It was not. It belonged to Marcus.
Every fine, every threatening letter, and every inspection visit had been built on authority that did not legally exist. Marcus sat inside his grandfather’s old chair for a long time. Then he called a property attorney.
Escalation and Injunction
When Marcus finished explaining the situation, the attorney remained silent for several seconds. Finally, he spoke quietly: “This is a good one.”
Marcus’s attorney sent a formal letter to the HOA. The letter explained that Marcus’s property was outside the association’s legal boundaries, demanded that every fine be canceled immediately, and instructed the HOA to stop contacting him as though he were a member.
A reasonable person might have expected Linda Marsh to step back. She did not.
Linda hired her own attorney, called an emergency meeting of the HOA board, and sent Marcus another letter. The association claimed that decades of implied use had established its authority over the property. Linda also argued that prolonged community use had transformed the access road into a public easement.
Then the situation stopped being amusing. The HOA filed a lawsuit seeking permanent legal authority over Marcus’s land. Linda was attempting to establish jurisdiction over his property before Marcus could formally challenge the neighborhood’s use of his road.
Marcus’s attorney was not concerned. “She has just made this significantly more expensive for herself,” he said.
They responded with a counter-filing. Marcus formally notified the HOA that, while the lawsuit remained unresolved, he was revoking all informal permission to use the private road crossing his property. He did not immediately block the road; doing so before the court ruled would have been premature. Instead, Marcus placed the association on legal notice. If Maplewood Ridge wanted to continue using the road, it would have to negotiate a written and paid easement.