The silence that followed was different from the silence at the HOA meeting. There were no residents waiting for an answer, no four men with a plan tube, no one standing in wet boots. There was only the board, the attorney, and a management company representative who could not explain why a repeated warning had been treated as a closed matter. Vivian looked at Diane and Marisol. They did not look away.
The board voted to issue a notice of non-renewal under the contract's required timeline. It would not terminate the management company immediately, because the association needed a stable transition while the drainage project was underway. The vote was not unanimous. One director, George Pritchard, abstained, saying he believed the company had been unfairly judged before its review was complete. Vivian respected his right to disagree, though she wished he had asked for the evidence before defending the company. The motion passed.
The decision had consequences almost immediately. Glenn sent a formal letter stating that Northgate reserved its contractual rights and disputed the board's characterization of the records. He requested that all future communication go through counsel. The regional director offered a transition plan but said the company would not waive the remaining fees. Lydia told the board that was expected. She advised them to maintain a professional tone and avoid public claims about misconduct. Vivian agreed. She did not want the neighborhood to mistake a contract dispute for the repair itself.
A week later, three bids arrived for the drainage work. One contractor proposed removing the wall and restoring the swale. Another proposed installing a larger underground pipe, which would cost substantially more. The third recommended clearing the existing line and rebuilding only the section that had been altered. Ellen Shaw reviewed each proposal and explained that the third was the most appropriate starting point, provided the camera inspection confirmed that the remaining pipe was structurally sound. The estimated cost was thirty-eight thousand dollars, excluding any additional work required by the county.
The board could pay part of the cost from the remaining stormwater reserve, but the reserve was not enough. A special assessment of several hundred dollars per home would cover the balance. The idea produced immediate resistance. Some residents said they should not have to pay again for a system the association had already charged them to maintain. Others said the repair should be funded from the general reserve. A few argued that the current owners should not pay for a wall installed before they bought their homes. Each objection had some logic. The association's documents did not provide an easy answer.
Vivian scheduled a budget workshop open to all residents. She asked Martin Hale to explain the funds and Ellen Shaw to explain the repair scope. She asked Lydia to clarify the association's legal obligations. No one would be asked to vote that night. The goal would be to show the options and receive questions. It was the kind of meeting Vivian would once have considered inefficient. Now she believed it was the only fair way to ask people to pay for a problem they had not created.
The budget workshop filled the clubhouse before the board had finished setting out chairs. Residents arrived with calculators, copies of old statements, and questions written on the backs of envelopes. Martin Hale stood beside a projection screen and explained the stormwater account in plain language. He showed the total collected through the assessment, the amount transferred to other operating expenses, the vendor payments, and the balance remaining. He made clear that the transfers had been approved in recorded board meetings. He did not suggest that the money had vanished. It had been spent on other association needs, and those choices had reduced the funds available for the drainage system.
A resident asked whether the board could recover the transferred money from the people who had approved it. Lydia explained that the transfers had been authorized under the association's budget procedures, though the board could review whether the decisions had been prudent. Another asked whether the association could sue the developer for the wall. Lydia said the county was still determining responsibility, and a legal claim would require evidence about when the wall was installed, who approved it, and whether the developer or a later owner had failed to complete the permitted work. She warned that litigation could take years and would not clear the channel before the next storm.