It was in that pressure, in the space between the review and his own pride, that Brandon made the decision that would bring him back to Natalie Brooks. He found her after a catering shift, waiting by the doors of the dining hall, his hands in his pockets, his jaw set in the way it always was when he was trying to look more confident than he felt, and Dylan Pierce and Caleb Moore were standing a few steps behind him, watching. He told her that he did not believe what had happened at the gala, that no quiet freshman girl could have handled him that easily unless it had been luck, and that he wanted a chance to prove it, in public, in front of people who could see for themselves. He said he wanted a demonstration, a real one, where she would show everyone what she could do, and where he would show everyone that he was not someone who could be embarrassed by a girl in a catering uniform. Natalie listened to him without interrupting, the way Aaron had taught her to listen to someone who was agitated, calmly, without reacting to the provocation in his voice, and when he finished she asked him, quietly, what he thought a demonstration would prove. He said it would prove that he was stronger, and she said, gently, that strength was not the question, and that she had never claimed to be stronger than him, and that a public contest would prove nothing except that two people were willing to fight in front of a crowd. He flushed at that, and Dylan shifted his weight, and Caleb looked at the floor, and Brandon said, more loudly, that she was afraid, that she knew she had gotten lucky and did not want to be exposed. Natalie looked at him steadily, and she thought about Aaron, and about her parents, and about Sofia and Liam and Grace, and about the circle she had started, and she knew that saying no outright would leave the question hanging over everything, and that saying yes without conditions would be reckless and wrong. So she gave him an answer that was neither, an answer that came from everything she had been taught. She said she would agree to a demonstration, but only under conditions that protected everyone involved, and that if he was not willing to accept those conditions, then there would be no demonstration at all.
She laid out the conditions plainly, in a voice that was calm and clear, and she watched his face as she spoke. It would take place in the campus gym, in the daytime, with mats on the floor and no audience beyond the people who needed to be there. It would be supervised, with Samuel Ortiz present as campus safety director, and with Helen Carter present as well, and with Aaron Levy present, because Natalie would not demonstrate anything without her instructor there to ensure it was done safely. There would be written rules, agreed in advance, and read aloud before anything began. No striking to the head, no striking of any kind to the face, no throws, no techniques designed to injure. Stop on signal, immediately, without question, every time, and either person could stop the demonstration at any moment, for any reason, without explanation. The demonstration would be about control and awareness and balance, not about winning, and it would end the moment either person signalled, or the moment Samuel Ortiz or Aaron Levy called a stop. Brandon listened, and his jaw tightened, and he said that those rules sounded like she was trying to protect herself, and Natalie said, evenly, that the rules protected both of them, and that if he wanted to prove something, he could prove it by respecting them. Dylan Pierce spoke then, quietly, for the first time, and said that the rules sounded fair, and Caleb Moore nodded, and Brandon looked at his friends, and something in his expression shifted, a small crack in the certainty he had been carrying. He said, after a long pause, that he accepted, and that he would be there, and Natalie said she would be there too, and that she would ask Helen Carter and Samuel Ortiz to arrange it, and then she turned and walked back into the dining hall, her hands steady, her breathing slow, feeling the weight of what she had just agreed to settle on her shoulders.