He was not a police officer. He had no authority to arrest anyone or direct a criminal investigation.
But his name appeared on the distribution list for the original complaint-review proposal.
Evelyn was not part of the interview. Laura Bennett and another investigator conducted it, with Nathaniel observing.
Vale explained that his role had been to coordinate the administrative pilot and ensure that the police department's proposal complied with city records policies.
He said the restricted archive was intended to protect sensitive material while allowing authorized supervisors to review related complaints.
He denied requesting that any complaint be concealed.
He denied instructing anyone to close a case without proper review.
He denied knowing that the matrix contained an exposure-level field until the investigators showed him the document.
When asked about the missing Appendix C, he said he remembered reviewing a draft but could not recall whether the final version had been distributed.
“Do you recognize this document?” Laura asked, placing the preliminary proposal before him.
Vale examined it.
“Yes.”
“Did you receive it before the public safety committee meeting?”
“I believe so.”
“Did you approve the pilot?”
“I approved the administrative coordination process. The police department was responsible for operational decisions.”
“Did you authorize transfers of live complaints before the committee formally approved the process?”
Vale frowned.
“I don't remember authorizing any transfer of live complaints.”
“Were you aware that a transfer occurred nineteen days before the implementation order?”
“No.”
“Were you aware that the original proposal instructed staff not to move live complaints until Appendix C was finalized?”
Vale read the handwritten note.
“I don't recognize the handwriting.”
“Did you know the note existed?”
“No.”
“Who was responsible for finalizing Appendix C?”
“The department's administrative team, working with the city records office.”
“Did you receive the final version?”
“I can't say with certainty.”
“Did you ask for it?”
“I may have. I would need to review my correspondence.”
“Would you provide the relevant emails and calendar records?”
“Through my attorney, yes.”
Laura moved to the matrix.
“Did you know the matrix included an exposure-level field?”
Vale studied the photograph.
“I've never seen this exact spreadsheet before.”
“Did you approve the use of an exposure-level score to prioritize complaints?”
“I approved a general concept for prioritizing administrative work. I did not approve a system that would determine whether a complaint deserved investigation based on the risk it posed to the city.”
“Did you know that the original safeguards were weakened in the implemented guidance?”
“No.”
“Did you review the final guidance?”
“I reviewed a summary.”
“Do you have the summary?”
“I believe it is in the city archive.”
“Did you notice that the shared administrative account could close certain categories of complaints without identifying an individual reviewer?”
“No.”
“Would that have concerned you?”
“Yes. An audit trail should identify who made a consequential decision.”
“Then why wasn't that safeguard preserved?”
Vale looked down at the table.
“I don't know.”
For the first time, his composure seemed to falter.
He turned the matrix photograph toward himself and examined the columns.
“If this was the implemented system, it did not match the process I believed we were approving.”
“Can you explain the difference?”
“Not without seeing the complete policy and the approval history.”
“Will you help us obtain them?”
“Yes.”
“Do you believe someone could have altered the process without your knowledge?”
Vale took a long breath.
“It's possible. I wasn't responsible for every operational decision. The department had its own chain of command, and the IT team handled system configuration.”
“Did you have authority to stop the pilot?”
“Yes, if I believed it violated city policy.”
“Did you ever consider stopping it?”
“Not before I saw these documents.”
“Why not?”
“Because I believed the process was being implemented according to the approved proposal.”
Laura made a note.
The interview continued for another hour.
Vale agreed to provide his correspondence, meeting notes, and the summary he had reviewed. He also agreed to identify the city employees who had handled the final appendix.
When the interview ended, Nathaniel walked with Laura into the corridor.
“Do you believe him?” Nathaniel asked.
“I believe he may not have known about the changes,” Laura replied. “But we need to verify his account.”
“Could he be distancing himself from a decision he approved?”
“Certainly. His name is on the distribution list, and he approved the coordination process. That makes his records important. It doesn't establish that he approved the specific changes.”
Nathaniel nodded.
“Then we keep tracing the documents.”
Laura looked at the binder.
“The most important question is still unanswered.”
“Who requested the changes?”
“And who approved them.”
That afternoon, the digital team recovered a fragment of an email from the period before the implementation order.
The message had been sent from an account associated with the police department's administrative office to a city records employee.
Its subject line read: Pilot Categories — Final Adjustments.
The surviving text contained only a few lines.
The revised categories are attached. Please ensure that the restricted review process can accommodate cases requiring consolidated administrative handling. We need the system ready before the committee's next session.
The attachment was missing.
The sender's name was partially obscured by corruption in the backup, but the account identifier remained intact.
It belonged to a staff member who had worked in Deputy Chief Mercer's office.
The message did not establish that Mercer had written or approved it. An administrative employee could have sent the email on his behalf. The account might have been used by more than one person. The attachment could have contained ordinary technical changes.
But the timestamp placed the message four days before the earliest transfer.
Evelyn studied the recovered fragment.
“Can we recover the attachment from the recipient's mailbox?” she asked Laura.
“We're trying.”
“What about the sender's workstation?”
“It was replaced. The city may have retained a backup, but we haven't confirmed it.”
“Do we know who had access to the account?”
“Not yet.”
Evelyn looked at the timestamp.
The process was beginning to take shape.
A preliminary proposal had been circulated.
Someone had prepared revised categories.
A message had instructed the records office to make the system ready before the committee's next session.
A live complaint had been transferred before formal approval.
Later, the implemented guidance weakened several safeguards.
At some point, the matrix acquired an exposure-level field.
And complaints had been marked for administrative closure without a complete record of who approved the decision.