Someone had tried to force it open before.
"Silas."
He approached.
"Can you open this?"
He used his knife to lift the lock.
The drawer slid outward.
Inside lay a bundle of letters tied with a blue ribbon.
Evelyn lifted them carefully.
The first was addressed to Eleanor Crowe.
The handwriting belonged to a woman named Sister Catherine.
Evelyn unfolded it.
Dear Mrs. Crowe,
I write concerning the child placed in our care under the name Rose Whitfield.
The girl remains healthy and has recently begun speaking in full sentences.
As instructed, we have not disclosed her parentage.
Evelyn stared.
"She was alive."
Nathan stepped closer.
"What?"
"Rose was alive after Eleanor was told she died."
She read the date.
March 1870.
Nearly two years after the child's birth.
Silas's expression darkened.
"Keep reading."
The next letter was dated six months later.
The child has been transferred to Saint Agnes under the revised name Rebecca Wells.
Evelyn felt a chill.
Saint Agnes.
The same orphanage where she had lived.
She turned to another letter.
Then another.
Each documented a transfer.
A changed surname.
A payment.
A new institution.
Until the final letter.
It was dated 1878.
Rebecca Wells has been placed with a private family near Denver. Further correspondence should be directed through the county registrar.
Nathan looked at Evelyn.
"Do you recognize the name?"
She shook her head.
"Not yet."
Silas examined the letters.
"She'd be around twenty now."
Evelyn looked toward the cradle.
"Somewhere out there, Eleanor's daughter may still be alive."
Nathan nodded.
"And she may have no idea who she really is."
Evelyn continued searching the drawer.
At the bottom lay a small leather book.
Inside were handwritten notes.
Not from Eleanor.
From Henry Crowe.
The entries recorded payments to county officials, transfers of land, and arrangements with private guardians.
One page contained a list of names.
Evelyn Mercer.
Andrew Bell.
Rebecca Wells.
Peter Walsh.
Sarah Finch.
Beside each name was a property description.
Evelyn stared.
"These children weren't simply moved."
Nathan looked over her shoulder.
"They were connected to land claims."
Silas examined the page.
His face hardened.
"Crowe used the children to gain control of their inheritance."
Evelyn nodded.
"And he did it to his own daughter."
Nathan looked toward the window.
"Why?"
Silas studied the documents.
"Because Eleanor's family owned land before she married Crowe."
Evelyn turned.
"What land?"
"The eastern silver claims."
Silas looked toward the mountains.
"Her father left them to his first grandchild."
Evelyn felt sick.
"Rose."
Silas nodded.
"Crowe couldn't claim the land while Rose was alive and legally recognized as the heir."
Nathan stared.
"So he made her disappear."
A silence settled over the room.
Then Evelyn heard footsteps on the stairs.
All three turned.
Doctor Warren appeared in the doorway.
His face was grave.
"Eleanor is alive," he announced.
Evelyn exhaled.
"But she's lost a great deal of blood. I can't promise she'll survive the night."
Evelyn looked toward the letters.
"She needs to know."
The doctor studied her.
"Know what?"
Evelyn held up the photograph of a baby found inside the desk.
"Her daughter lived."
Doctor Warren stared at it.
For a moment, his expression changed.
Not surprise.
Recognition.
Evelyn noticed.
"Doctor?"
He looked away.
"Where did you find that?"
"In this room."
The doctor closed his eyes.
Silas stepped forward.
"Elias."
Doctor Warren looked at him.
"There's something I should have told you years ago."
Evelyn felt her heart tighten.
"What?"
The doctor stared at the cradle.
"I was the physician who delivered Rose Crowe."
Nathan frowned.
"And?"
Doctor Warren swallowed.
"The baby was healthy."
Evelyn stared.
"Then why did you certify her death?"
The doctor's face crumpled.
"Because Henry Crowe threatened to destroy my family."
The room became silent.
Evelyn looked at him.
"Did you know where she was taken?"
The doctor nodded slowly.
"At first."
"Where?"
He hesitated.
Then whispered.
"To Saint Agnes."
Evelyn felt the floor shift beneath her.
She had lived there.
She might have known Rose.
She might have shared meals with her.
Slept in the same dormitory.
Walked the same cold hallways.
"Did she have another name?" Evelyn asked.
Doctor Warren looked at her.
"Yes."
"What was it?"
He lowered his eyes.
"Rebecca."
Evelyn pressed a hand against her mouth.
A memory surfaced.
A girl with golden hair.
A girl who used to sing while sweeping the orphanage floors.
A girl who had disappeared one winter morning.
Evelyn remembered her.
And suddenly, she remembered something else.
Rebecca had not gone to Denver.
At least, not willingly.
She had been taken away by a man with a silver watch and a black carriage.
Evelyn looked toward Nathan.
"I know who took her."
The deputy stared.
"Who?"
Evelyn's voice trembled.
"Henry Crowe himself."
Evelyn had not thought about Rebecca Wells in nearly fifteen years.
At Saint Agnes, children came and went so often that remembering everyone had become a painful exercise.