Below them, in the schoolhouse yard, the children had come out onto the porch. They were shouting, their small voices carrying across the greening valley, waving their slates at the water that had finally come home.
The spring thaw brought the circuit court back to Dry Creek, setting up its bench in the upstairs assembly room over the general mercantile. It was a long room with low ceiling joists of hand-hewn fir, smelling perpetually of dry goods, kerosene barrels, and cured bacon from the floor below. Judge Halden sat behind an improvised desk of three flour barrels and an unplaned pine door, with the flag of the United States draped over a harness rack behind him.
The court had already spent three days listening to the depositions regarding the forged survey markers and the missing county ledgers. But on Thursday morning, the room went entirely quiet when Deputy Lyle Benton brought Gideon Vale into the prisoner’s dock. Vale was without his spurs, his boots ungreased, his broad shoulders hunched inside a borrowed mackinaw that lacked buttons. His right eye was still yellow from the bruise he had taken during the arrest at the lime quarry, and he kept his gaze fixed on the rough pine floorboards between his feet.
Deputy Benton placed a battered carriage lantern on the table before the judge. Its brass hood was dented, the red side-glass splintered and held together with twisted copper wire.
"Your Honor," Benton testified, his youthful voice clear and resonant in the crowded hall, "this lantern was found hidden beneath the hay floor of the old livery stable at the four-mile turn. It matches the iron mounting bracket of the spring wagon belonging to the Crowe Development Company. The stable keeper, old man Henderson, has sworn an affidavit that Gideon Vale brought that wagon in at two in the morning on the night Samuel Ellison died. The left hub was smeared with limestone dust, and the near horse was cut across the shoulder as if it had collided with another vehicle at high speed."
Judge Halden adjusted his spectacles and looked down at Vale. "Mr. Vale, you have heard the testimony of Deputy Benton and the affidavit of Mr. Henderson. The grand jury has returned an indictment against you for manslaughter and vehicular assault on the person of Samuel Ellison. Do you wish to make a statement under oath, or do you stand upon your counsel’s demurrer?"
Crowe’s lead attorney, Bradley, stood up, but before he could speak, Vale lifted his head. His eyes were bloodshot, rimmed with the deep red of a man who had not slept through five nights in the county jail.
"Sit down, Bradley," Vale said, his voice grating like gravel under an iron tire. "Your five hundred dollars doesn't keep me from swinging if they turn this into a hanging charge."
The courtroom gasped. Judge Halden raised his walnut gavel, but did not strike the block. He simply waited.
Vale turned toward the front bench where Mara sat beside Jonah and Elias. He looked Mara straight in the eye, without defiance, but with the weary candor of a man whose debts had all come due at once.
"It wasn't supposed to be a collision, Miss Ellison," Vale said, his voice flat and hoarse. "Crowe told me to intercept your father before he reached the telegraph office at the junction. He said Samuel had a satchel containing the 1871 survey notes, and that if Samuel wired the territorial land office in Cheyenne, the canal charter would be tied up in litigation for ten years. Crowe gave me two hundred dollars in gold and told me to run his wagon off the grade into the ditch so the satchel would be lost or ruined in the mud."
Jonah leaned forward, his hands gripping the pine rail until his knuckles turned white as tallow. "You rammed him in the dark!"
"I didn't ram him from behind," Vale muttered, looking down at his scarred knuckles. "I came around the quarry bend with the carriage lanterns doused. I pulled across the track to block the bridge approach. Samuel saw me at twenty paces. He didn't try to pull up his team; he laid the whip to his horses and tried to jump the ditch to get around me. His near wheel caught the limestone ledge, the axle snapped, and the buckboard rolled into the dry wash. I didn't push him over, Miss Ellison. But I took the leather satchel from his seat while he was pinned beneath the box, and I rode away while he was still breathing."