Several Apache elders sat beside ranchers who had come from neighboring properties.
Margaret Pike was there with Samuel.
Doctor Whitfield stood near Reverend Hale, who had insisted on leaving his bed despite his wound.
Sheriff Bellamy sat apart from the others.
His revolver had been taken.
His hands rested on his knees.
He looked like a man who had aged twenty years overnight.
Elias approached.
Taza stood.
"We must decide what happens next."
Reverend Hale nodded.
"Varrick still controls the town. If he destroys the mine, he may destroy the evidence."
Naya looked toward the mountains.
"And Matthew Bellamy may die."
The sheriff raised his head.
"Please."
His voice was hoarse.
"Whatever you think of me, my son had nothing to do with this."
Elias studied him.
The man had helped hide the truth about Clara.
He had threatened her.
He had allowed Varrick's crimes to continue.
But Matthew was innocent.
And Elias remembered the promise he had made to Samuel Pike.
Children should not pay for the sins of their fathers.
"We'll bring him back," Elias said.
Bellamy stared at him.
"After what I did?"
Elias's expression hardened.
"Don't mistake this for forgiveness."
The sheriff lowered his eyes.
"I won't."
Taza spread the map across a wooden table.
"The silver mine has three known entrances."
He pointed to the northern passage.
"This is the main road. Varrick's men will guard it."
Then the eastern tunnel.
"This passage is narrow and unstable."
Finally, the southern entrance.
"This one connects to the underground river."
Naya leaned closer.
"The same passage we used yesterday."
Elias nodded.
"The bridge is gone."
"Then we find another crossing."
Taza looked at his daughter.
"You are still wounded."
"I am healing."
"You should remain here."
Naya met his gaze.
"Father, I know those tunnels."
"So do others."
"Not as well."
Taza sighed.
Elias almost smiled.
He recognized the argument.
Naya had used the same tone with him.
The elder looked toward Elias.
"Will you keep her safe?"
Naya's eyes flashed.
"I do not need—"
Elias raised one hand.
"I'll do my best. And she'll probably save me twice before breakfast."
Several people laughed.
Even Taza smiled.
Naya gave Elias a look that promised a private argument later.
But the tension around the table eased.
They began planning.
A small group would enter the mine through the southern passage.
Elias and Naya would lead.
Two Apache warriors, Kele and Sani, would accompany them.
Bellamy insisted on coming.
Taza initially refused.
But the sheriff knew the layout of the prison chamber where Matthew was being held.
His knowledge could save time.
Eventually, Taza agreed.
The rest would remain near the ranch, preparing to defend the water trust and protect the witnesses.
Reverend Hale would send copies of the evidence to Santa Fe.
Doctor Whitfield would care for the wounded.
Margaret Pike would organize food and supplies.
For the first time, settlers and Apache families were working together openly.
Elias watched them.
It was a fragile alliance.
Built upon fear, grief, and the recognition of a common enemy.
But it was real.
And that mattered.
They departed shortly before sunset.
The western sky burned orange and red.
Elias rode beside Naya along the northern trail.
Behind them came Bellamy, Kele, and Sani.
The sheriff remained silent.
Elias did not attempt conversation.
There were wounds between them that words could not repair.
After an hour, Naya slowed her horse.
She pointed toward a distant ridge.
"Do you see that?"
Elias followed her gaze.
A thin line of smoke rose from the mountains.
"Campfire?"
"No."
She studied it.
"Too dark."
Elias felt dread rise.
"Explosives?"
"Perhaps."
They urged their horses forward.
By nightfall, they reached the abandoned silver road.
The entrance lay between two towering cliffs.
A cold wind moved through the passage.
Naya dismounted.
"We leave the horses here."
Elias followed.
He checked his rifle and secured the leather pouch containing the forged agreement and Whitcomb's evidence.
Naya approached him.
"Elias."
He turned.
"What?"
She hesitated.
For the first time since he had met her, she seemed uncertain.
"If something happens inside..."
He shook his head.
"Don't."
"Listen."
He waited.
She looked directly into his eyes.
"When I came to your ranch, I believed I might die before reaching my people."
"You didn't."
"Because of you."
"You would have found another way."
"Perhaps."
She stepped closer.
"But I want you to understand something."
Elias felt his heart quicken.
"What?"
"You gave me water when I had nothing to offer in return. Since then, you have risked your home, your safety, and perhaps your life."
He looked away.
"I couldn't stand by while Varrick hurt more people."
"I know."
She touched his hand.
"That is why I trust you."
Elias looked at her.
The moonlight softened her face.
For a moment, the danger ahead seemed distant.
"Naya..."
She smiled sadly.