The second week after the first jokes in the cafeteria did not feel like a new week at all to Lena Morales. It felt like the same day stretched thin and then stretched again, until the light in the hallways at Cedar Grove High School seemed too bright and the noise between classes seemed too close. She had told herself on Monday morning, while she shelved returned books in the library before first period and tried to keep her hands steady, that if she did not react, the attention would move on. She had practiced that idea the way she practiced everything else, quietly and without announcing it, by keeping her eyes on her sky notebook when Derek Vaughn passed her table and by answering only when a teacher spoke directly to her. By Tuesday she understood that silence was not the same as invisibility, and by Wednesday she understood that Derek Vaughn had learned how to use her silence as a kind of stage. He did not need her to answer him. He needed only for other people to watch her not answer, and for that watching to feel like permission.
It started again at lunch, not with a shove or a shout, but with a chair pulled a little too close. Lena had chosen the end of a long table near the windows because the light there made it easier to read her notes, and because the table was usually half empty at that hour. She had her sandwich in its paper wrapping, her water bottle, and her sky notebook open to a page where she had sketched the path of a comet she had been following in the astronomy club's borrowed telescope data. She was copying numbers carefully when she heard the scrape of a chair, and then another, and then the low sound of someone settling in as if the space beside her had always belonged to him. Derek Vaughn sat down without asking, turned his tray sideways so that it crowded the edge of her notebook, and began talking to Owen Price and Sam Keller as if Lena were a prop placed between them for convenience. He talked about a video he had seen, about a girl who talked to stars because no one on earth wanted to talk to her, and he said it in the loose, laughing voice that made it possible for everyone nearby to pretend it was only a joke. Owen Price laughed first, a short laugh that sounded rehearsed, and Sam Keller laughed a half second later, quieter, as if he were checking whether the laugh was safe. Lena did not look up. She moved her notebook an inch to the left, away from Derek's tray, and kept writing, though her numbers began to slant.
The crowding was the point, she realized later, when she tried to explain it to herself in the library after school. It was not only what Derek said. It was the way he and his friends took up room around her, the way they leaned in when she tried to lean back, the way their trays and elbows and backpacks narrowed the space until she felt as if she were sitting inside a smaller room that they controlled. At lunch on Thursday, Derek arrived earlier, before she had finished unwrapping her sandwich, and he brought two friends with him, so that Lena was suddenly in the middle of a group that had not invited her and had not exactly excluded her either. They talked across her, over her notebook, about practice and about a party and about who had been embarrassed in class that morning, and every few sentences Derek would drop her name into the conversation as if she were part of it, asking her whether she had seen a shooting star lately or whether her notebook had told her the future. When she did not answer, Owen Price said that maybe she was listening to space, and Sam Keller added that space was probably quieter than the cafeteria, and the table laughed. It was not loud laughter. It was the kind of laughter that spreads because no one wants to be the only person not laughing, and Lena could feel it moving outward to the next table, where a few students glanced over and then quickly looked away.
She tried changing tables on Friday. She carried her tray to a table near the doors where a group of girls from her English class usually sat, girls she had spoken to before about homework, and she asked, as lightly as she could, whether the seat was free. One of them nodded, but her smile tightened, and another girl moved her bag without quite making room. Lena sat down anyway, because she did not want to make a scene by standing in the middle of the cafeteria with a tray in her hands, and for three minutes it was almost normal. Then Derek Vaughn walked past with his tray, slowed down, and said, loud enough for the whole nearby section to hear, that Lena must be collecting tables now, the way she collected stars. He did not stop. He did not need to stop. The girls at the table laughed, not unkindly at first, but with the nervous edge of people who did not want to be noticed noticing, and one of them said, "No, she's fine, sit," in a voice that was trying to be kind and also trying to end the moment. Lena stayed for the rest of lunch, but she ate very little, and she kept her notebook closed, because opening it felt like giving Derek another line to use. When the bell rang, she walked out with her tray and felt the strange, hollow relief of being alone in a moving crowd, where no one was looking directly at her and yet she was certain that everyone had seen.