HOA Board Called Cops When I Said I'm Not Under Your HOA — Didn't Know I Bought the Entire Block

Chapter 32

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Several weeks after the board meeting, the county called me. The woman on the phone did not introduce herself with a title I remember now, only with the careful, official tone of someone delivering a question that had already been discussed by people above her. She asked whether I would be willing to participate in the transition to a self-managed community, now that the old HOA had suspended operations. She did not say it as a favor. She said it as a practical matter, the way you would ask the owner of a piece of land whether he intended to keep the gate open. I asked her what participation meant, exactly, and she explained that the neighbors wanted to organize something new, something that belonged to the people who lived here rather than to a board that had stopped answering its own mail. I thought about it for a day. I thought about the folder on my dining table, about the map with the yellow boundary and the gray line beside it, about the officer standing in the sunlight holding my certified copy. I thought about Mara standing behind her portable podium, and Doug arranging his documents like a prosecutor, and Betty standing up in the meeting room to ask whether the HOA had been collecting dues to maintain land it did not own. I thought about all of it, and then I called the county back and said yes, with one condition.

"No rules built around fear." That was the condition, and I said it plainly, because I had spent enough time in Oakrest Meadows to know exactly what the old rules had been built around. They had been built around the idea that if you watched people closely enough, and fined them quickly enough, and wrote them letters on official letterhead often enough, they would stay in line. The new agreement had to be built around the opposite idea, or it was not worth building at all. I told the county that I would help with the transition, and I would keep the park and the trail and the hall open, and I would do my part, but only if the rules we wrote together were rules a person could read without feeling afraid. The woman on the phone was quiet for a moment, and then she said that seemed reasonable, and she wrote it down, and I could hear the pen moving, and I remember thinking that this was how it should have worked from the beginning, a person stating a condition in plain language and another person writing it down without arguing.

The meeting where we voted on the new agreement was nothing like the hearing on the street or the board meeting in the hall. There was no portable podium. There were no folding chairs arranged in rows facing a table. There were no documents arranged like evidence. People sat in a circle, or stood along the walls, or leaned in the doorway, and somebody had brought a pot of coffee, and somebody else had brought a plate of cookies, and the whole thing felt less like a proceeding and more like a conversation that had finally been allowed to happen. I did not run the meeting. Nobody ran it, exactly. Betty read the agreement out loud, one point at a time, and after each point she paused, and people nodded, or asked a question, or suggested a small change in wording, and the changes were written down, and we moved on. I sat there listening, and I kept waiting for someone to object, for someone to stand up and say that this was not how things were done, that standards were non-negotiable, that the neighborhood would fall apart without someone enforcing the rules. Nobody did. The people in that room had lived under the old rules for years, and they knew exactly what those rules had cost them, and they were not interested in building a new version of the same thing with a different name.

The agreement itself was simple, and I liked it for being simple, because simple things are harder to misuse. No fines without documentation and due process, which meant that nobody could be punished on the basis of a photograph taken from across the street or a complaint nobody had bothered to verify. No surveillance, which meant that nobody would be followed, photographed, or watched as a condition of living here. No authority beyond legally recorded boundaries, which meant that the lines on the map were the lines, and nobody could extend them with an email or a vote or a strongly worded letter. No threats disguised as community standards, which meant that a rule was a rule, and a warning was a warning, and nobody would be told to comply or else without anyone saying what the or else was supposed to be. No board member above the rules, which meant that the people who wrote the rules had to live under them like everyone else. Five points. I read them twice when Betty handed me the paper, the way I had read the violation notice twice on that Tuesday morning, except this time the words did not make my jaw tighten. This time they made sense.

News in the same category

HOA Board Called Cops When I Said I'm Not Under Your HOA — Didn't Know I Bought the Entire Block

45 Part