I immediately contacted my own attorney, a quiet but ruthlessly effective property lawyer named
Harrison. I handed him my grandfather's deed, the official survey maps, and Margaret's
extortionate letters. Harrison read them over, a slow, predatory smile spreading across his face.
Margaret's attorney letter triggered what she declared an "emergency enforcement meeting" at
her pristine lakefront palace. I didn't RSVP, but I decided to attend anyway, bringing Harrison
along for the ride.
Her living room looked like a country club crossed with a corporate boardroom. It reeked of
vanilla candles and desperation. The nervous coalition of HOA members sat clutching their
violation notices. Margaret was at the front, clicking through a PowerPoint presentation.
"Property values are at stake," Margaret announced dramatically. "We must stand firm against
non-compliant residents who refuse to respect the rule of law."
I cleared my throat from the back of the room. "Excuse me, Margaret. I think we need to talk
about the law."
She glared at me, her face flushed with anger. "You are not a member of this HOA, Mr. Blackstone.
You are trespassing. I will call the police."
"Please do," Harrison chimed in, stepping forward and placing a thick manila folder on her glass
coffee table. "But before you do, you might want to review these documents."
Margaret looked at the folder like it was a live grenade. "What is this?"
"That is the legally binding deed to Pine Ridge Lake," Harrison explained smoothly. "Dating back
to 1942. It proves unequivocally that Mr. Theo Blackstone holds exclusive ownership of the lake
bottom, the water rights, and a ten-foot easement along the entire shoreline."
A collective gasp echoed through the room. Dale Pemberton, the wet-cardboard treasurer, turned
the color of chalk.
"That's impossible!" Margaret shrieked, snatching the papers. "This is a public lake! My property
line goes to the water!"
"Actually," Harrison continued, "your property line ends ten feet before the water. The dock you