she had stood in the doorway, and she had not said anything, and Roy had not seen her, and he had closed the box, and he had put it back in the drawer, and he had gone out to the back steps, and Ida had stood there, and her heart had been beating hard, and she had thought that she must have been mistaken, and that Roy would not take money from his own mother's box, and that there must be a reason, and that Opal must have asked him to take it, and that she had misunderstood what she had seen, and she had gone upstairs, and she had found Opal, and she had given her the bread, and she had not said anything about what she had seen, and she had gone home, and she had not told Roy that she had seen him, and she had not told Opal, and she had lain awake that night, and she had thought about it, and about how twenty dollars was a great deal of money, and about how Opal counted her money, and about how Opal would know, and about how Roy must have known that she would know, and about how he had done it anyway, and about how that frightened her, and about how she had decided to watch, and to wait, and to see if it happened again, and about how she hoped it would not happen again, and about how she prayed it would not happen again, and in the days that followed she watched him, and she watched the way he went to town, and the way he came back quieter, and the way he sat at the table in the evenings without speaking, and the way he counted his own money at night, and she wondered where the twenty dollars had gone, and she wondered if he had paid some of what he owed, and she wondered if he meant to pay it all back, and she wondered if he had told himself that taking it was only borrowing, and she wondered if a man can borrow from his own mother without asking, and she
wondered if the second time would be the last time, and she hoped it would be, and she watched, and she waited, and it happened again, fourteen days later, on the twenty-sixth of September, and that time she was ready, and that time she did not stay silent, and that time she followed him home, and she waited until the children were in bed, and she stood in front of him in their own kitchen, and she said, "Roy, I saw you take twenty dollars from your mother's box," and Roy had looked at her, and his face had gone red, and he had said, "It is my money, Ida. It will be mine one day anyway, and Mother does not need it, and I need it now, and I owe the storekeeper sixty dollars, and I have to pay it, and it is my right, and you will not speak of it to anyone, and you will not tell my mother, and it is none of your business," and Ida had said, "It is my business, Roy, because it is wrong, and because your mother trusts you, and because you are stealing from her," and Roy had said, "I am not stealing, Ida. A son does not steal from his own mother. I am taking what is mine, and I will take it again if I need it, and you will keep your
mouth shut, because a wife does not turn against her husband, and because if you tell her, you will break this family, and it will be your fault, and not mine," and Ida had looked at him, and she had thought about Hugo and Mina asleep upstairs, and about how they loved their father, and about how they did not know what he had done, and about how telling Opal would change what they thought of him, and about how not telling her would change what she thought of herself, and about how she had married Roy when she was twenty years old, and about how she had loved him then, and about how she loved him still, and about how love did not mean silence, and about how a wife who loves her husband tells him the truth, and about how she had told him the truth that night, and about how he had not listened, and about how she had not answered him, and she had gone to bed, and she had lain awake, and she had thought about what he had said, and about how he had called it his right, and about how a right does not need to be taken in secret, and about how a man who takes money in secret knows it is wrong, and about how she had seen him take it twice