HOA Karen Cut Down the Young Trees in My Yard — So I Gave Her a Lesson She Couldn’t Hide From

Chapter 2

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Two years later, they were finally starting to be something. The red maples had put on real height. The dogwoods had bloomed that spring — white flowers, thousands of them, that made the whole western side of the yard look like it had been dusted with snow in April. Ruby the Japanese maple had turned a deep, ridiculous red in the fall that made Rachel gasp out loud when she saw it from the kitchen. Sweetpea the serviceberry had berries the cedar waxwings fought over.

They were asking their question marks, and I was watching.

The Porch

That Thursday morning, I took my coffee out to the back porch and stood there looking at the wreckage, and for a long moment my brain refused to assemble what I was seeing into anything with a meaning.

Six trees were lying across the grass.

Not broken. Not storm-damaged. Cut.

Three of them had been cut almost completely through — I could see the pale, fresh wood at the severed trunks, the clean angle of a saw's work, wood chips scattered in a fan across the lawn. Two more had been chopped near their bases, hacked at with something heavier, the cuts ragged and brutal. And one — Ruby, the Japanese maple, the one Rachel could see from the kitchen — had been dragged toward the driveway, leaving a long brown trail of torn-up sod across the lawn like a wound.

I walked down the porch steps. I don't remember setting the coffee down, but I must have, because I had my hands free when I bent over the stump of the largest red maple — one of the Three Brothers — and saw the tag.

It was a yellow plastic tag, the kind with a wire loop, tied around the stump. It read:

HOA COMPLIANCE ACTION

I stared at it. I read it three times. My hand was shaking, which surprised me, because my first thought wasn't anger. It was confusion — a pure, crystalline, almost academic confusion, the kind where your mind is turning the thing over like a pebble, looking for the side that makes sense.

Then I found the second tag, tied around the chopped base of one of the dogwoods. Same message. Same yellow plastic. Same wire loop.

Then a third, on Sweetpea the serviceberry.

Every tag the same. HOA COMPLIANCE ACTION. As if the trees had been cited, the way you cite a car parked in a fire lane. As if cutting them down was the enforcement mechanism, not the fine, not the warning, not the hearing — the saw.

The cuts were fresh. You could tell — the wood was still pale, the sawdust still bright, the bark still giving off that sharp green smell of wounded tree. Wood chips were everywhere, tracked across the lawn in boot prints I didn't want to think about yet. And underneath it all, the lingering smell of gasoline, the two-stroke kind, from a chainsaw. Somebody had run a chainsaw in my yard in the middle of the night, or in the gray wash before dawn, and cut down my trees.

I walked the length of the row slowly, the wet grass soaking through my socks, and I counted the stumps the way you count something you can't quite believe. One. Two. Three. The Three Brothers — or what was left of them, two of them felled clean and one hacked at like somebody had gotten angry halfway through. Four and five, the dogwoods, their spring blossoms still a memory in my hands from when I'd pruned them. And Ruby. Ruby was the one that got to me. Somebody had dragged her twenty feet toward the driveway — I could see the gouge in the sod where her crown had caught and torn — and left her there like a thing that had been used and discarded. Her little red leaves were already wilting in the morning air. Maya had named that tree when she was eight years old, her tongue sticking out with concentration as she wrote the name on a popsicle stick and pushed it into the mulch.

No workers. No trucks. No explanation. No knock on the door, no letter on the porch, no phone call. Just the stumps, the tags, the wood chips, and the sunlight pouring through the kitchen window like it owned the place.

I stood there in my socks on the wet grass — it was that early-morning wet that soaks through immediately — and I looked at the row where my trees had stood, and I looked at the tags, and I looked at the brown trail Ruby had left across the lawn, and something cold settled into my stomach.

Cooper came out onto the porch, nails clicking on the boards, and whined at the back of his throat. He stood there looking at the yard, his tail down, like he understood that something had happened here that wasn't supposed to happen.

"Yeah," I said. "I know, buddy."

Rachel was still asleep. Maya was still asleep. It was just me and Cooper and the stumps and the yellow tags fluttering slightly in the morning breeze.

I went back to the porch and picked up my coffee. It had gone cold.

Karen Holloway

Let me tell you about Karen Holloway.

Karen Holloway has been the president of the Cedar Brook Estates Homeowners Association for almost seven years. She lives at 8 Willow Bend Lane, four houses down from us on the same side of the street. Her house is the one with the shutters painted the exact shade of forest green specified in the community design guidelines — I know this because she told me once, at a block party, in a tone that suggested the shutters were a moral achievement.

Karen is the sort of person who could turn a neighborhood barbecue into an inspection.

I'm not saying that to be cruel. I'm saying it because it's accurate, and because accuracy matters when you're trying to explain how we got to six trees lying in my yard with yellow tags around their stumps. Karen knows which houses have unapproved flowerpots on their porches. She knows who parks too close to the sidewalk. She knows who painted their front door without filing the paperwork first. She knows these things the way a birder knows birds — it's not effort for her, it's instinct, it's the thing her eyes do when she's out in the world.

She walks the neighborhood every morning. That's her patrol. She has a particular briskness to her stride, and she carries her phone, and she takes pictures. Of what? Of violations. Of potential violations. Of things that might become violations if the wind changed. A fence picket slightly out of alignment. A mailbox with paint that has weathered past the approved sheen. A basketball hoop left in a driveway overnight. She photographs all of it, and she sends it to the board, and she keeps copies. Karen Holloway keeps copies of everything.

News in the same category

HOA Karen Cut Down the Young Trees in My Yard — So I Gave Her a Lesson She Couldn’t Hide From

20 Part