"Start here," I said, and slid the insurance declarations toward him.
The coverage was one point eight million dollars, updated annually. I had the declarations pages for the last several years, each one signed, each one current, each one showing that the car had not been some forgotten relic gathering dust in a garage. It had been insured, deliberately and consistently, at a value that reflected what it was. Jason read each page slowly, his finger tracking down the columns, and set them aside in a neat stack.
"And these," I said, "are the restoration receipts."
Three hundred and forty thousand dollars in parts and labor, spread over a decade. I had kept every invoice, every parts order, every shop bill, because my father had taught me to keep records and because, somewhere in the back of my mind, I had always understood that the car was worth documenting. The receipts told their own story if you read them in order: the slow accumulation of work, the long stretches where progress was measured in inches, the expensive years when the engine and the bodywork demanded everything we had. Jason flipped through them without rushing. He paused once, at a receipt for a set of original trim pieces, and looked up at me.
"You kept all of this," he said. It was not quite a question.
"My father kept most of it," I said. "I kept the rest."
Then the photographs. I had brought them in a folder, prints as well as the digital files, because I wanted Jason to hold them the way I had held them. Photographs of every stage of the restoration: the car as my father had bought it and kept it, the long middle years when it sat disassembled in the garage and looked, to an untrained eye, like nothing at all, and then the slow reassembly, panel by panel, system by system, until it was whole again. And in the middle of that sequence, the photograph I always came back to: my father, two months before he died, leaning into the engine compartment with a wrench in his hand, his face half-turned toward the camera, caught in the middle of explaining something. He was not posing. He was working. That was the point.
Jason held that photograph a little longer than the others.
"And this," I said, and turned my laptop toward him, "was shot three weeks before the destruction."
The video was short. The car was running. You could hear the engine settle into its idle, that deep, even sound that had taken us three years to get right, and you could see the bodywork catch the light as my father would have wanted it to — not flashy, just correct, every line where it belonged. Three weeks. That was how close the car had been to the end of its story when Christine had it dragged out of my garage and crushed. Jason watched the whole thing without speaking, and when it ended he did not immediately say anything. He just sat there for a moment, looking at the frozen frame on the screen.
The last piece was the comparable auction records. Three similar Shelbys, sold at auction in the past eighteen months: one point eight million, two point three million, two point four million. I laid the sale sheets out side by side so Jason could see them together, and I watched his eyes move across the numbers.
"Mason Torres did the appraisal," I said. "Thirty-two years as a certified appraiser. His assessments are accepted by insurance companies, auction houses, and courts."
Jason nodded. He already knew that, but I said it anyway, because it needed to be said out loud in the room where the case was being built.
"Two point one million," he said.
"Two point one million," I said. "And if you look at the comparables, he was conservative. He could have gone higher. He didn't."
That mattered more than I think most people would understand. An inflated appraisal is a gift to a defense attorney. It lets them stand up in front of a jury and say the victim is exaggerating, that the numbers are padded, that the whole case is built on wishful thinking. Mason Torres had not given them that gift. He had looked at three real sales, at a decade of documented restoration, at a car that ran and was insured and photographed at every stage, and he had come in under the top of the market. The appraisal was not a claim. It was a floor.
Jason gathered the auction sheets and tapped them into alignment. "This is good," he said, and for Jason that was high praise. "This is the kind of file that doesn't leave room for a story about a rusty old car. The paper kills that story before it starts."
I thought about Christine calling it junk. I thought about her saying it was rusty, an eyesore, something that lowered property values. The photographs were still spread across Jason's desk, and the video was still frozen on the screen, and the numbers were still sitting there in black and white. She could call it whatever she wanted. The file said otherwise, and the file did not blink.
Verified From the Ground Up
Jason's plan was not dramatic. That was the point, and I think he knew I needed to hear it stated plainly, because everything in me wanted to move fast and he needed me to understand why we would not.
"The case gets assigned to a detective outside our unit," he said. "Someone with no connection to you. No shared cases, no shared history, nothing a defense attorney can point to and call a favor."