The document described a shared arrangement involving land, water rights, hunting grounds, and access to timber.
Names appeared in two columns.
Some belonged to settlers.
Others belonged to families from the northern valley.
At the bottom were several signatures.
One belonged to his father.
Another belonged to a man named Thomas Red Elk.
Ethan recognized the name.
Thomas Red Elk had been Aiyana and Kip's grandfather.
The documents were real.
And if they were accepted as evidence, Harlan's claims to the land could collapse.
Ethan turned another page.
There was a map.
It showed the northern valley, the creek, the old trading post, and a large section of timberland extending toward the railway corridor.
Several boundaries had been marked in red ink.
A note appeared in the margin.
Original record retained at Blackwater Trading Post.
Ethan frowned.
Kip had said the documents were hidden near the old trading post.
Perhaps the papers in the chest were copies.
Perhaps the original agreements remained there.
He reached for the leather journal.
Its pages were filled with his father's handwriting.
He opened it near the middle.
The entries described meetings, disputes, payments, and conversations with various men.
Then he found a name that made his stomach tighten.
Caleb Rusk.
The entry was dated September 12, 1879.
Rusk came to the cabin today. Harlan sent him to ask whether I had changed my mind. He said the valley would soon belong to men who understood progress.
I told him that progress without honesty is merely theft.
Rusk laughed.
He said I should remember that a man can lose more than land.
Ethan closed the journal.
The cellar seemed suddenly colder.
He remembered his father's death.
The official explanation had been that Samuel Cole had suffered a fall while repairing a section of fencing.
But Ethan had never been entirely satisfied with that account.
His father had been strong, careful, and experienced.
He had not been the sort of man to fall from a fence.
Ethan looked again at the journal.
A terrible possibility began forming in his mind.
What if his father's death had not been an accident?
What if Harlan had been involved?
He sat motionless for several minutes.
Then he heard something.
A sound from upstairs.
A floorboard creaked.
Ethan immediately extinguished the lantern.
He listened.
Another creak.
Then the faint scrape of a boot against the floor.
Someone was inside the cabin.
He reached for the revolver at his belt.
The cellar entrance was partially concealed, but not enough to hide him if someone looked directly down.
He moved quietly toward the stairs.
A man's voice came from above.
"Mr. Cole?"
Ethan recognized it.
Silas Harlan.
He climbed the final steps without making a sound and stopped just beneath the trapdoor.
Harlan continued.
"I know you're here."
Ethan tightened his grip on the revolver.
A second voice spoke.
"Should we check the cellar?"
It was Caleb Rusk.
Ethan felt his blood turn cold.
Harlan answered calmly.
"Not yet."
Footsteps crossed the room.
Then came a familiar sound.
The scrape of a chair being pulled away from the table.
Harlan sighed.
"I had hoped we could settle this without unnecessary difficulty, Ethan."
Ethan said nothing.
Harlan continued.
"Your father was a stubborn man. I always admired that about him, although it made him difficult to deal with."
Ethan's jaw tightened.
"Unfortunately, stubbornness has consequences."
The footsteps stopped near the cellar entrance.
Harlan's voice became quieter.
"Come upstairs, Ethan. We need to discuss what your father left behind."
Ethan raised the revolver.
He had spent seven years believing his father's death was an unfortunate accident.
Now the man who might have ordered it was standing above him.
And he had come looking for the chest.
Ethan stood beneath the trapdoor, revolver in hand, listening to the two men above him.
He knew the cabin better than either of them. He knew which floorboards creaked, which windows stuck in their frames, and where his father had once hidden a spare rifle beneath the kitchen floor.
But familiarity did not guarantee safety.
There were two armed men upstairs.
And he had no idea whether others waited outside.
"Mr. Cole?" Harlan called again.
Ethan remained still.
A chair scraped across the floor.
"Perhaps I should explain something," Harlan continued. "Your father and I had a disagreement many years ago. It was unfortunate, but business disagreements happen."
Ethan felt his grip tighten.
"Your father made certain promises. He broke them. I simply want what was promised to me."
A second voice interrupted.
"Boss, I think he's downstairs."
Rusk.
Ethan heard the faint movement of boots approaching the cellar entrance.
He stepped backward.
The chest stood behind him, its lid open and its contents exposed. He quickly gathered the most important papers, wrapped them in the oilcloth, and placed the bundle inside his coat.