HOA Karen Cut Down the Young Trees in My Yard — So I Gave Her a Lesson She Couldn’t Hide From

Chapter 3

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"With what?"

"With the people responsible for protecting this community."

I looked at the binder under her arm.

"Show me where it says you're allowed to destroy privately owned landscaping."

She didn't answer.

Instead, she said, "The association's attorney will explain everything."

"Great."

I began closing the door.

She stopped me.

"If you try to sue the HOA, you're basically suing yourself and your neighbors."

I looked directly at her.

"Who said I'm suing the HOA?"

For the first time, Brenda looked uncertain.

Then she walked away.

I watched her cross the sidewalk.

She never looked back.

The HOA board meeting was scheduled for Monday evening.

Normally, maybe twelve people attended.

That night, thirty-eight homeowners showed up.

Apparently, chainsaws were more effective than newsletters at community engagement.

The clubhouse was packed.

Brenda sat at the front beside the other four directors.

Harold Price, the treasurer.

Monica Reed, the secretary.

Paul Kim, the vice president.

Susan Lang, an at-large director.

Brenda looked composed.

Almost smug.

She had a thick binder open in front of her.

I had a much smaller folder.

She glanced at it.

I could see her trying to decide whether I had enough information to be dangerous.

The meeting began.

Routine items came first.

Budget updates.

Pool maintenance.

Parking complaints.

A discussion about holiday decorations.

Then homeowner comments began.

I stood.

Brenda immediately said, "This matter is under legal review, so the board should not discuss it publicly."

Harold turned toward her.

"Legal review by whom?"

"Our attorney."

"When did we authorize that?"

Brenda blinked.

"I contacted counsel as president."

"Using HOA funds?"

"Obviously."

Harold's expression changed.

I stepped toward the microphone.

"I don't need the board to decide liability tonight. I have three factual questions."

Brenda said, "Daniel, this isn't appropriate."

Monica interrupted.

"Let him ask."

Brenda looked at her.

Monica didn't look away.

I held up the first document.

"This is the final decision on violation HR-2217, dated January nineteenth. It states that enforcement regarding my trees was closed because the association failed to establish that the trees violated a recorded easement or an approved architectural standard."

A murmur moved through the room.

Brenda said, "That was before additional review."

I nodded.

"Question one. Was a new violation issued after January nineteenth?"

Silence.

Monica checked her records.

"I don't remember one."

Susan shook her head.

"Neither do I."

Brenda said, "The condition continued."

I looked at the board.

"So there was no new violation?"

Harold answered.

"Not that I'm aware of."

I raised the survey.

"Question two. Did the board receive a survey showing any of these trees were on HOA property?"

Paul looked confused.

"No."

Brenda said, "Survey boundaries aren't the only issue."

I continued.

"Question three. Did the board vote to authorize Brenda Whitmore to hire contractors to enter my property and cut twelve trees?"

Silence.

This time, it was heavier.

Harold looked at Paul.

Paul looked at Monica.

Monica slowly shook her head.

"No."

Susan said, "Absolutely not."

The entire room turned toward Brenda.

She straightened.

"I exercised enforcement authority."

Harold stared at her.

"You spent HOA money without a vote?"

"I used the landscaping maintenance account."

"For work on Daniel's property?"

"He was in violation."

Paul leaned forward.

"You told us the contractor was clearing vegetation along the common path."

Brenda turned toward him.

"That's what this involved."

"No," I said.

I opened my folder.

"The contractor's work order says otherwise."

I handed copies to the board.

Then the survey.

Then photographs.

Then the final violation decision.

The work order description was clear:

REMOVE NONCOMPLIANT TREES ADJACENT TO HOA WALKWAY — LOT 118. AUTHORIZED BY B. WHITMORE.

Lot 118 was my property.

Harold stared at the paper.

"Brenda."

She said nothing.

I reached for my phone.

She immediately said, "What are you doing?"

"Playing a recording."

Her expression changed.

I pressed play.

The room heard the worker's voice.

"You sure these are association trees?"

Then Brenda.

"Yes. Owner's been notified repeatedly."

The worker again.

"These look inside his lot."

Brenda.

"I'm HOA president. I have authorization."

Then the sentence.

"Just cut them enough that he can't keep them."

The recording ended.

Nobody spoke.

Brenda's face turned red.

"You recorded me without permission."

"The camera records my property."

"That's illegal."

Harold turned toward her.

"Brenda, stop."

She ignored him.

"You deliberately set this up."

"I installed the camera six months ago."

"You knew there would be a dispute."

"I knew people sometimes walked beside my house."

Paul leaned forward.

"Did you tell the contractor the board authorized this?"

"I told them I had authority."

"The recording says you have authorization."

"I meant my authority as president."

Harold shook his head.

"That's not what authorization means to a contractor asking whether he can cut someone's trees."

Brenda looked around the room.

For the first time, she seemed to realize that she wasn't controlling the meeting.

She had controlled the neighborhood for years because people usually surrendered before reaching this point.

But now everyone had heard the same words.

Everyone had seen the same documents.

And no one could pretend they didn't understand what had happened.

Brenda tried another argument.

"Those trees were going to grow into the common area."

I looked at her.

"They were four feet inside my property."

"They would have become a problem."

"So you solved a future problem by creating a current lawsuit?"

A neighbor laughed.

Brenda snapped, "Nobody trespassed."

Monica held up the survey.

"Every damaged tree is inside his boundary."

Brenda stopped talking.

Then Harold asked the question that finally frightened her.

"How much did this cost the association?"

She looked at him.

"The contractor?"

"Yes."

"About twelve hundred dollars."

Harold opened his laptop.

"I don't see board approval."

"It was landscape maintenance."

"That account still requires two approvals above five hundred."

He looked up.

"Who was the second approval?"

Nobody moved.

Brenda didn't answer.

Harold stared at her.

"Brenda?"

The meeting was no longer about my trees.

It was about power.

And whether the woman who had spent years telling everyone what the rules were had ever bothered to follow them herself.

The board voted that night to suspend Brenda's authority to approve expenses or direct contractors pending an internal review.

They did not remove her as president.

Not yet.

I was fine with that.

Anger was not process.

Evidence was.

And I had plenty.

The next morning, the HOA's insurance carrier contacted me.

So did the association's attorney.

Her name was Andrea Mills.

Unlike Brenda, Andrea did not sound angry.

She sounded careful.

"Mr. Mercer, I understand privately owned landscaping was damaged during work commissioned by the association."

"That's correct."

"We're investigating."

"Good."

"Would you be willing to hold off on replacing the damaged trees until the insurer completes its inspection?"

"For a reasonable period."

"Do you have an arborist report?"

"Yes."

"Could you provide it?"

"I'll have my attorney communicate with you."

There was a brief silence.

"You have counsel?"

"As of this morning."

That was true.

I had hired Rachel Monroe, a property attorney recommended by a colleague.

Rachel was not impressed by drama.

That was one reason I liked her.

She spent the first hour reading everything.

The survey.

The photographs.

The video transcript.

The HOA notices.

The board minutes.

The contractor's work order.

The arborist's preliminary report.

When she finished, she leaned back.

"This is unusually well documented."

"I like receipts."

News in the same category

HOA Karen Cut Down the Young Trees in My Yard — So I Gave Her a Lesson She Couldn’t Hide From

7 Part