"I have to go."
"Where?"
"Somewhere I cannot take you."
"Why?"
He had looked toward the window.
Then back at her.
"If I don't come back before morning, listen carefully."
Clara had nodded.
"Trust no one who tells you they know what happened to me."
She had frowned.
"Not even Sheriff Rusk?"
Silas had gone completely still.
A long silence followed.
Then he whispered:
"Especially not him."
Clara had forgotten those words for years.
Or perhaps she had simply buried them.
Now they came rushing back.
A voice spoke behind her.
"You look like you've seen a ghost."
Clara turned.
Sheriff Amos Rusk stood there.
He was a large man with silver hair and a thick mustache. He had been sheriff of Red Creek for as long as Clara could remember.
He had also raised her after her father's disappearance.
To the town, Rusk was dependable.
Kind.
Almost fatherly.
Clara had once believed that too.
She quickly closed her hand around the button.
"Just a customer."
Rusk looked toward the empty stall.
"That customer bought everything?"
"Yes."
"Paid too much?"
Clara hesitated.
"Perhaps."
Rusk's eyes moved toward the road.
"Who was he?"
"I don't know."
"You didn't ask?"
"I did."
"And?"
"He left."
Rusk smiled.
"Strange men often bring trouble."
Clara forced herself to smile.
"I'll remember that."
"You should go home before dark."
Rusk walked away.
But before turning the corner, he glanced back.
His eyes fell on Clara's closed fist.
She knew he had seen something.
She waited until he disappeared.
Then she looked at the silver button again.
Her heart began to pound.
Twenty years.
One button.
And a stranger who knew her father's pies.
That evening, Clara locked herself inside her rented room.
She pulled an old wooden chest from beneath her bed.
Inside lay two dresses, a child's wooden horse, several letters, and a folded gray coat.
Her father's coat.
She spread it across the floor.
Then she examined the buttons.
One was missing.
Exactly one.
Clara sat down hard.
The stranger had not simply bought her pies.
He had returned something that had belonged to Silas Whitmore.
Something that had disappeared the same night her father vanished.
For the first time in twenty years, Clara allowed herself to consider a possibility she had never dared to imagine.
Maybe her father had not died that night.
Maybe he had survived.
And maybe someone had finally come back to tell her the truth.
Clara barely slept.
She spent most of the night sitting beside the window, the silver button resting in her palm.
Outside, Red Creek settled beneath the darkness.
The saloon eventually went quiet.
The blacksmith's forge stopped glowing.
The horses became still.
Even the wind seemed to disappear.
But Clara's mind refused to rest.
At eleven thirty, she noticed something scratched into the reverse side of the button.
She moved closer to the lamp.
Three words.
MIDNIGHT.
OLD MILL.
She read them twice.
Then a third time.
Her first thought was that it was a trap.
Her second was that she should tell Sheriff Rusk.
Her third reminded her why she could not.
Especially not him.
Clara put on her dark cloak.
She slipped the button into her pocket and left through the back door of Mrs. Hale's laundry.
The streets were empty.
She crossed the dry creek bed and followed the abandoned road north.
The old mill stood beyond a field of dead grass.
It had not operated in fifteen years.
The wooden wheel had rotted beside the river, and one wall leaned dangerously toward the water.
Clara stopped twenty yards away.
There was light inside.
A lantern.
Her heart hammered.
She approached the door.
It was open.
"Hello?"
No answer.
She stepped inside.
The stranger stood beside an old grinding stone.
He had removed his black hat.
Without it, Clara could see the full shape of his face.
The scar near his eyebrow.
The tired eyes.
The expression of a man carrying too many secrets.
"You came," he said.
"You knew I would."
"I hoped."
Clara reached into her pocket.
She held up the silver button.
"Who are you?"
The stranger looked at it.
"My name is Caleb Vale."
"How did you get this?"
His jaw tightened.
"Your father gave it to me."
Clara shook her head.
"My father died twenty years ago."
"No."
"He disappeared."
"No."
"Everyone says he died."
"Everyone was wrong."
The words struck her harder than she expected.
Clara stepped backward.
"Is he alive?"
Caleb lowered his eyes.
"He was."
Clara stared at him.
"When?"
"Six months ago."
Her heart seemed to collapse.
"Where?"
"Arizona."
She struggled to breathe.
"What happened?"
"He died in a small mining town near the border."
Clara covered her mouth.
For twenty years she had imagined finding her father.
She had imagined anger.
She had imagined forgiveness.