“Facts need someone to put them where people can see them.”
Claire entered as he spoke. She looked at the papers, then at Maeve. “Are you planning to present this at the meeting?”
“Yes.”
“Without knowing the full financial picture?”
“I know the path is public. I know the loft is part of the agreement. I know the new plan removes both.”
“Northline could pay for the repairs.”
“Then they can explain how they will do that without closing the path.”
Claire sat down. “You make it sound as if people who support the plan don't care about the town.”
“I haven't said that.”
“You imply it.”
“I think some people are tired of waiting for the town to fix things. I understand that. But a new restaurant doesn't replace access to the water.”
Elias laid his hand on the map. “She is right about the access. We need to ask what the plan does with it.”
Claire looked at him. “You haven't seen the numbers.”
“Then bring them to the meeting.”
“I don't have them.”
“Who does?”
She picked up the map, folded it once, and placed it back on the table. “I have to go.”
After she left, Maeve watched the door close. “I don't want this to become a war with her.”
“It already became a problem when she asked you to leave without speaking to me,” Elias said. “But it doesn't have to become a war.”
He reached for the map. “We'll let the documents do the talking.”
That afternoon, Harriet Bell called. She had reviewed the harbor charter and found a second document recorded in 1936, when the town had granted the Rowan family permission to maintain the lower landing in exchange for keeping the path open. The agreement had been renewed when the boatyard was transferred to Elias and Elise. Any redevelopment that blocked public access would require a formal release from the town and the trustees. The release could not be obtained simply by purchasing the surrounding land.
“Northline may not know about the renewal,” Harriet said. “Or they may hope the town won't make it an issue.”
“Can they build around it?” Elias asked.
“Possibly. But the current plan doesn't. You should not sign anything until the planning board has reviewed the full record.”
Elias thanked her and hung up. He looked across the room at Maeve. She had been listening without interrupting.
“Your mother was very careful,” he said.
Maeve nodded. “She knew what could happen if people stopped using the path.”
“Did she ever talk to you about the agreement?”
“Not in legal terms. She said the shore belongs to whoever needs to get home.”
He smiled, then felt the ache of missing her. “That sounds like Elise.”
On Tuesday, Noah asked Elias to take a walk. They went along the upper road, where the wind moved through the dry grass and the sea lay flat and silver beyond the low wall. Noah kept his hands in his coat pockets.
“Northline contacted me three months ago,” he said.
Elias stopped. “About what?”
“They wanted an estimate for the marine systems in their concept plan. I did a little consulting. It was meant to be separate from the property. I thought they were only asking about power and navigation.”
“Did you know they were interested in our land?”
“I knew they were looking at the boatyard. I didn't know they wanted the loft.”
“Why didn't you tell me?”
Noah kicked a stone off the path. “Because I needed the money. I had three supplier invoices overdue and a loan payment I couldn't cover. They offered a consulting fee that would have kept me afloat until the boat job started.”
“How much?”
“Four thousand.”
Elias looked at him. “Did you take it?”
“Yes.”
“Did you tell them you could influence the sale?”
“No. I told them I didn't own anything. But they asked if I could introduce them to Mum. I said I would ask.”
“And did you?”
Noah hesitated. “I gave her the contact. I thought she would tell you.”
Elias closed his eyes for a moment. “You should have told me.”
“I know.”
“Did you tell them anything about the agreement?”
“I told them the yard was old and needed work. I didn't know about the access trust.”
Elias let the wind pass between them. He was angry, but the anger was not simple. He remembered Noah's face in the garage, the shame in his voice when he spoke about the failed business. He also remembered that money had made people do things they later called small. “You will need to tell the planning board about the consulting work,” he said.