole set the plant on the coffee table and apologized before he had fully sat down, the words coming out in a rush, as if he had rehearsed them and then forgotten the order. He said he was sorry for the call, sorry for not checking, sorry for assuming, sorry for the way his assumption had traveled from his mouth to a dispatcher's ear to an officer's report until it no longer sounded like an assumption at all. He said he had moved to Oak Creek hoping for a quiet street and good neighbors, and instead he had become the reason a good neighbor had been humiliated in his own home, and he did not know how to live with that. Marcus listened with his arms crossed, and then, slowly, he uncrossed them, because he could see that Cole was not performing remorse. He was embarrassed in the deep, uncomfortable way of a man who has discovered that his judgment is not as reliable as he believed, and who is frightened by what that discovery might mean about other judgments he has made without noticing.
The conversation that followed was difficult in the way honest conversations are difficult, not because anyone shouted but because no one could offer the other an easy absolution. Marcus told Cole what it had felt like to hear a gun cocked in his own garage, to be told to drop a tool he used to care for a car he loved, to be cuffed while he tried to produce proof of his own life. He told him about the shaking in his hands and the case he had handed to Samuel Okafor, not to elicit pity but because Cole needed to understand that consequences did not end when the cuffs came off. Vivian told Cole about standing in the doorway watching it happen, and about checking the street before she went out to get the mail afterward, as if safety were something she now had to verify. Cole listened without interrupting. He said he had assumed the house was empty because he had not seen anyone coming or going that morning, and because the man in coveralls did not match the picture he had in his head of who lived there, and he was ashamed of that picture now that he had said it out loud. He said he wished he had walked over and introduced himself instead of calling. Marcus did not say he forgave him, because forgiveness was not something that could be granted in a single afternoon over coffee, but he did say that Cole had come, and that coming mattered, and that they could start from there.