Tommy Walsh was called in on the third day. He was twenty-nine, and he had spent years standing close enough to Dominic Riker to feel protected and far enough away to tell himself he was not really responsible for what Riker did. That story had worked for him until the review began, and then it stopped working, because the investigators had Reyes's notes and Doyle's statement and the statements of men who had paid, and Tommy could see, sitting across the table from them, that the space he had lived in was closing. He was not a cruel man by nature. He was a frightened man who had learned to be useful to a stronger man, and usefulness had become a habit, and habit had become a kind of loyalty, even when the loyalty cost other men their food and their peace.
He told the truth. He said that he had collected canteen goods for Riker, that he had passed along warnings when Riker wanted a man reminded of who was in charge, that he had taken a share for himself because taking a share made it easier to pretend he was a partner instead of an errand runner. He named dates. He named amounts. He said that Earl Benson had been the one who watched for officers and who decided which new men were worth pressing, and that Riker had been the one who decided what happened when a man refused. He did not try to make himself sound better than he was. He said he was tired of being afraid of Riker and tired of being afraid of being caught, and that telling the truth was the first time in a long time he had not felt afraid of both at once. The investigators listened, and they wrote it down, and when Tommy left the room, his hands were shaking, but his shoulders were lower than they had been when he went in, as if something heavy had been set down.
Earl Benson was called in the next day, and he did not tell the truth. He denied everything, calmly and completely, in a voice that sounded reasonable until you listened to the details. He said he had never collected anything, never watched anything, never threatened anyone. He said the canteen trade was a rumor, and that men who said otherwise were trying to settle old scores. But the review did not rest on his word alone. It rested on Reyes's notes, on Doyle's statement, on Tommy's statement, on the statements of men who had paid, and on the records of canteen purchases that did not match what men had actually received. Piece by piece, the picture held together, and Benson's denials began to sound less like a defense and more like a man refusing to look at a wall he had helped build.
What mattered most to Darius was not that Benson was caught, but that the process held. No one was beaten in a cell. No one was dragged before the yard to be made an example of. No one was punished because Riker had fallen and someone needed to take his place. The review was fair, and because it was fair, its result could be trusted, even by men who did not like the result. Riker was held accountable through the proper process. He lost his privileges, his movement was restricted, his role in the canteen trade was formally recorded, and his case was referred for the disciplinary measures the rules allowed. He was not humiliated in public. He was not made to kneel or beg or perform his regret for an audience. He was told, in a plain office, by people who followed the rules, what he had done and what the consequences would be, and he was given the same right to be heard that every other man in the building was given. That was the difference between justice and revenge, and Darius felt it in his chest when he heard about it, not as triumph, but as relief, because revenge would have made the yard smaller, and fairness made it possible for the yard to become something else.
Tommy Walsh was held accountable too, in proportion to what he had done, and he accepted it without argument. He lost privileges, he was moved to a different work detail, and he was required to take part in the counseling and the program work that Warden Marsh had made part of the response. He did not complain. He told Samuel, in the library, that he had expected to feel worse, and that instead he felt as if he had been holding his breath for years and had finally been allowed to breathe. Samuel did not offer him easy comfort. He said that breathing was a good start, and that what came next would be harder, because telling the truth once was not the same as living differently every day. Tommy nodded, and he went back to his cell, and the next morning he was in the gym early, waiting for the class to begin, not because anyone had ordered him to be there, but because he wanted to be somewhere that had rules he could understand.