The notebook contained dates and partial sums that matched several Northbridge invoices. The photographs showed Celia and Simon at a restaurant before Celia had been introduced to Julian. Celia had claimed they met through the foundation. The phone, Rebecca explained, had been left in a drawer at her apartment after Celia spent a weekend there. She had not unlocked it. She wanted the police to handle it legally.
Julian thanked her. He was aware that Rebecca's decision might sever a family bond already strained beyond repair. He also understood that the phone could prove nothing relevant. It might contain holiday pictures and shopping lists. Its significance lay in the chance to investigate, not in the assumption that it was incriminating.
“Did she ever love me?” he asked, surprising them both.
Rebecca looked away. “I don't know what she felt. She talked about you as though you could solve everything, and then she sounded angry whenever you said no.”
Julian thought of the first few months of their relationship. Celia had brought dinner to the hospital when his father was recovering from surgery. She had listened as he spoke of Clara without looking bored. He had mistaken that patience for depth. Perhaps some of it was real. The question no longer mattered in the way he wanted it to. Whatever Celia had felt, she was responsible for what she had chosen to do.
At the music hall Lillian introduced Julian to a young violinist named Iris whose family had moved recently from another state. Iris showed him a borrowed instrument with a bridge that had begun to lean. She spoke enthusiastically about a piece she hoped to perform at the spring concert, then asked whether the new instruments would arrive before rehearsal began for the summer program.
“I hope so,” Julian said. “We're working to make the promises reliable.”
It was a less impressive answer than a billionaire's guarantee. It was also the truth. He had come to understand how much damage grand promises could do when nobody paid attention to their machinery. Lillian seemed to appreciate the difference. She invited him to sit through rehearsal if he could listen without taking photographs for publicity.
Julian put his phone away. In the back row he watched children count beats together, miss their entrances and begin again. Nobody was asking them to be perfect. The teacher wanted them to listen to one another, correct mistakes and keep playing. He wished he had learned the same lesson before the teacup fell.
The next morning Priya reported that two of the consulting firms receiving foundation money shared a registered director. The listed office was a rented mailbox. No staff could demonstrate services performed under several large invoices. She had also found one troubling email from a junior accounts clerk named Talia Reed, warning that the vendor details did not match the payment authorizations. Celia had marked it resolved without forwarding it to the audit committee.
Julian asked to meet Talia. Priya said the employee had left four months earlier after being told her work was disruptive. She had kept a copy of the email because she feared being blamed for the eventual discrepancy. Talia's last words to Priya had been: “One day somebody is going to ask why nobody checked.”
Julian stared at the email. A seven-year-old had shouted in his dining room, and he had almost ignored her. A junior clerk had raised a quieter alarm months earlier, and the foundation had ignored that too. The situations were different in substance and seriousness, but the common failure was impossible to miss. People with less power had told the truth as they understood it. Those with more power had preferred comfort.
He called Talia that afternoon. She answered cautiously, expecting a demand that she return confidential documents. Instead he asked whether she would be willing to speak with Priya and the investigators. He apologized for the institution's response to her warning.
“You're apologizing now?” she asked.
“Yes.”
“Because you finally need me?”
“That's part of it,” Julian admitted. “And because you should have been heard even if nobody ever needed your records.”
There was a long silence. Then Talia agreed to meet with a lawyer present. Julian understood that her agreement was not forgiveness. It was an act of professionalism from someone his organization had treated badly.
The meeting with Talia Reed took place in a library conference room because she did not want to return to the foundation headquarters. Priya arrived with an independent attorney and a note-taker. Julian came only after Talia agreed to his presence. She was younger than he expected, with dark-framed glasses and a canvas bag full of carefully labeled folders. She began by asking whether the meeting would be recorded. Priya explained the arrangements, and Talia requested a copy of the final statement.