Which was why, on that last Thursday, the empty chair mattered. Mel had come in her work clothes, her training bag over one shoulder, the other shoulder held a fraction high in the way of a person performing the sentence I am fine and failing at the performance. She had, she reported, slept on it wrong two nights running, which in Mel language meant she had slept on it wrong one night and trained on it anyway the next, and now the shoulder had unionised. She would watch. She would keep score of nothing. She would, she said, heckle responsibly.
The room was filling the way it filled on open-mat nights in the autumn: the regulars staking out their squares of mat real estate, two visiting brown belts from Bangor unrolling their belts like flags, a father and his grown daughter arguing cheerfully about a sweep, the radiators ticking as the heat came up against the cold leaking off the harbour. Tessa rolled her shoulders and felt the day settle. In her bag were her mouthguard, her tape, her phone with the shift group chat muted, and a satsuma she had been carrying since Tuesday like a talisman. Everything in its place. She could not have said, and would not have believed, that the evening had already begun to lean.
Every academy has a centre of gravity, and at East Harbor, for as long as Tessa had trained there, the centre of gravity had a name, a ranked rash guard, and a following. Jared Whitlock was thirty-two years old, a black belt, the competition captain, and the single most talented grappler in the building. Nobody disputed the talent, which was part of the problem, because the talent was real and it arrived in the room about four seconds before the man did and stayed about four minutes after he left.
He had wrestled in college, in the years when wrestling still meant something in his family, and he carried the build of it the way other men carry an accent: the thick neck, the forearms like dock rope, the cauliflower beginning in one ear that he wore the way veterans wear weather. What wrestling had given him was a base you could not move with good intentions and a relationship with pressure that bordered on fluency. What it had not given him, Priya said once, in the tone of a woman reading from a file she wished were thinner, was any particular interest in the experience of the person underneath the pressure.
His competition record was displayed, because Jared had displayed it, on a corkboard by the water fountain: regional titles, a silver at a national qualifier, a photograph of him on a podium with his medal turned sideways. The record was genuine and the photograph was genuine and underneath them, in smaller letters than the achievements, were the other entries in his file, the ones only Priya kept. Two warnings in three years. The first for rolling through a visiting student's tap at a seminar in Bangor, an incident he had described, to Priya's face, as a misunderstanding about momentum. The second, the previous spring, for a heel hook finished with an enthusiasm the academy's insurance would have described in Latin. On both occasions Priya had done what owners of small academies do with their best competitor and their biggest draw: she had spoken to him seriously, in the office, with the door shut, and accepted the apology he was very good at making, because an apology from Jared Whitlock arrived gift-wrapped in self-knowledge. He could name his flaw better than you could. He was working on it. He had always just finished working on it.
The clips were the thing nobody had managed to speak to seriously. Jared's phone lived on a tripod at the edge of the mats on open-mat nights, angled like a small patient journalist. He posted to a channel with a name involving an apex predator. The clips were legal, in the narrow sense: partners in the academy had all signed the waiver, and the waiver's sixth paragraph covered recording in terms nobody read. But there was a difference, which everyone in the building could feel and nobody said aloud, between a competition highlight and what Jared posted. His favourite material was the last eight seconds of rounds with people who had no business being the last eight seconds of anything. A white belt from the evening class, folded. A visiting blue belt, a big earnest man from the Bangor club, caught in a triangle and tapping with increasing urgency while the caption made a joke about real estate. Tessa had watched one of those clips over Mel's shoulder in the spring and had not finished her coffee.