HOA Demanded Access to Marcus’s Private Backyard — They Had No Idea What Was Hidden Behind His Fence

Chapter 3

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Landscaping contracts.

Streetlight repairs.

A proposal for holiday decorations.

Then Richard cleared his throat.

“Next, we have a compliance matter involving 417 Willow Crest.”

Marcus sat straighter.

Patricia opened a folder.

“The board has received multiple complaints regarding Mr. Reed's property.”

Marcus waited.

“The primary concern,” Patricia continued, “is the excessive height of the rear privacy fence.”

Marcus raised his hand.

Richard looked at him.

“Yes?”

“I have the architectural approval.”

Patricia responded immediately.

“The approval is under review.”

Marcus nodded.

“Then I'd like a copy of the board's determination that the approval was improperly issued.”

Patricia frowned.

“We haven't made a final determination.”

“Then why am I being fined?”

Richard intervened.

“The fine is related to your refusal to permit inspection.”

Marcus looked at him.

“Where in the bylaws does the HOA have the right to enter my fenced backyard for an architectural inspection?”

Richard leaned back.

“Homeowners agree to reasonable access.”

“Where is that written?”

“In the governing documents.”

“Which section?”

Richard's expression changed.

“We don't need to debate every sentence.”

“I think we do if you're fining me.”

A few homeowners glanced at one another.

Patricia leaned toward Richard.

Then she said:

“Mr. Reed, the board has a responsibility to protect the community.”

“I agree.”

“Then you should cooperate.”

“I will cooperate with any lawful request.”

“We've made a lawful request.”

“Then show me the authority.”

Richard's jaw tightened.

Before he could answer, a woman in the audience raised her hand.

It was Evelyn Carter.

She had lived in Whispering Oaks for fifteen years and was known for rarely speaking at meetings.

Richard recognized her.

“Yes, Evelyn?”

“Why does the HOA need to inspect the inside of his backyard?”

Patricia answered.

“To verify compliance.”

“But the alleged violation is the fence.”

“Yes.”

“Then why do you need to inspect behind it?”

Patricia paused.

“There may be additional violations.”

“Such as?”

“We don't know yet.”

Evelyn frowned.

“So you want to search for violations?”

“That is not what I said.”

“It sounds like what you said.”

A few people murmured.

Richard raised his hand.

“Let's keep the meeting orderly.”

Marcus remained silent.

He didn't need to say anything.

The questions were beginning to spread.

The board postponed the matter.

Marcus went home.

The following Monday, another letter arrived.

This one wasn't from the HOA.

It was from an attorney.

NOTICE OF INTENT TO FILE LIEN

Marcus read it twice.

Then he called Lauren Brooks.

Lauren had represented him during the purchase of his house.

She was a property attorney with a reputation for being calm even when everyone else in the room wasn't.

She met him the next afternoon.

Marcus placed the entire HOA folder on her desk.

Lauren looked at the stack.

“You've been busy.”

“I don't like unresolved systems.”

She smiled.

“I remember.”

She began reading.

Twenty minutes later, she looked up.

“Who approved your fence?”

“The architectural committee.”

“Who was on the committee?”

Marcus gave her the name.

Lauren checked the approval.

“Interesting.”

“What?”

“The approval is valid.”

Marcus nodded.

“I knew that.”

“More importantly, it was unanimous.”

“So?”

“The committee approval predates Richard becoming president.”

“Does that matter?”

“It matters because the current board can't simply erase an approval because they don't like it.”

Lauren flipped through the bylaws.

“And this inspection request?”

“I can't find authority for it.”

“Neither can I.”

Marcus leaned forward.

“Then what are they doing?”

Lauren didn't answer immediately.

Instead, she asked:

“When did you buy the property?”

“Three months ago.”

“Did the seller mention anything unusual?”

“No.”

“Any easements?”

“There's a utility easement.”

“Where?”

“Behind the backyard.”

Lauren stopped turning pages.

“Show me.”

Marcus pulled up the survey.

Lauren studied it.

Then she zoomed in.

“Marcus.”

“What?”

“Do you know what this is?”

“A utility corridor.”

“Not exactly.”

She pointed at a faded line running behind the rear boundary.

“This was once a public access corridor.”

Marcus looked closer.

There were handwritten markings on the old plat.

SERVICE ROAD — PROPOSED

“What is that?”

“That's what I want to know.”

Lauren opened another database.

She spent several minutes searching county records.

Then she sat back.

“I found something.”

“What?”

“The original subdivision plan.”

Marcus leaned closer.

The map showed Whispering Oaks as it had existed decades earlier.

The streets were different.

Several homes didn't exist.

And behind the properties was a long strip of land connecting the corner of Willow Crest to another road.

News in the same category

HOA Demanded Access to Marcus’s Private Backyard — They Had No Idea What Was Hidden Behind His Fence

7 Part