I smiled politely, wiping dirt from my hands. "Oh, hi Brenda. Nice to meet you. Actually, we aren't part of the HOA. Our property is just outside your boundaries."
Brenda’s eyes narrowed. "Nonsense. Every house on this street is in the HOA. You owe $1,200 for the year, and I'll need you to sign this agreement regarding our landscaping standards. Your grass is currently half an inch over the regulation height."
I laughed, thinking she was joking. She wasn't.
Despite me showing Brenda a copy of our property map, proving we were not in her jurisdiction, she refused to accept reality. To Brenda, our house was a rogue state that needed to be brought to heel. Within a week, the letters started arriving. They weren't mailed; they were taped aggressively to our front door.
The first was a "Warning" for having a pickup truck parked in the driveway overnight. The second was a "Citation" for our exterior light fixtures not matching the neighborhood's approved Tuscan bronze aesthetic.
Sarah, my wife, worked long, demanding hours and usually just rolled her eyes at the letters. "Just ignore her," Sarah said one evening, tossing a brightly colored 'Fine Notice' into the recycling bin. "She has no legal authority. It's just paper." But Brenda was only getting started.
The harassment escalated. Brenda began patrolling the edge of our property line with a measuring tape and a clipboard. I caught her one afternoon trying to measure the distance between our oak tree and the street.