Helen paused.
"Is there any indication that the passenger's assignment was changed manually?"
"Not according to the records we've seen," Robert answered.
"Then I'll verify the audit trail independently."
The call ended.
David returned to his son.
Malik had begun drawing in his notebook.
He had sketched the outline of an airplane wing and was adding small clouds beneath it. His concentration was imperfect, but the familiar activity seemed to be helping him recover.
David sat beside him.
"What are you drawing?"
"The plane."
"Looks good."
"I'm trying to make the wing look right."
David studied the page.
"I think you're getting there."
Malik added another line.
Then he asked, "Dad?"
"Yes?"
"Are you going to fire her?"
David did not answer immediately.
He understood why Malik was asking.
From a child's perspective, the situation appeared straightforward. Catherine had done something cruel. His father had arrived. His father had the power to punish her.
But David wanted Malik to understand that authority carried responsibilities beyond retaliation.
"I don't know yet," he said honestly.
Malik looked up.
"Why not?"
"Because I need to understand what happened, and the company needs to follow a fair process."
"But she threw my bag."
"Yes. And that was wrong."
"She told me to move even though my ticket was right."
"Yes."
"So why don't you know?"
David leaned forward.
"Because doing the right thing isn't always the same as doing the fastest thing. If I punish someone without understanding the full situation, I could make another mistake. But if the evidence shows that she deliberately mistreated you, there will be consequences."
Malik thought about that.
"Even if she says sorry?"
"An apology matters. It doesn't automatically erase what happened."
Malik lowered his eyes to his drawing.
"I don't want her to lose everything."
David was quiet for a moment.
That response told him something important about his son.
Malik was hurt, but he was not looking for revenge.
He wanted the humiliation to stop. He wanted an explanation. He wanted to know that another child would not have to endure the same experience.
David put an arm around his shoulders.
"That's a good thing to care about."
"Can the airline teach her to be nicer?"
"Perhaps. But this is about more than being nice. People who work for the airline have to follow rules that protect passengers. They have to treat people fairly, and they have to be honest when something goes wrong."
"Even if the passenger is annoying?"
David smiled slightly.
"Especially then."
Across the aisle, Thomas Reed had been listening without appearing to do so.
He folded his newspaper and looked toward them.
"Your son has a good head on his shoulders," he told David.
"Thank you."
Thomas glanced at Malik.
"I've seen adults behave worse than that child did today."
Malik gave a small, uncertain smile.
Thomas continued, "And I've seen companies spend millions of dollars telling the public how much they care about customers, then ignore the people standing right in front of them."
David met his eyes.
"That's something we're going to examine."
Thomas nodded.
"I hope you do."
A few minutes later, Helen Brooks called again.
"The initial camera review is complete," she said.
"What did you find?" Robert asked.
"The footage shows Ms. Ward approaching the boy and speaking to him. It shows her reaching beneath the seat, removing his backpack, and placing it in the aisle."
"Does it show whether the boy was behaving aggressively?" David asked.
"It shows him remaining seated and holding a document. He does not appear to threaten or strike anyone."
"Can we hear the conversation?"
"The camera does not record clear audio. We'll need witness statements for the precise wording."
"Understood."
Helen continued, "There is something else. We checked the reservation audit log. Ms. Ward accessed the passenger manifest before boarding was completed."
Robert frowned.
"That's normal."
"Yes. But the timing matters. She viewed the manifest after the boy had scanned his boarding pass. The system displayed his assigned seat correctly."
David looked at Catherine.
She was standing several feet away, speaking quietly to another crew member.
"Was there any attempted seat change?" he asked.
"No."
"Any note indicating a safety concern?"
"No."
"Any indication that the passenger was ineligible for the seat?"
"No."
"Then the system gave her the information she needed."
"Correct."
David nodded.
"Thank you, Helen. Preserve the original footage, the access logs, and the audit history. I don't want anyone editing or deleting anything."
"We'll place the records under preservation procedures."
When the call ended, Robert appeared visibly uncomfortable.
He had worked alongside David for years and knew that the chairman was not easily distracted by dramatic explanations.
The facts were becoming difficult to avoid.
Catherine had access to the reservation system.
The reservation system confirmed Malik's seat.
No safety concern had been recorded.
No reassignment had been made.
Yet she had insisted that the child move.
Robert approached Catherine.
"Ms. Ward, I'd like you to accompany me to the galley for a private discussion."
She looked toward David.
"Am I being removed from duty?"
"For the moment, I need to understand your account of the incident."
"This is ridiculous."
Robert lowered his voice.
"Please."