Celia arranged a meeting with Arthur Wynn, the retired county engineer whose name appeared on the old project file. Arthur was eighty-one and lived in a small house near the river. He received them in a sunroom filled with binders and model bridges. His hands trembled slightly when he poured tea, but his memory of the drainage project was sharp once Celia placed the field report on the table.
Arthur said the county had required Mercer Civil Works to revise the east basin line after the original trench encountered groundwater and rock. He remembered the temporary bypass because it had been a practical decision made under pressure. He also remembered asking for a final as-built drawing before he would sign the closeout. The company had sent a package, but it did not include the field verification he needed. He returned it with a note requesting the missing material.
“Did you ever receive it?” Celia asked.
“I cannot say. I was moved to the highway division a few months later. My successor would have handled the file.”
“Did you approve the temporary branch as permanent?”
“No. Not that I recall. It was a temporary measure. The final route had to follow the approved plan or be submitted as a new revision.”
Arthur looked at the drawing again. “This is the problem with old projects. A decision made on a rainy Tuesday gets remembered as a permanent arrangement because no one writes down what happened next.”
Hoa asked whether the county had any right to enter her property. Arthur said the drainage easement gave the county and the association limited access to inspect and maintain the line. The abandoned monitoring route was different. It had been a proposal, and the developer was responsible for obtaining the necessary agreements before construction. He said he had never seen signed agreements from the eastern lot owners.
Celia asked whether Arthur would provide a written statement. He said he would, but he wanted to review the county file once more and make sure his memory matched the dates. He did not want to be quoted inaccurately. Celia agreed to prepare a draft for him to review, not sign.
As they were leaving, Arthur asked Hoa whether Daniel had built the pool. Hoa said he had overseen the tile work and built the pergola. Arthur smiled. “I remember him. He came to the public works counter once with a little model of the terrace. He was very particular about where the water would go.”
Hoa had not known Daniel visited the county about the pool. She asked what he had discussed. Arthur said Daniel had wanted to ensure that the deck runoff did not enter the storm-water corridor. He had asked for a separate discharge plan and had paid for a small dry well near the west garden. Arthur remembered approving the plan because it kept the pool project independent from the public drainage system.
On the drive home, Hoa felt a new kind of grief. Daniel had taken care to keep the pool separate from the old drainage route, and now that distinction was exactly what she had been forced to defend. She wished he were there to say something dry and practical about it. She could almost hear him telling her to check the level before trusting the line.
Linh reached across the console and touched her hand. “He would be proud of you.”
Hoa looked through the windshield. “He would ask whether I had the revised drawing.”
“He would do both.”
The company’s response to the preservation letter arrived in a thick packet. It contained the original drainage contract, a partial closeout binder, and several emails from the period when Mercer Civil Works was winding down the project. One email from the project manager said the temporary branch had been “left active pending final connection.” Another, sent three weeks later, said the final crew had been reassigned and the work would be completed under a future maintenance order. No future order appeared in the packet.
A second email referred to the monitoring conduit. The project manager wrote that the conduit had been installed “for potential future use, subject to access agreements.” A note from the developer’s attorney said no equipment should be placed until written permissions were obtained from the affected owners. The permissions were never attached.
Celia read the records aloud. “The documents establish that the branch was temporary and that the monitoring route was conditional. They do not establish that Mercer obtained the required approvals.”
Linh turned to another page. “Why would the company send these now? They make it look worse.”