Thomas stared at the Chief. "She was dying. I gave her water. When her fever broke, she left in the night. That's the truth."
The Chief leaned forward in his saddle. "Truth is a shadow. Hard to catch. My warriors demand blood for the white men who hunted her. They wish to burn this house to the ground and take your scalp to appease the spirits."
Thomas looked around at the sea of painted faces. He saw hatred. He saw a people pushed to the absolute brink, looking for retribution.
"If that was true," Thomas said, his voice lowering to a dangerous rumble, "you would have burned me in my bed. Why are you talking to me?"
"Because," the Chief said, "my daughter says your heart is good. I have come to test this truth. If you are a coward, if you act out of fear, we will burn you. If you gave her water only to save yourself from our wrath, you will die today."
A terrifying realization washed over Thomas. This wasn't just an execution; it was a trial. The Lakota valued bravery above all else. If he begged, if he pleaded for his life, he would confirm their worst suspicions about the white man's weak and deceitful nature.
A warrior rode up beside the Chief, holding a blazing torch. He looked at Thomas with pure venom, ready to throw the fire onto the dry wooden roof of the cabin.
Thomas took a deep breath. He let go of his rifle entirely, letting it lean against the porch rail. He stepped down off the porch, walking slowly toward the Chief and the warrior with the torch.
He stopped five feet from the Chief's horse. He looked up, his blue eyes meeting the Chief's dark, piercing gaze.
"You have five hundred men," Thomas said, his voice ringing out clear across the yard. "You can burn my house. You can kill me. I can't stop you."
He pointed a calloused finger at the warrior with the torch, then swept his hand across the front line of warriors.
"But I promise you this," Thomas said, his voice turning to steel. "If my house burns today, I will take as many of you to the grave as I can. Your warriors might kill me, but their names will die here with mine. I gave her water because she was a human being in pain. Not for you. Not out of fear. Now, light the fire, or get off my land."
The absolute audacity of the statement hung in the air. For a long moment, no one breathed.
The warrior with the torch sneered and reared his arm back, ready to throw.
"Stop!"
The voice rang out from the back of the war party, clear and commanding. The sea of horses parted once again. Riding forward on a beautiful white Appaloosa was the woman.
Thomas barely recognized her. She was no longer the dying, dirt-covered ghost he had carried into his cabin. She sat tall and proud in her saddle, dressed in stunning ceremonial leathers, her hair braided with eagle feathers. She looked like royalty. She was Elu, the Chief's daughter.
She rode up beside her father and looked down at Thomas. For the first time, he saw a glimmer of warmth in her dark eyes.
She turned to her father and spoke rapidly in Lakota, her voice ringing with authority and passion. She gestured to Thomas, then to the cabin, and finally, she pulled something from her pouch.