He Bought the Dying Filly for One Dollar. By Winter, She Had Returned Something the Prairie Had Buried for Thirteen Years.

Chapter 3

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

But Samuel cared less about pedigrees than temperament.

“A horse remembers kindness longer than cruelty,” he used to say.

The best mare he ever bred was Belle.

Chestnut.

Small.

Fast.

Double whorl beneath the left ear.

Reed crescent brand.

Belle gave birth to one filly.

Mercy.

Jonah gave Mercy to Rebecca as a wedding present.

Mercy vanished with Rebecca thirteen years ago.

Penny could not be Mercy’s daughter.

Too much time had passed.

But she could be her granddaughter.

Perhaps great-granddaughter.

That meant someone had kept the bloodline alive.

Someone who had access to Mercy after Rebecca disappeared.

The question was who.

At midnight, Jonah heard a noise outside.

This time he did not reach for the rifle.

He waited in the darkness.

A shadow slipped through the barn.

The mysterious auction-yard girl.

She moved silently toward Penny.

Penny recognized her immediately.

The filly gave a soft breath and pressed her face against the girl’s chest.

The girl wrapped both arms around Penny’s neck.

“Oh, Penny.”

Jonah stepped from behind a stall.

“So that was already her name.”

The girl spun.

A knife appeared in her hand.

“Easy.”

“You followed me.”

“This is my barn.”

She held the knife higher.

Jonah remained still.

“You knew her.”

“No.”

“You just called her Penny.”

The girl’s eyes filled with tears.

She hated them for appearing.

“I named her.”

Jonah’s pulse began pounding.

“Who are you?”

Silence.

“Did Silas Cobb steal her from you?”

The knife trembled.

“Yes.”

“Where?”

She shook her head.

“What does Harlan Voss want with her?”

At the name, terror crossed her face.

Jonah saw it.

“You’re afraid of him.”

“You should be too.”

“I’m not.”

“Then you’re stupid.”

“Been called worse.”

The girl lowered the knife.

“She wasn’t supposed to go to auction.”

“Where was she supposed to go?”

“To the bone wagon.”

Jonah stared.

“They were going to kill her?”

“Silas said she was useless.”

“Why save her?”

“Because she was mine.”

There was something in the way she said it.

Something fierce.

Something familiar.

Jonah approached slowly.

“What’s your name?”

“Nell.”

“Nell what?”

She looked away.

“Just Nell.”

Jonah studied her face.

Dark hair.

Gray-green eyes.

A narrow scar at the chin.

She appeared fifteen, perhaps sixteen.

Something about her bothered him.

Not recognition.

Something close to it.

Like hearing a melody through a wall.

“Where are your parents?”

“Dead.”

“I’m sorry.”

“No, you’re not.”

“I know something about dead people.”

She looked directly at him.

“I know.”

The words landed strangely.

Before Jonah could ask what she meant, Nell reached beneath her coat and removed a small leather pouch.

She threw it at his feet.

“Don’t open that until I’m gone.”

Jonah bent to pick it up.

When he looked up, she was running.

“Nell!”

The barn door slammed.

He chased her into the night.

By the time Jonah reached the yard, a horse was already galloping toward the trees.

He returned to the barn.

The pouch lay in his hand.

Inside was a silver thimble.

Jonah nearly dropped it.

Tiny blue flowers were engraved around the edge.

On the bottom were the initials:

R.R.

Rebecca Reed.

Jonah sat down hard against the stall.

Penny lowered her head.

For thirteen years he had possessed nothing from Rebecca’s final day.

No ring.

No coat.

No body.

Nothing.

Now her thimble rested in his palm.

And a frightened girl who claimed both parents were dead had just placed it there.

Nathan found Jonah awake the following morning.

“You look terrible.”

Jonah handed him the thimble.

Nathan stopped smiling.

“Where?”

“A girl.”

“What girl?”

Jonah explained.

Nathan listened without interruption.

When Jonah finished, the doctor walked to the barn window.

“You’re thinking Rebecca lived.”

“Yes.”

“For how long?”

“I don’t know.”

“And the girl?”

“I don’t know.”

Nathan turned.

“You do.”

Jonah’s jaw tightened.

“I don’t.”

“You’re afraid to say it.”

Jonah stared at Penny.

Nell looked fifteen.

Rebecca had disappeared thirteen years ago.

Impossible.

Unless Nell was older than she looked.

Unless—

No.

Jonah shut the thought away.

Nathan approached Penny.

“She’s improving.”

“She already had a name.”

Nathan glanced back.

“What?”

“Nell called her Penny.”

“Coincidence?”

“No.”

“How do you know?”

Jonah looked at the filly.

“Because Rebecca’s mare was named Mercy.”

Nathan waited.

“So?”

Jonah swallowed.

“Rebecca said if Mercy ever had a brown filly, she’d call her Penny.”

Nathan stared at him.

“She said it the week before she disappeared.”

Two days later Silas Cobb finally came for Jonah.

Not alone.

Three riders stopped outside the Black Creek barn near sundown.

Jonah stepped onto the porch with his Winchester.

Silas had the scar the auction clerk described.

Long.

Pale.

Right cheek to jaw.

“Evening.”

“Get off my land.”

Silas smiled.

“Harlan wants the horse.”

“She’s mine.”

“He’ll pay twenty dollars.”

“No.”

“Fifty.”

“No.”

“One hundred.”

Jonah almost laughed.

“For a horse worth less than oats?”

Silas’s smile faded.

“Give her to me.”

“Why?”

“Because Mr. Voss asked politely.”

“He told me to kill her.”

Silas’s eyes narrowed.

“So now one of you is lying.”

Jonah shifted the rifle.

“My property line is behind you.”

Silas looked toward the barn.

“Horse won’t make winter anyway.”

“She’s doing fine.”

“That can change.”

Jonah raised the rifle one inch.

“So can your breathing.”

The two riders behind Silas reached toward their guns.

Silas lifted a hand.

“Easy.”

He looked at Jonah.

Then smiled.

“You always were too sentimental.”

Jonah’s blood cooled.

“Always?”

Silas realized his mistake.

Jonah stepped forward.

“Did you know me thirteen years ago?”

Silas turned his horse.

“Ask your dead wife.”

Jonah fired.

The bullet struck a fence post beside Silas.

Horses reared.

Silas spun.

Jonah’s voice carried across the yard.

“You say her name again, aim better than I just did.”

Silas stared.

Then rode away.

That night, Jonah packed food, ammunition, blankets, and Rebecca’s thimble.

At dawn, he left Nathan in charge of Penny.

“Where are you going?” Nathan asked.

“To find Nell.”

“How?”

Jonah tightened his saddle.

“She rode north.”

“That covers half the territory.”

“Silas came from north.”

Nathan frowned.

“Harlan’s northern property?”

“No.”

Jonah looked toward the distant mountains.

“The old Reed ranch.”

The Reed ranch had burned seventeen years earlier.

Jonah had not returned since.

His father died the winter after the fire.

His mother followed two years later.

Everyone believed lightning caused the blaze.

The surviving horses were scattered, sold, or stolen in the confusion.

Jonah rebuilt at Black Creek, fifteen miles south.

He thought that chapter ended.

But when he reached the old property, he found fresh hoofprints.

Someone had been living there.

The stone chimney still stood.

The barn foundation remained.

Beyond it was a small hunting cabin Jonah barely remembered.

Smoke rose from the chimney.

Jonah dismounted.

His hand moved toward his revolver.

“Nell?”

Silence.

He walked closer.

The door opened.

A shotgun barrel appeared.

“Don’t.”

Nell stood behind it.

She was no longer dressed as a boy.

Her dark hair hung loose.

Without the cap and oversized coat, Jonah saw her clearly.

His breath caught.

Not because she looked like Rebecca.

She didn’t.

Not exactly.

But the way she held the shotgun…

The left eyebrow lifted slightly when she was afraid.

Rebecca had done that.

“Put it down,” Jonah whispered.

“Why’d you come?”

“You gave me the thimble.”

“You were supposed to understand.”

“I’m trying.”

Her eyes filled.

“Then understand faster.”

A branch cracked behind Jonah.

News in the same category

He Bought the Dying Filly for One Dollar. By Winter, She Had Returned Something the Prairie Had Buried for Thirteen Years.

7 Part