Nancy was too nice to shoo the guys away, and Anna noticed Oliver was kinda hot. She left for the dance floor with him, leaving Harry and Nancy to talk for hours alone.
Nancy ended up sleeping with Harry that night.
A few months later, Harry got down on one knee and said the three magical words. Nancy said yes almost immediately, and they kissed. Everything was perfect.
"They're going to love you," Harry told her as they stood on his parents' front porch a few days later.
The door opened, accompanied by a booming voice, and Harry's mother, Miriam, hugged him with open arms.
''Dad, this is my fiancée,'' Harry said as he stepped back from his father only to reveal… Robert.
Nancy and Robert decided to keep the secret of the one-night stand between themselves.
Present-day…
"Tell me, Dad!" Harry exploded. "How is it that our pediatrician of several years had to tell MY SONS are my SIBLINGS? How did it happen?"
"It happened in Vegas," Robert sighed, defeated.
"Grandpa is our father?" Josh asked. They all turned in horror to the doorway, where the twins and their friend, Bobby, stood.